Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-08148 · Session 1

Whether it has come to a view on the remaining substantive issues aired in the public consultation held on the McIntosh Report into local g…

Answered Asked by Karen Gillon Lab Lodged 20 Jun 2000

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has come to a view on the remaining substantive issues aired in the public consultation held on the McIntosh Report into local government and the Scottish Parliament.

The answer

Answered by Frank McAveety on 21 Jun 2000 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

I am pleased to announce our position on the following issues arising from our consultation on the McIntosh Report:On the issue of whether we should legislate to allow for management structures involving directly-elected provosts/leaders, we have noted the extensive opposition to this model of political management and have concluded that, given the lack of demand for it and the degree to which it is not central to Scottish councils' thinking on structural modernisation, there would be little benefit in legislating in its favour in the forthcoming local government Bill.On the issue of eligibility of council employees to become councillors in their own councils, the consultation has persuaded us that there is a case for relaxing the current rules. We have therefore decided that future local government legislation should contain provisions which would allow council employees (other than those in politically restricted posts) to stand for election to their own council without having to resign their posts until they are elected.On the issue of which council employee posts should be deemed "politically restricted", we note that the political sensitivity of a given post is determined by the nature of the post rather than the salary it receives. We therefore conclude that the current statutory salary threshold (above which all posts are deemed to be politically restricted) is not a reasonable measure of political restriction and that it should be abolished. We intend to legislate to do so as soon as the opportunity arises and prior to that we will consult on which types of post should be designated as politically restricted.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-08148 by reference.