Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3731 title not published

Unlisted First activity 3 Feb 2021 Last activity 20 Mar 2021

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3731), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: rule metre walk scrap multiple sclerosis vary

Signatures
3,101
Comments
450
Activity window
45 days
3 Feb 2021 to 20 Mar 2021

Signatures by country

3,101 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,291 41.6%
  2. United Kingdom943 30.4%
  3. England766 24.7%
  4. Wales62 2%
  5. Northern Ireland28 0.9%
  6. Germany2 0.1%
  7. Spain2 0.1%
  8. Ireland2 0.1%
  9. Canada1 0%
  10. Not given1 0%
  11. 3 other countries3 0.1%

Comments

450 comments, oldest first
450 comments · showing 1–50
  1. Catherine Cowan 4 Feb 2021
    Every type of disability is different. Ms effects everyone differently. One day you may be able to walk 20 metres but there may be many days you cannot walk at all. This is a rule set by someone who has no idea of how disability affects individuals
  2. Catriona Hyland 4 Feb 2021
    Yes I agree 20 metre rule must be removed . If the Powers that Be had their independence to walk & do the simplest activities taken from them for any length of time , how interesting it would be to see the changed attitude. No one wishes to be reliant others
  3. Janice campbell 4 Feb 2021
    20 meter rule is not a true reflection on what life is like with multiple sclerosis
  4. Margaret murray 4 Feb 2021
    This is the lowest of the lowest of Scotland do this to disabled people everybody has different needs just like MSP
  5. Lesley Wood 5 Feb 2021
    I think the 20 meter rule should be removed because it does not reflect how walking impacts on people like myself who have varying degrees of walking distances determined by how I may feel on and particular day. One day I may be able to walk about 20 meters and the next day I can barely walk a few meters without pain.
  6. ANITA DUFFY 5 Feb 2021
    If a person with disabilities could walk 20metres on a particular day, but that was all......what do they do after 20metres if they can't go any further? If they are in too much pain to proceed? If they collapse?

