Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-24299 · Session 1

Further to the answer to question S1W-23288 by Mr Jim Wallace on 20 March 2002, when it will report to (a) the Justice Committees and (b) t…

Answered Asked by Christine Grahame SNP Lodged 21 Mar 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-23288 by Mr Jim Wallace on 20 March 2002, when it will report to (a) the Justice Committees and (b) the Parliament on its conclusions from its consultation exercise on Huts and Hutters and the report on the Carbeth Hutters by the former Justice and Home Affairs Committee.

The answer

Answered by Jim Wallace on 24 Apr 2002 · 34 days after it was lodged, 20 days after it was due

I am aware that constructive discussions are taking place at local level to resolve the difficulties at Carbeth which prompted the committee's report. All of us who are keen to see a fair and amicable settlement to this issue will hope for a positive outcome to the current discussions. I would not, however, wish to intervene in private negotiations, nor would it be appropriate to do so. I expect within the next few weeks to announce conclusions on the committee's report and the subsequent consultation. It is already clear however that there would be substantial drawbacks to any attempt to legislate in this area. Some of these were recognised by the committee itself. Such legislation would be contrary to fundamental principles of Scots law, in particular that leased land under a short lease reverts to the landlord at expiry of the lease and that property built on leased land belongs to the landlord. Moreover, legislation could not be retrospective or applicable to hutters only, and its promotion might precipitate changes to the ownership and management of comparable estates in Scotland which would be profoundly damaging to the interests of hutters.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-24299 by reference.