SPCB Written Question · S2W-09327 · Session 2
Whether the Presiding Officer has received any communication from Lord Fraser of Carmyllie regarding the publication of the report of the H…
The question
To ask the Presiding Officer whether the Presiding Officer has received any communication from Lord Fraser of Carmyllie regarding the publication of the report of the Holyrood Inquiry and whether that communication will be made available in SPICe.
The answer
Lord Fraser has written to me to request that his report be published under the authority of the Parliament (as was the case with the reports by Sir Anthony Campbell and Dr Raj Jandoo into the Chhokar case). One consequence of publication under the authority of the Parliament would be that any statements made in the report would attract absolute privilege.
I have therefore considered the request very carefully, and have discussed it with the First Minister as joint sponsor of the Inquiry.
We have been assured by Lord Fraser that the whole of his report will be evidence-based and that any individual who might be subject to criticism in the report will be treated fairly and will have an opportunity to respond to any critical comment before the report is finalised. Copies of Lord Fraser’s letter dated 24 June are available in SPICe.
On that basis, I have been prepared for a motion to be put before the Parliament authorising Lord Fraser’s report to be laid and instructing the Clerk to publish it.
I have therefore considered the request very carefully, and have discussed it with the First Minister as joint sponsor of the Inquiry.
We have been assured by Lord Fraser that the whole of his report will be evidence-based and that any individual who might be subject to criticism in the report will be treated fairly and will have an opportunity to respond to any critical comment before the report is finalised. Copies of Lord Fraser’s letter dated 24 June are available in SPICe.
On that basis, I have been prepared for a motion to be put before the Parliament authorising Lord Fraser’s report to be laid and instructing the Clerk to publish it.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-09327 by reference.