Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-12089 · Session 1

What assessment it has made of any impact of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) on (a) civil liberties, (b) policing generally …

Answered Asked by Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con Lodged 18 Dec 2000

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what assessment it has made of any impact of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) on (a) civil liberties, (b) policing generally and (c) the operation of its departments; whether ECHR has had any impact on the spending levels of (i) its departments and (ii) non-departmental public bodies (NDPBs) in the current financial year and whether it will detail any estimated impact on spending levels in the next three years, broken down by department and NDPB and showing any costings.

The answer

Answered by Jim Wallace on 17 Jan 2001 · 30 days after it was lodged, 14 days after it was due

The UK has been bound by the European Convention of Human Rights since 1951. The principal effect of the Human Rights Act is to allow UK citizens to assert their Convention rights in domestic courts, rather than having to take their cases to Strasbourg. As such, it will have a positive impact on civil liberties, by bringing human rights home and giving them a place at the heart of civic society.As far as the impact on policing is concerned, it is in the first instance for Chief Constables to assess the implications of the legislation for operational policing. The Association of Chief Policy Officers in Scotland (ACPOS) has put arrangements in place to assess the policies and procedures of Scottish forces in the light of their obligations under the Convention, and a range of awareness-raising and training activities have been organised for police officers.The Scottish Executive has carried out an audit of all areas of activity in order to identify any potential incompatibilities with the Convention; and it has taken prompt and appropriate action, including legislation, where problems have been identified.As far as costs are concerned, I refer to my answers to questions S1W-2571 and 2572. The Executive has made provision for the Crown Office, the Legal Aid Fund and the Scottish Courts Service to take account of ECHR issues arising in criminal and civil proceedings under the Scotland Act and Human Rights Act. The total provision for these services principally in respect of the ECHR was £6.5 million in 1999-2000; £10.6 million in 2000-01, and £8.9 million in 2001-02. Nothing has happened since then to cause us to revise those estimates. However, costs resulting from the consideration of ECHR issues cannot readily be disaggregated from other costs incurred in civil or criminal proceedings. The same difficulty arises in relation to any ECHR-related spending by departments of the Executive and non-departmental public bodies. The detailed breakdown requested by Lord James Douglas-Hamilton is therefore not available.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-12089 by reference.