Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

SPCB Written Question · S1W-30572 · Session 1

Further to his answer to question S1W-30288 on 18 October 2002, why the breakdown of fees payable to consultants involved in the Holyrood p…

Answered Asked by Fergus Ewing SNP Lodged 10 Oct 2002

The question

To ask the Presiding Officer, further to his answer to question S1W-30288 on 18 October 2002, why the breakdown of fees payable to consultants involved in the Holyrood project was commercially confidential, given that the breakdown of fees payable to Davis Langdon & Everest, EMBT/RMJM Ltd, Ove Arup and Partners, RMJM Scotland Limited and Bovis Lend Lease (Scotland) Limited was disclosed in the Auditor's General's report The New Scottish Parliament Building
- An examination of the management of the Holyrood Project (AGS/2000/2) and whether the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body considers that information on consultants' fees is in the public interest.

The answer

Answered by David Steel on 29 Oct 2002 · 19 days after it was lodged, on time

The SPCB regards the amount of fees paid to individual consultants as commercially confidential. Publication of such information by the Parliament would generally be considered as something that might impede fair competition between them and their competitors and/or prejudice the consultants', or the Parliament's, future negotiating position. Disclosure would also be in breach of the individual tender agreements between the Parliament and the consultants, which were agreed on a commercially confidential basis and could not be made without the agreement of the firms involved. I understand from the Convener of the Holyrood Progress Group that the Auditor General was required to obtain the specific approval of the respective consultants before authority for publication of the figures was given under the particular circumstances. The Parliament would not normally release such information unilaterally and that is only proper. It is the case that certain elements of fee agreements are still under discussion, however, once outstanding negotiations have been concluded and subject to clearance with the Parliament's legal office, we would expect to secure the agreement of the consultants involved and make these details available.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-30572 by reference.