Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-31242 · Session 1

What measures have been, or are being, taken to ensure that reports submitted by its Environment and Rural Affairs Department to the Crofte…

Answered Asked by Tavish Scott LD Lodged 5 Nov 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what measures have been, or are being, taken to ensure that reports submitted by its Environment and Rural Affairs Department to the Crofters Commission on the decision-making process over apportionments are fair and impartial; what monitoring takes place of such reports, and whether any appeal over the content of such reports is allowed.

The answer

Answered by Ross Finnie on 18 Nov 2002 · 13 days after it was lodged, on time

The Crofters Commission employs the services of locally based agricultural staff of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department to compile reports relating to apportionment applications. In carrying out these responsibilities, the agricultural staff are expected to take a fair and impartial view and follow guidance from the Crofters Commission. They apply their professional and technical judgement in assessing the information obtained through inspection and discussion with the applicant and other affected parties and aim to ensure that all aspects of a case are brought out in the report. At all times they are expected to operate to the Scottish Executive Aim, Vision and Values. Those values include integrity, honesty, objectivity, political impartiality and fairness. Reports are monitored and countersigned by a senior officer. There is also a system of Quality Management Checks whereby an office manager ensures consistency of standard and impartiality. These are random checks so the officer concerned cannot know which cases may be selected. In addition the Crofters Commission will make the report available, on request, to the person applying for the apportionment. A reporting officer may make a recommendation but the Crofters Commission decides each application and may or may not accept such a recommendation.There is currently no mechanism for an appeal against the content of a report made to the Crofters Commission by a member of the agricultural staff of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-31242 by reference.