Written Question · S1W-20533 · Session 1
What its response is to the report by the Auditor General for Scotland, The new trunk road contracts, and what action it plans to take as a…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive what its response is to the report by the Auditor General for Scotland, The new trunk road contracts, and what action it plans to take as a result.
The answer
I welcome the Auditor General's authoritative report which he agreed to undertake at my predecessor's invitation earlier this year. In particular, his conclusion that overall the department implemented these large and important contract competitions fairly, properly and with due regard to value for money, and reached the right contract decisions, is helpful. He noted that the new contracts should provide annual savings of some £15 million and that winning bids were £121 million lower than the second placed bids over a five-year contract period. He also noted that the number of staff affected was significantly less than predicted earlier with 218 staff transferring to the new road operators and 85 reported to have been made redundant.The department has learned important lessons from what was a difficult and complex process and the Auditor General has provided recommendations on how to improve future tender competitions. These will be examined in detail. He has also suggested that a report be published on the first year of operation of the new contracts. The Performance Audit Group and the department have been closely monitoring the new road operators' performance and I plan to publish a report from the Performance Audit Group next summer.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-20533 by reference.