Written Question · S1W-12632 · Session 1
How it plans to take forward the future delivery of ferry services in the Highlands and Islands to bring these into compliance with Europea…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive how it plans to take forward the future delivery of ferry services in the Highlands and Islands to bring these into compliance with European Community Law.
The answer
In April 2000, I announced publication of the consultation document Delivering Lifeline Ferry Services which sought views on options for putting our subsidised lifeline services out to tender in order that they can continue under European Community rules.We received a response of over 100 replies. I have considered all of the points made carefully, taking account of the relevant EC Regulations and Guidelines on State Aid. I am announcing today a package of provisional proposals which have been submitted to the European Commission and which I believe will provide a robust framework for the continued delivery of high quality lifeline ferry services to the Highlands and Islands. The key elements are briefly summarised as follows:- I regard all Caledonian MacBrayne ferry services which serve islands as being consistent with public service obligations (PSOs) and plan to tender these services in line with the requirements for these as set out in the European Community cabotage regulations and guidelines;- I have made robust representations to the Commission in relation to Caledonian MacBrayne's mainland-to-mainland routes, Gourock-Dunoon and Tarbert-Portavadie. I am pleased that the Commission has indicated it might be prepared to consider such services where land based transport would not provide a viable alternative. I regard Caledonian MacBrayne's present mainland-to-mainland routes as being consistent with this criterion. I therefore propose PSOs in respect of these routes also. In the case of Gourock-Dunoon, the PSO would be in respect of a passenger only service because of its integration with other modes of transport (as indeed is the approved service at present);- On the packages of routes to be tendered, the Executive's strong preference, based on the results of consultation, is to tender the network as a whole. Overwhelming support was expressed for this option in response to consultation and we believe this would maximise service reliability for the communities served, simplify the process for management of vessels and provide economies of scale in company management, safety and quality systems. It also avoids cherry picking of routes and facilitates integrated transport through co-ordinated timetabling of services;- On arrangements for future ownership of vessels, I propose to establish a publicly owned vessel owning company in line with proposals set out in Delivering Lifeline Ferry Services. I believe this strikes the right balance between the need to ensure the efficient utilisation of the unique existing fleet and service reliability through this period of great change. Vessels would be leased to operators on a commercial basis and without subsidy in line with European Community rules that prohibit grants in respect of vessel replacement;- I propose operators would be bound to the vessel owning company's existing vessels. However, I propose to allow scope for operators to bring their own vessel solutions where we have identified a need for new vessels to replace older ships or expand the range of services during a five-year contract period. This will be decided on a case by case basis at the outset of each PSO contract period. In line with the Commission's guidance, the vessel owning company's functions would focus on bare boat leasing to operators as well as ownership and maintenance of CalMac's piers and harbours. I am considering the possibility of the vessel owning company offering, on an optional basis, a management of maintenance package which might be attractive to some operators. We also propose the vessel owning company should act as an operator of last resort which would provide an important safeguard through this period of change;- Delivering Lifeline Ferry Services made clear that the Executive would allow Caledonian MacBrayne to bid to operate th
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-12632 by reference.