Written Question · S1W-23462 · Session 1
Further to the answer to question S1W-12675 by Mr Sam Galbraith on 5 February 2001 and in light of the recent report by Casella Stanger con…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-12675 by Mr Sam Galbraith on 5 February 2001 and in light of the recent report by Casella Stanger confirming the existence of the low frequency noise known locally as the "Largs Hum", whether it will review its decision not to intervene in this matter and whether it will now arrange for a full and independent inquiry to be carried out in order to determine the source of the noise.
The answer
The question is based on a false premise. The Low Frequency Noise Report, undertaken by Casella Stanger for the Scottish Executive in partnership with DEFRA and the other Devolved Administrations, neither addresses nor confirms the existence of the so-called "Largs Hum". Rather, it sets out general guidance for those dealing with and investigating complaints about low frequency noise.The use of the term "Largs Hum" implies that the issue is one of general concern to residents of Largs, however, North Ayrshire Council is aware of only three cases from Largs' residents about low frequency noise in the last two years. In one case, the complainant advised the council the noise had stopped, in another a potential acoustic source was identified. In the one other case
- behind the present interest in the "Largs Hum"
- despite extensive investigations, there has not been clear instrumental evidence showing the existence of a problem. As the answers to previous questions (S1W-12675 on 5 February 2001, 13098 on 9 March 2001 and 14341 on 9 April 2001) on this matter have made clear, the Executive is satisfied that North Ayrshire Council has acted fully and correctly in this matter. North Ayrshire Council officials involved in the case have indicated that they have read, and welcome, the procedures suggested in the Low Frequency Noise Report. They have also stated that they believe their actions met and exceeded the recommendations made therein. In addition, after having made wide-ranging enquiries of various expert bodies, the Executive is satisfied that, insofar as a judgement can be made, there is no identifiable acoustic source in this case.In the absence of any significant corroboration and after making enquiries of the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, Glasgow Caledonian University, Scottish Power and The Royal Navy and in the light of the proper actions of North Ayrshire Council, the Executive considers it inappropriate to fund the further full independent inquiry sought.
- behind the present interest in the "Largs Hum"
- despite extensive investigations, there has not been clear instrumental evidence showing the existence of a problem. As the answers to previous questions (S1W-12675 on 5 February 2001, 13098 on 9 March 2001 and 14341 on 9 April 2001) on this matter have made clear, the Executive is satisfied that North Ayrshire Council has acted fully and correctly in this matter. North Ayrshire Council officials involved in the case have indicated that they have read, and welcome, the procedures suggested in the Low Frequency Noise Report. They have also stated that they believe their actions met and exceeded the recommendations made therein. In addition, after having made wide-ranging enquiries of various expert bodies, the Executive is satisfied that, insofar as a judgement can be made, there is no identifiable acoustic source in this case.In the absence of any significant corroboration and after making enquiries of the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, Glasgow Caledonian University, Scottish Power and The Royal Navy and in the light of the proper actions of North Ayrshire Council, the Executive considers it inappropriate to fund the further full independent inquiry sought.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-23462 by reference.