Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-25239 · Session 1

Whether it will publish the annual accident figures for roads where route accident reduction plans have been implemented within the past th…

Answered Asked by Jackie Baillie Lab Lodged 19 Apr 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will publish the annual accident figures for roads where route accident reduction plans have been implemented within the past three years.

The answer

Answered by Lewis Macdonald on 21 May 2002 · 32 days after it was lodged, 18 days after it was due

At least three year's accident figures are required in order to see how well a route accident reduction plan (RARP) is performing. An analysis of the accident figures for pre-1999 RARPs has been prepared to illustrate the reduction, or otherwise, of injury accidents along these lengths of road. The figures may be distorted by traffic growth, development in the vicinity, treatment of accident cluster sites and the carrying out of improvement schemes or major maintenance, but they do suggest that some RARPs have worked and some have not. They are attempting to deal with the most difficult type of accident to treat
- the random occurrence of crashes along a length of road. The effectiveness of various types of treatment in different locations is being monitored, and should result in more effective investment in such schemes in the future.Trunk Road Route Accident Reduction Plans (1996-98)Route | Scheme Name | CompletionDate | EstimatedCost | BeforeACCS | After ACCS
A87 | Invergarry to Kyle of Lochalsh | 31/10/1997 | £268,330 | 61 | 41
A9 | Dornoch to Scrabster | 31/07/1997 | £320,000 | 104 | 57
A84 | Stirling to Crianlarich | 30/05/1997 | £150,000 | 83 | 100
A83 | Tarbet to Kennacraig | 01/03/1998 | £575,000 | 98 | 124
A85 | Lochearnhead to Crianlarich | 17/12/1997 | £155,000 | 32 | 34
A887 | Invermoriston to Bun Loyne | 28/02/1998 | £61,226 | 6 | 6
A737 | Beith to Dalry | 31/10/1997 | £65,000 | 34 | 26
A737 | Howwood to Renfrewshire | 15/03/1999 | £24,500 | 29 |

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-25239 by reference.