Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-05672 · Session 1

Further to the answer to question S1W-3021 by Mr Jim Wallace on 12 January 2000, what progress has been made on the establishment of an ind…

Answered Asked by Keith Raffan LD Lodged 28 Mar 2000

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-3021 by Mr Jim Wallace on 12 January 2000, what progress has been made on the establishment of an independent Commission to review and reform charity law in Scotland.

The answer

Answered by Jim Wallace on 29 Mar 2000 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

I am pleased to announce that the independent Charity Law Commission has now been established. The chair of the Commission is Mrs Jean McFadden, lecturer in law at Strathclyde University and formerly president of CoSLA. The members of the Commission are: -Colin Crosby, Fund Manager, Aberdeen Asset Management plcGillian Donald CA, Messrs Scott Moncrieff Downie Wilson CAMartyn Evans, Director, Scottish Consumer CouncilRichard Fries, Visiting Fellow of the Centre for Civil Society at the London School of EconomicsAlistair Grimes, Chief Executive, Community Enterprise in StrathclydeKeith Jones, Head of Law and Administration (North), Aberdeenshire CouncilKaliani Lyle, Chief Executive Officer, Scottish Association of Citizens' Advice BureauxSimon Mackintosh, Partner, Messrs Turcan, Connell, SolicitorsIan MacPherson, Head of Legal Services, Strathclyde PoliceJohn Naylor, Secretary and Treasurer of Carnegie United Kingdom TrustDavid Orr, Director, Scottish Federation of Housing AssociationsAvril Sloane, Administrator, Glasgow Educational and Marshall TrustMrs Jeanette Wilson, Solicitor to the Church of ScotlandIan MacPherson, Head of Legal Services, Strathclyde PoliceThe Commission has been asked to report in one year and its remit is: "To review the law relating to charities in Scotland and to make recommendations on any reforms considered necessary.In carrying out its remit the Commission will:consider the structure of regulation and support for the charitable sector in Scotland
consider the operational effects of Scottish legislation on charities of all types and size, bearing in mind the need to encourage voluntary and charitable activity and the contribution which the voluntary sector makes to the social economy
consider how best to provide the charitable sector with definitive advice and information
consider the requirement to protect the public, ensure high standards among charities but at the same time avoid over-burdensome administrative requirements
consider whether in addition to reform, the law should also be consolidated.
In carrying out its work the Commission will review relevant recent research on charity law, including that carried out by Dundee University."

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-05672 by reference.