Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-09968 · Session 1

What responses it received to its consultation on the Annual Expenditure Report Investing in You.

Answered Asked by Duncan McNeil Lab Lodged 19 Sep 2000

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what responses it received to its consultation on the Annual Expenditure Report Investing in You.

The answer

Answered by Jack McConnell on 19 Sep 2000 · 0 days after it was lodged, on time

The attached note provides a summary of the responses to the consultation on Investing in You.SUMMARY OF CONSULTATION RESPONSES ON INVESTING IN YOUWhen the Annual Expenditure Report, Investing in You was published in April 2000, the Scottish Executive invited members of the public to respond with their views on the proposed budget for 2001-02. The result of that consultation is set out below. The Minister for Finance also visited four areas of Scotland to meet with an invited audience and hear their views on the proposed budget. The questions asked and the broad themes that emerged are also set out.
Written submissions172 letters, postcards or e-mails were received during the consultation period. Of these, 134 (79%) were from members of the public. (Of these, 23 identified themselves as farmers, five as students, one as a general practitioner, one as a vet and one as an academic.) Seventeen responses were received from charities, societies and pressure groups, nine from public bodies, four from professional bodies, three from trade unions and two each from community councils and trade or representative bodies. Two responses were also received from members of the Scottish Parliament, one of which covered a petition from constituents.
A small number of responses (mostly from organisations) made comments on the layout and presentation of the consultation document. The vast majority, however, made comments about areas where additional expenditure should be devoted. Many of these were from a particular perspective and there appear to be four distinct campaigns for additional spending. There was no support for reduced spending.
In addition to a submission from Shelter (Scotland) we also received 26 postcards distributed by that organisation. In addition to the petition on behalf of improving roads in South Lanarkshire submitted a local MSP, a number of members of the public from Lanarkshire also wrote in support of additional road spending. Some 31 people, predominantly farmers and cattle societies, wrote in support of additional expenditure for biological and agricultural research in Scotland and predominantly for the Moredun Research Institute. Finally, we received a number of e-mails from university students in favour of better student support. In total, around 122 of the letters or communications were specific about areas that required additional spending.
The 10 most popular groups (including apparent campaigns mentioned above) that received support for additional public spending were:
Housing or homelessness (including Shelter postcards) 31% (37 responses) The Scottish Agricultural and Biological Research Institutes 25% (31 responses) Improving roads and reducing fuel tax 13% (16 responses including 1 petition) Education (including sports education and School transport) 8% (10 responses) Healthcare and additional treatments 7% (8 responses) Improved rail transport and sustainable transport 7% (8 responses) Improved student support and higher education 5% (6 responses) Better provision for elderly care and for Pensioners 4% (5 responses) Improving rural affairs, forestry and Sustainable environment 4% (5 responses) Heritage (from Built Heritage through to Musical heritage) 3% (4 responses)The remaining responses included support for law and order, local government services, nursery nurses and parental care, victim suppor

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-09968 by reference.