Written Question · S2W-10998 · Session 2
What the findings were of the review conducted by the Scottish Children’s Reporters Administration (SCRA) into Munchausen’s syndr…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive what the findings were of the review conducted by the Scottish Children’s Reporters Administration (SCRA) into Munchausen’s syndrome by proxy and what action it intends to take as a result.
The answer
The report is being published by the SCRA today. I am placing a copy in the Parliament’s Reference Centre (Bib. number 33946).
Following the judgement of the Court of Appeal in England and Wales in the case of Cannings, ministers asked the SCRA to look at cases involving Munchausen’s syndrome by proxy and related infant deaths or conflicting medical evidence which might now be regarded as unreliable.
The SCRA examined 35 cases in detail. They were able to complete their examination of 32 cases. A further three cases might be affected by current court proceedings. The SCRA will return to these cases after those proceedings are concluded.
Although Munchausen’s syndrome by proxy was mentioned in some of the 32 cases, none was referred to a hearing solely because of a diagnosis of the condition. In all 32 completed cases, SCRA found that the grounds for referral were based on reliable evidence, and not solely on medical expert opinion that might be considered unreliable in the light of the Canningsjudgement.
In the light of the review, the Executive does not consider that any further work is required. I have however asked SCRA to send me its observations when the outcome of court proceedings in the three cases is known. SCRA will also contact ministers should any related concerns arise in the future.
Following the judgement of the Court of Appeal in England and Wales in the case of Cannings, ministers asked the SCRA to look at cases involving Munchausen’s syndrome by proxy and related infant deaths or conflicting medical evidence which might now be regarded as unreliable.
The SCRA examined 35 cases in detail. They were able to complete their examination of 32 cases. A further three cases might be affected by current court proceedings. The SCRA will return to these cases after those proceedings are concluded.
Although Munchausen’s syndrome by proxy was mentioned in some of the 32 cases, none was referred to a hearing solely because of a diagnosis of the condition. In all 32 completed cases, SCRA found that the grounds for referral were based on reliable evidence, and not solely on medical expert opinion that might be considered unreliable in the light of the Canningsjudgement.
In the light of the review, the Executive does not consider that any further work is required. I have however asked SCRA to send me its observations when the outcome of court proceedings in the three cases is known. SCRA will also contact ministers should any related concerns arise in the future.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-10998 by reference.