Written Question · S2W-09498 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-8682 by Mr Andy Kerr on 15 June 2004, what steps it is taking to ensure that evaluations by the Scott…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-8682 by Mr Andy Kerr on 15 June 2004, what steps it is taking to ensure that evaluations by the Scottish Assessors of non-domestic properties valued with reference to cost, as opposed to those valued with reference to rent, produce a like-for-like valuation with comparable premises in England, given that the Valuation Office Agency bases cost valuations on the cost of building a comparable modern building while the Scottish Assessors base valuations on the cost of constructing exactly the same building as is being evaluated.
The answer
The Scottish Assessors,who act independently of central and local government, base their valuations onthe cost of constructing a comparable modern property that provides the samestandards of quality, services and space as the property to be valued. In thecase of properties already of “modern construction”, valuations can thereforebe based on the generally recognised level of cost of constructing exactly thesame property as being valued. In the case of commonly occurring propertiesfrom an earlier era, costs are based on the comparable modern property.
In both cases, the same costbasis is used i.e. the cost of constructing a comparable modern property. Thiscost is estimated by reference to reliable average unit cost rates derived fromthe analysis of actual costs. The approach used is in harmony with ValuationOffice Agency practice and there is an established exchange of relevant costinformation and analyses between the Scottish Assessors Association and theValuation Office Agency to provide consistent cost bases.
In both cases, the same costbasis is used i.e. the cost of constructing a comparable modern property. Thiscost is estimated by reference to reliable average unit cost rates derived fromthe analysis of actual costs. The approach used is in harmony with ValuationOffice Agency practice and there is an established exchange of relevant costinformation and analyses between the Scottish Assessors Association and theValuation Office Agency to provide consistent cost bases.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-09498 by reference.