Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-06812 · Session 2

What its policy is on the commercial planting of genetically modified (GM) crops.

Answered Asked by Alasdair Morrison Lab Lodged 8 Mar 2004

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what its policy is on the commercial planting of genetically modified (GM) crops.

The answer

Answered by Allan Wilson on 9 Mar 2004 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

The Executive recognisesthat the public are uneasy about GM and that there is limited support for thecommercial planting of GM crops in Scotland. The biotechnology companies have yet to persuadeScottish farmers and consumers that there are real benefits to be gained fromGM crops. The Executive’s role is not to persuade people to accept GM products.Our primary concern is to safeguard human health and the environment. Ourapproach is cautious and precautionary. We will not allow the growing of GMcrops in Scotland where we have scientific evidence that theyrepresent an increased risk to human health or the environment.
We do not have thescientific evidence nor are there powers within the framework of Europeanlegislation to ban all GM crops. We must, however, maintain an active role inthe regulation process, subjecting each application to careful scrutiny and satisfyingourselves that any products which receive approval are safe.
In relation to thefarm-scale evaluation crops, our statutory advisory committee on releases tothe environment (ACRE) have advised that GM herbicide-tolerant beet andspring-sown rape should not be approved for planting on the basis of themanagement regimes tested under the trials. They have also advised that theconsent for herbicide-tolerant maize should be amended to restrict themanagement conditions under which it can be grown. We accept ACRE’s adviceand we have agreed with the UK Government a basis for pursuing the amendment of the maize consent at EU level. In the meantime no GM crops can be grown in Scotland.
The farm scale evaluationshave clearly demonstrated that there is no simple yes or no when it comes to GMand that it is sensible to assess each crop on an individual basis. Thiscase-by-case approach was further supported by the conclusions of the review ofGM science. The review panel agreed that a blanket approach to GM technology isnot appropriate. Nor would it be compatible with European regulation.
We should not dismiss thelonger-term potential of GM technology out-of-hand. Most people support thedevelopment of GM medical applications because they can see the benefits thesemight bring. We can be proud that Scotland is host to some of the world’s leading biotechnologyresearch and development and we should not undermine our future competitivenessby closing the door to the potential benefits of this technology.
But the Executive alsoaccepts that GM crops are not solely a scientific issue. We recognise thatpeople have strong views about whether or not they wish to consume GM foods. Itis therefore vital that consumers can exercise informed choice whether or not theywish to buy GM products. The new traceability and labelling regulations, whichcome in to force next month, will go a long way towards this. They will provide,according to Greenpeace, the strictest and most comprehensive labelling regimein the world.
In order to provideassurance that farmers will be able to meet consumer demand for non-GM producewe plan to establish statutory coexistence measures. We will consultstakeholders, including conventional and organic farmers, on the mostappropriate measures and on possible compensation mechanisms for those whosuffer financial loss. We will work with them to put these measures in placebefore there is any planting of GM crops in Scotland. In addition, we willwork with farming bodies to provide guidance to groups of farmers who wish toestablish voluntary GM-free zones.
A joint response by the UK and devolvedadministrations to the key issues raised during the GM dialogue has also beenpublished today. Copies will be placed in the Parliament’s Reference Centre.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-06812 by reference.