Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-29204 · Session 1

Whether there is a fundamental incompatibility between the full and tasteful restoration of historic buildings for contemporary use and the…

Answered Asked by Rhoda Grant Lab Lodged 11 Sep 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether there is a fundamental incompatibility between the full and tasteful restoration of historic buildings for contemporary use and the ability to interpret such buildings for their historic interest.

The answer

Answered by Elaine Murray on 25 Sep 2002 · 14 days after it was lodged, on time

There is no fundamental incompatibility. However, a basic distinction may be drawn between the adaptation for contemporary use of an occupied historic building and the restoration of a ruinous ancient monument. In the former case, where the historic interest may lie primarily in its architectural design, there generally need be no fundamental incompatibility between the adaptation of the building and our ability to interpret its historic interest. However, in the case of a ruinous structure, where the interest may be more likely to lie in our ability to document its historic importance and use, the very act of restoration may hide the evidence that allows the building's structural history to be interpreted by visitors. By way of example, people living in a restored medieval castle do not normally wish to live within bare walls, but to cover these with plaster: this hides important evidence for the structural history of the building.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-29204 by reference.