Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-34924 · Session 1

What decision has been taken in relation to the release of the report about Thomas Hamilton by DS Paul Hughes to the Procurator Fiscal at S…

Answered Asked by Tom McCabe Lab Lodged 17 Mar 2003

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what decision has been taken in relation to the release of the report about Thomas Hamilton by DS Paul Hughes to the Procurator Fiscal at Stirling in 1991.

The answer

Answered by Colin Boyd on 18 Mar 2003 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

Following the shooting of 16 schoolchildren and their teacher, and the suicide of Thomas Hamilton, on 13 March 1996 at Dunblane Primary School, the then Secretary of State for Scotland established an Inquiry under the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act 1921. The inquiry was chaired by Lord Cullen and the remit was to inquire into the circumstances leading up to and surrounding the events at Dunblane Primary School on Wednesday 13 March 1996 and to consider the issues arising therefrom. The inquiry sat for 26 days, between 29 May and 10 July 1996 and the whole proceedings were held in public and recorded by shorthand writers. The report of the inquiry and the transcript of the evidence are available on the internet at:www.archive.official-documents.co.uk/document/scottish/dunblane/duncntnt.htm andwww.scotland.gov.uk/library3/justice/dunblane/dunblane-00.asp respectively.In the course of the inquiry a large number of documents were lodged with the clerk to the inquiry and copies of all productions were given to those represented at the inquiry, including those representing the parents of the dead and injured. All of these productions were available for reference in the course of the inquiry and any issue arising from those documents could have been raised during the proceedings. In January 1997 there was a meeting between the clerk to the inquiry, and representatives of the Scottish Record Office and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. Following that meeting it was agreed that copies of all the productions in the inquiry should be lodged with the Scottish Record Office (now the National Archives of Scotland). It was also agreed that there should be a closure period of 100 years, because many of the productions referred to people who were children at the time. It was further agreed that these productions could be accessed with the consent of the Crown by those showing a legitimate interest. Lord Cullen was consulted and indicated that he was content with what had been agreed.There is no statutory basis for the closure of records created by Scottish public bodies. The Public Records (Scotland) Act 1937 (the 1937 act) makes provision for the preservation, care and custody of the public records of Scotland. The terms of the legislation are permissive. By contrast, in England and Wales the Public Records Act 1958 (as amended by the Public Records Act 1967) sets a statutory "closure period" of 30 years after which records must, with limited exceptions, be made available to the public. The 1937 act does not impose similar obligations on Executive departments, but in practice those procedures are followed in Scotland.The criteria for closures longer than 30 years were defined in the 1993 White Paper on Open Government (CMD2290), in accordance with which it is for the department responsible for depositing the material to decide on the closure period. In Scotland, the National Archives of Scotland cannot vary this closure period and cannot produce "closed records" to the public without the permission of the depositing department. The white paper sets out a clear statement of principle as to what information should be made available and what ought properly to be kept confidential in the public interest. Documents containing information about individuals, whose disclosure would cause either substantial distress, or endangerment from a third party to persons affected by disclosure or their descendants can be subject to a variable closure period of between 40 and 100 years. When the productions for the inquiry were lodged with the Scottish Record Office no effort was made to distinguish between productions making references to ch

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-34924 by reference.