SPCB Written Question · S1W-09467 · Session 1
Further to his statement in his answer to question S1W-233 on 8 July 1999 that "a figure for contingency... is commercially confidential", …
The question
To ask the Presiding Officer, further to his statement in his answer to question S1W-233 on 8 July 1999 that "a figure for contingency... is commercially confidential", why the Spencely Report was able to reveal the estimated value of contingency costs for the Holyrood Project.
The answer
Under normal circumstances, a public body would not publicise the sum of money set aside for contingency before or during a major capital project in order to protect its negotiating position. This is in line with standard public procurement guidance and my answer to question S1W-233 is consistent with that position. However, in the context of the debate surrounding the project in March this year the SPCB took the view that it was of paramount importance to publish the Spencely report in full and thereby put all available financial information before Parliament at a time when the future of the Holyrood Project was being considered.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-09467 by reference.