Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-11981 · Session 2

Why its Comparative Study of Business Tax Revenue shows that business property taxation in Scotland is 17% higher than in the rest of the U…

Answered Asked by Murdo Fraser Con Lodged 4 Nov 2004

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive why its Comparative Study of Business Tax Revenue shows that business property taxation in Scotland is 17% higher than in the rest of the United Kingdom.

The answer

Answered by Tom McCabe on 18 Nov 2004 · 14 days after it was lodged, on time

Table 4.2 of the Comparative Study of Business Tax Revenue shows that totaltax revenue raised from business in Scotland relative to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is lower or comparable to most of our competitors with the exception of the United States, Ireland and Austria. This is reproduced in the following table:
Table 4.2 – Business and Transport Tax Revenue Relative to GDP, 2000
Country
| Revenues as a percentage of GDP

Corporate Income Taxation
| Employers’ Social Security
| Business Property Taxation
| Business Transport Taxes
| Total

Austria
| 2.1
| 7.2
| 0.2
| 0.2
| 9.8

Belgium
| 3.7
| 8.5
| 0.1
| 0.9
| 13.2

Finland
| 5.5
| 8.8
| 0.3
| 0.5
| 15.1

France
| 3.2
| 11.3
| 0.6
| 1.0
| 16.1

Germany
| 1.8
| 7.3
| 0.3
| 1.0
| 10.4

Ireland
| 3.8
| 2.7
| 0.6
| 0.9
| 8.0

Netherlands
| 4.2
| 4.7
| 0.6
| 0.9
| 10.4

Scotland
| 3.5
| 3.6
| 2.1
| 1.1
| 10.4

Sweden
| 4.1
| 11.9
| 0.5
| 0.7
| 17.2

UK
| 3.7
| 3.5
| 1.8
| 1.4
| 10.4

USA
| 2.5
| 3.5
| 1.5
| 0.2
| 7.7

Source: OECD (2002); GERS (2003).
As can be seen, revenue from business property taxation represents 2.1 per cent of GDP in Scotland, as opposed to 1.8 per cent for the UK as a whole. However, as the report stresses, comparing individual taxes in isolation is misleading. Furthermore, comparison of total tax revenue raised from business follows the methodology and definition used by the Confederation of British Industry in their paper, UK Manufacturing: Strategy into Action, published September 2003. Such a comparison reveals that the overall tax revenue raised from business in Scotland is 10.4 per cent of GDP, the same level as in the UK. This level is comp

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-11981 by reference.