Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-27777 · Session 1

Which appointments were referred to in page 8 of the Commissioner for Public Appointments's Seventh Report 2001-2002 "where the Executive h…

Answered Asked by Alex Neil SNP Lodged 19 Jul 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive which appointments were referred to in page 8 of the Commissioner for Public Appointments's Seventh Report 2001-2002 "where the Executive had failed to follow the Code of Practice in several key respects."

The answer

Answered by Andy Kerr on 29 Aug 2002 · 41 days after it was lodged, 13 days after it was due

My colleagues and I are absolutely committed to the delivery of a fair, open and transparent public appointments system. Arrangements are kept under continuous review and improvements introduced whenever and wherever appropriate.Neither the audit reports received by the Executive nor the Commissioner's Annual Report refer to individuals or specific public bodies. The contents of the reports are a matter for the Commissioner who is generally satisfied that the Executive complies with her Code of Practice. She has also made it clear that no appointment made by Scottish ministers was brought into doubt as a result of the audit and that the concerns expressed in her report related solely to the process adopted. Action taken by the Executive to address these issues is set out in the following table.Key Audit Findings | Action Taken by Executive
A sponsor team within the Executive failed to comply with the Code of Practice in several significant respects when making a number of appointments to an advisory NDPB. | All sponsor teams have been firmly reminded that they must comply with the Code of Practice.
Ministers not offered a choice of candidates | Sponsor teams have been firmly reminded that, if more than one candidate meets the criteria for appointment, ministers must be given the choice of who to appoint. If only one candidate meets the criteria for appointment, ministers must be given the option of re-opening the competition. Where re-opening the competition is unlikely to bring forward new candidates because of the open process that has been followed, this should be made clear to ministers. Teams have also been asked to ensure that vacancies are made known to as wide a field of candidates as possible. As part of the parliamentary notification system introduced in May this year, the Executive's Public Appointments Team sends details of all vacancies to all ministers, Parliament and a number of outside bodies. The team also maintains details of vacancies on the Executive's Public Bodies website.
Failure of an applicant to complete an application form | Sponsor teams have been firmly reminded that application forms must be completed by all applicants by the agreed closing date, irrespective of the circumstances.
Failure to obtain completed political activity forms prior to appointment | This problem was uncovered before the audit took place and the commissioner and her auditors were informed in advance. In response to this issue, I announced on 26 March action to centralise the appointments process. In addition, checks are now in place to ensure that the political activity forms for all appointees are completed in advance.
Lack of proper record keeping | Sponsor teams have been firmly reminded of the need to ensure that all appointments are fully documented and key decisions and actions are recorded.
Lack of central guidance | The Commissioner's Code of Practice and the Cabinet Office Best Practice Guide are already available to, and used by, sponsor teams. Guidance on specific issues is circulated to sponsor teams whenever necessary. Consolidated guidance on appointment arrangements is being prepared by the Executive. This should be available in the autumn and a copy will be placed in the Parliament's Reference Centre.
Performance Appraisals of appointees not conducted on an on-going basi

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-27777 by reference.