    Seems a stupid test, if the idea is they can use a bus to get about. A bus only takes you to another bus stop....and then what? Not everything is 20metres from a bus stop!!!!!!
  7. Mairi Burgess 5 Feb 2021
    As MS is such an unpredictable illness it is very unfair to penalise someone who could possibly walk 20 meters one day and be confined to bed the next.
  8. Elaine Young 5 Feb 2021
    People with a known medical condition should not have to prove they qualify. A medical specialist's letter should be enough.
  9. Patricia Ann Stewart 6 Feb 2021
    Fully agree with this petition!
  10. Warren Duncan 8 Feb 2021
    The 20 metre rule needs to be reviewed and ultimately removed. It causes unnecessary stress and indignity. Scotland wants to be a progressive country the 20 metre rule is not progressive and embarrassing, people are losing out on benefits that they need for a
  11. Barbara jackson-smith 8 Feb 2021
    People with ms struggle to get recognised .If we don't look disabled then to others we are not but that is far from the truth.
  12. Wendy Leonard 8 Feb 2021
    Most definitely
  13. Jamie Blair 8 Feb 2021
    Having gone through this process it's a shambles!
  14. Alice Waugh Waugh 8 Feb 2021
    Abolish the 20 metre rule It is so unfair
  15. Mary Douglas 9 Feb 2021
    The 29 metre rule impacts heavily on people with MS. It can be a fluctuating condition which makes mobility possible on one day but not on the next. It is not a fair measurement of ability
  16. kenneth alexander macintosh 9 Feb 2021
    should be removed
  17. Steven Holgan 10 Feb 2021
    The 20 metre rule is a ridiculous concept. Just because someone can walk more than 20 metres does not mean they can go about a normal working day in many workplaces. I find myself potentially having retire early as I can't do my normal work duties do to MS...and I'm one of the lucky ones. Some people struggle with many normal functions but may still be able to walk 20 metres. It is an absurd rule.
  18. Kim Chrystie 10 Feb 2021
    It should be the disease and not the symptoms the system should support.
  19. Dr Rachel Petrie 10 Feb 2021
    MS is a fluctuating condition with many different disabling symptoms which are poorly understood by most. Whether someone can walk 20m has got very little to do with how disabled someone is. Please involve medically qualified professionals with assessment of disability.
  20. Christine Hunter 10 Feb 2021
    20 metre rule should be removed.
  21. Isabel Barker 10 Feb 2021
    Definitely should be removed and soon.
  22. George Barker 10 Feb 2021
    Definitely needs to be removed.
  23. Fiona Kelly 10 Feb 2021
    My daughter was diagnosed at 18 last March she has good days were she feels good but her bad days she can't walk from the living room to the kitchen as her dizzy spells are very bad
  24. Diane Hogg 11 Feb 2021
    Should be removed, not a concept that is realistic, MS sufferers are not all unable to walk, I can walk but in debilitating pain, but I don't count, so as a progressive illness that affects sufferers at different levels it shouldn't be taken into account how much you can walk. MS doesn't go away they need to get that through their heads its progressive and painful unless they have it they will never understand.
  25. Ruth Findlay 12 Feb 2021
    The 20m rule is discriminatory against people with MS. Many of us find walking painful and our conditions are highly variable.
  26. Paul Paterson 13 Feb 2021
    Definitely agree, This 20 meter should be scrapped! I have multiple sclerosis and things change from day to day one day I can reach the 20m next day I can't even get out of bed.
  27. Emma Folan 14 Feb 2021
    The 20 metre rule needs removed. This is not a realistic measure of MS sufferers disabilities. It can vary greatly depending on the day. This is discrimination.
  28. Alan Wyllie 24 Feb 2021
    Please rethink this. Find a better way of accessing needs without putting arbitrary barriers in front of disabled people.
  29. Tina Jackson 24 Feb 2021
    The 20 metre, should be scrapped.
  30. Hazel Rutter 24 Feb 2021
    I like the new name definitely should 'adopt' it.
  31. richard holder 24 Feb 2021
    I cannot walk 10metres let alone 20metres
  32. David Allen 24 Feb 2021
    20 meters gets me nowhere it would leave me stranded in the middle of nowhere exposed and extremely vulnerable.
  33. Anneliese Paterson 24 Feb 2021
    Multiple Sclerosis is a variable and unpredictable condition , making the ruling unfair
  34. Diane Mortimer 24 Feb 2021
    The 20 metre rule should not apply.
  35. Roger Horton 24 Feb 2021
    I wish to support this petition.
  36. Tina Marshall 24 Feb 2021
    Every day is different for people with motor skills disability and the 20 meters is not an indicative measure of abilities
  37. Marie Corbett 24 Feb 2021
    I have MS and some days I can do 20mtrs some days struggle to do 2.
  38. john Doherty 24 Feb 2021
    Ms is a one way street for all who suffer. It is a disability downhill with years of suffering with no light at end of tunnel WE HAVE A DUTY TO LOOK AFTER OUR FAMILY AND FRIENDS THAT CANNOT LOOK AFTER THEMSELVES THEY ARE IN PAIN AND MISERY EVERY DAY.
  39. Pat Crossley 24 Feb 2021
    20 metre rule should be scrapped.
  40. Brenda Whitley 24 Feb 2021
    I agree that the 20 metre should be removed and who ever thought up this rule made go on his or her bare knees for 20 metres. Imoral rule
  41. Rachel Bailey 24 Feb 2021
    Where on earth is 20m going to get you?
  42. Bernice G Addis 24 Feb 2021
    This rule should not be applied to MS sufferers and is discriminatory. It is not realistic as disability can vary from day to day. Some days 20 metres might be possible but in immense amount of pain and on other days one can not even get out of bed.
  43. Cathy Davidson 24 Feb 2021
    Not everyone is the same or day by day can be different please ban 20 metre rule for the whole of UK
  44. Thomas Digan 24 Feb 2021
    I agree the 20m rule needs to go my wife has ms and on a good day she may walk further than 20 m but most of the time she cant walk half of that she was on a lifetime mobilty award for 20yrs at the higher rate now she gets standard rate and was too scared to appeal and is terrified when the assessment comes
  45. Alan Meston 24 Feb 2021
    Due to my MS and the Covid restrictions like the 20m rule, I rarely go out as my balance, coordination and poor strength in my legs means I would be in breach of the rules.
  46. Rebecca Vallance 24 Feb 2021
    Understanding the disease and the enduring ups and downs both physically and mentally moment by moment.
  47. Rachel Bailey 24 Feb 2021
    Where on earth is 20m going to get you?
  48. Juanita Woolliscroft 24 Feb 2021
    I have MS amd my walkingability fluctuates
  49. Frances Stewart 24 Feb 2021
    MS ability to walk varies almost daily and no way can it be judged on 20 meters anytime
  50. Linda Murdoch 24 Feb 2021
    People with MS suffer