Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-31405 · Session 1

When it was first advised of the outcome of the appeal to the Competition Commission Appeal Tribunal in the case of BetterCare Group Limite…

Answered Asked by Linda Fabiani SNP Lodged 8 Nov 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive when it was first advised of the outcome of the appeal to the Competition Commission Appeal Tribunal in the case of BetterCare Group Limited v the Director General of Fair Trading and what steps it has subsequently taken to consider the implications of the tribunal's findings.

The answer

Answered by Frank McAveety on 20 Nov 2002 · 12 days after it was lodged, on time

We were first made aware of the Competition Commission Appeal Tribunal's judgement on 20 September 2002. The tribunal's judgement in the case of Bettercare Group Ltd and the Director General of Fair Trading stated that the Competition Act 1998 applied in the particular circumstances of that case. The director has decided not to appeal that decision. One implication is that, potentially, local authorities' commissioning of care services could be subject to the Competition Act, but each case would need to be decided on its particular facts. The judgement did not comment on whether the North and West Belfast Health and Social Services Trust or, in our context, other local authorities, are presently contravening the act. The Office of Fair Trading will now reconsider the issue of the alleged anti-competitive conduct of North and West Belfast Health and Social Services Trust. I understand that the European Court is currently considering a similar case and that an outcome is expected by next spring. This may help to clarify whether the act applies to the commissioning functions of public bodies.Against this background, no general assessment has been made of the implications of the ruling and we remain in close contact with our counterparts in Northern Ireland and the other UK administrations on this issue.In the meantime, we would continue to expect councils to apply Best Value principles when providing or purchasing care services and to operate in full concordance with the spirit and terms of the Competition Act.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-31405 by reference.