Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-26079 · Session 1

Further to the answer to question S1W-25026 by Mr Jim Wallace on 16 May 2002, how the obligation to secure best value can be fulfilled when…

Answered Asked by Roseanna Cunningham SNP Lodged 20 May 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-25026 by Mr Jim Wallace on 16 May 2002, how the obligation to secure best value can be fulfilled when it cannot compare the sensitivity analysis of the public sector comparator detailed in paragraph 2.2.4 of the PricewaterhouseCoopers Financial review of the Scottish Prison Service Estates Review with an equivalent model for a privately operated prison.

The answer

Answered by Jim Wallace on 10 Jun 2002 · 21 days after it was lodged, 5 days after it was due

The Pricewaterhouse Coopers report explains why the information is not available:Para 4.2:It is clear that it is not possible to construct a detailed financial model of the PPP Private Build Public Operate model with the same degree of confidence in cost estimates as it is for the PPP Private Build Private Operate and PSC options because of the absence of any benchmark data. To have an equivalent level of certainty in such a model, there would need to be a fully worked up definition of how the model would be implemented, stating where the boundaries of risk transfer would lie, with assumptions regarding the private sector's response to the brief.Consequently, for the purpose of this initial assessment of the PPP Private Build Public Operate Option, PwC's approach has been:(a) to consider in conjunction with SPS the key issues of risk transfer and operational interface involved in implementing a PPP Private Build Public Operate Option and the implications of these for the definition of the PPP Private Build Public Operate Option and for its deliverability;(b) to undertake an outline financial assessment of the PPP Private Build Public Operate Option based upon scenario analysis of possible financial outturns relative to the PPP Private Build Private Operate and PSC options.Para 4.6.5:Unless the PPP Private Build Public Operate option is more fully specified it is not practicable to develop cost estimates which provide significantly more accuracy than the scenarios outlined above.In addition, the report also concludes in para 4.6.5:However, the above analysis demonstrates that any PPP Private Build Public Operate model has a very substantial value for money gap to bridge compared with the PPP Private Build Private Operate option and also a requirement for major changes in the approach to prison operation and staff terms and conditions within SPS to reduce its costs significantly below the PSC. The lowest cost option, Scenario 4, which assumes the possibility of replacing completely the SPS requirements for a prison design together with a 20% reduction in operating costs, will still be significantly more expensive than a PPP Private Build Private Operate option.On that basis, the work carried out by PricewaterhouseCoopers fulfils the obligation to secure best value.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-26079 by reference.