Petition · unlisted · Session 5
Unlisted petition 3790 title not published
This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3790), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.
What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.
Stand-out terms in its comments: island representation boards decisions decision making representatives
Signatures by country
473 online signaturesComments
32 comments, oldest first-
Martin Johnstone 19 Mar 2021Shouldn't be necessary but it clearly is necessary..
-
Camille Dressler 19 Mar 2021The island community voice must be represented as widely as possible!
-
Ian Gillies 19 Mar 2021I am very pleased to support this petition, seeking to redress the current situation of membership of public boards that have little relevance to the island communities they serve.
-
David G Newman 20 Mar 2021As the Scottish Government has just published its Population Strategy I believe that decisions taken by public organisations like HIAL should also take into consideration whether de-population of island communities will also result.
-
Ian Gillies 20 Mar 2021Very pleased to support this petition which seeks to redress the relevance and membership of public Boards to the island communities they serve.
-
Murdo Maclean 21 Mar 2021Fully support
-
Kris Westerman 21 Mar 2021It is vital that islanders with actual knowledge of island issues and impacts should be fully involved in any decision making with regard to island issues. It is also vital that they not be there as a tick box exercise but actually listened to and taken notice of. One of the biggest exports from the islands is graduates, who after gaining a wealth of experience often return in later life. This experience should be harnessed.
-
John Daniel Peteranna 21 Mar 2021All islanders should support this
-
Bernie Bell 22 Mar 2021Only those who live in a place can correctly assess the situation there.
-
Mary Schmoller 22 Mar 2021Community Representation needed. Of note, the address box in the petition does not offer islands only town and city
-
Peter Henderson 22 Mar 2021Practical, first hand knowledge of Island life is a necessary skill needed to assess the impact a course of action will have when applied to an Island community. What seems a good business or financial solution does not always translate to a good outcome when applied to the Islands or other remote parts of Scotland. Local Board representatives are the only way to stop decisions being made that damage rather than improve our daily lives
-
Mairi MacLeod 22 Mar 2021Absolutely essential that is genuine representation by community members who understand the importance of these services and the impact of their delivery (or non-delivery!)
-
Wanda Gorzkowska 22 Mar 2021Life line services and their needs are best understood by those needing them
-
Joyce Murison 22 Mar 2021I totally agree with more local community input into decisions that affect them.
-
Joyce Murison 22 Mar 2021I totally agree with local representatives being on committees that take decisions that impact their community.
-
Marion Walker 22 Mar 2021Fully Support this for our Island community
-
Ian M Wilson 22 Mar 2021Essential for those who will be affected to have a voice.
-
Matt Bruce 22 Mar 2021It seems obvious that island residents should be on the board of transport organisations that provide essential services
-
Rodney Shannon 22 Mar 2021We need representation
-
vanessa langley 22 Mar 2021This has been a long battle with HIAL, still not over with the island communities feeling that their views have been minimised and undervalued which seems to be in complete contradiction to the island proofing of government decisions.For these to be taken without an island voice and proper representation on HIAL's Board seems to be negligent in the extreme.
-
James Dobson 23 Mar 2021It is essential, and obvious, that local representation is available on these boards to contribute to decisions that meet island needs and concerns.
-
Frank Creighton 23 Mar 2021I agree with petition
-
Kathleen Grace 23 Mar 2021Yes, I agree with this petition.
-
Angus MacDonald 23 Mar 2021These boards need island representatives
-
Morag MacAulay 23 Mar 2021It is essential and important that local representation is available on these boards to contribute to decisions that affect island issues, needs, and concerns. Vital even to have a representation.
-
Teen MacDonald 23 Mar 2021I agree with petition
-
William Barker 23 Mar 2021No taxation without representation. Islander taxes help pay for the service. They are the primary users. The islands aren't an outpost or a central belt colony. A local voice in the decision making should be minimum requirement.
-
Margaret Deyell 23 Mar 2021I agree that local communities must have more say in decisions that affect them.
-
Angus MacDonald 23 Mar 2021These boards need Island representation
-
John Mac Lennan 24 Mar 2021Bit unfair giving such a tight timeline
-
Donald Mac Lean 24 Mar 2021I agree we need more representation
-
John N Macleod 24 Mar 2021Agree with petition.