Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-03231 · Session 1

Whether changes are being considered to the present arrangements for making appointments to public bodies.

Answered Asked by Karen Whitefield Lab Lodged 10 Dec 1999

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether changes are being considered to the present arrangements for making appointments to public bodies.

The answer

Answered by Jack McConnell on 13 Dec 1999 · 3 days after it was lodged, on time

The Executive believes that the time is now right to consider carefully whether the current procedures enable Ministers to meet fully and effectively the objectives of transparency and equal opportunities in post-devolution Scotland, and if not, what changes should be made. We are therefore planning to publish a wide-ranging consultation paper early in the New Year. The consultation paper will both provide detailed information about how the current system works, and invite views on the current system and on possible options for change.The consultation paper will in particular seek views on the following:should the Parliament be involved in appointments made by the Executive and if so at what stage and in what way? We are examining the experience in legislatures in other countries to see what lessons can be learned;whether a separate Scottish Commissioner for Public Appointments should be established
- if so, what powers, responsibilities and reporting arrangements might he/she have?the role and appointment of independent assessors
- including consideration of whether the composition of appointments panels should vary according to the nature/type of appointments;whether the targets inherited from the Scottish Office for achieving greater representation in public appointments are relevant; andmore generally what more can be done to encourage women, disabled people and people from ethnic minorities to apply for public appointment?Any changes to the appointments system will affect large numbers of people across Scottish society. Arrangements will be put in hand therefore to ensure that the consultation exercise is widely publicised and that MSPs, public bodies and members of the public are able to make their views known before any final decisions on changes to the system are reached.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-03231 by reference.