Written Question · S1W-27107 · Session 1
What factors contributed to the differential in quality identified in the recent HM Inspectorate of Education report, Standards and Quality…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive what factors contributed to the differential in quality identified in the recent HM Inspectorate of Education report, Standards and Quality in Scottish Pre-school Education 1997-2001 and in Early Education and Childcare Workforce Survey Final Report which highlighted that local authority nursery schools performed consistently and substantially better in the quality of learning experiences and that 13% of their staff have a teaching degree compared with 6% in the private and 5% in the voluntary centres and how it will ensure that quality will not be diminished under the new staffing guidelines.
The answer
Local authorities have had a long history in the provision of pre-school education through nursery schools and classes. By contrast, most private and voluntary providers have only recently begun providing funded pre-school education. The report found that overall standards in the private and voluntary sectors have improved during the last four years. This is encouraging for new players in provision. The report did not define the percentages of staff in sectors who had teaching qualifications and no causal link could be drawn from the qualifications of staff in the different sectors.The new staffing guidelines should allow all providers
- whether in the private, voluntary or local authority sectors
- to deploy teams of staff in a way which uses their individual expertise and enhances the quality of children's experience. All pre-school education providers will be inspected annually under the New National Care Standards by the Commission for the Regulation of Care. The Commission for the Regulation of Care will also be undertaking joint inspections with Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education, in order to assess the quality of pre-school education. These inspections should ensure that quality is not diminished under the new staffing guidelines.
- whether in the private, voluntary or local authority sectors
- to deploy teams of staff in a way which uses their individual expertise and enhances the quality of children's experience. All pre-school education providers will be inspected annually under the New National Care Standards by the Commission for the Regulation of Care. The Commission for the Regulation of Care will also be undertaking joint inspections with Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education, in order to assess the quality of pre-school education. These inspections should ensure that quality is not diminished under the new staffing guidelines.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-27107 by reference.