Petition · unlisted · Session 5
Unlisted petition 3716 title not published
This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3716), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.
What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.
Stand-out terms in its comments: history culloden battlefield historical ancestors site
Signatures by country
21,660 online signaturesComments
798 comments, oldest first-
Dorothy Holden 3 Feb 2021Our Battlefields need to be protected and treated with the respect they deserve. Current planning controls are not working, they need to be much more rigourous and less easy to circumvent by developers
-
Kate MCMANUS 3 Feb 2021Scottish importance.
-
Dianne Y Nelson 3 Feb 2021Culloden is sacred ground.Would you want people building and partying on your Mother's grave? Thought not.
-
sarah bailey 3 Feb 2021Battlefields should be kept as a monument to all those who lost their lives as a sign of respect.
-
Lisa Davies 3 Feb 2021We need to protect Scotland's Battlefields for future generations, past & current planning applications at Culloden show that not enough is being done to protect these areas.
-
David Wilds 3 Feb 2021We should be safeguarding this and every battlefield for future generations and to honour the memory of all soldiers who fought and lost their lives here.
-
Ada Cartwright 3 Feb 2021I fully expect SNP to intervene on this.
-
Alison Dickie 3 Feb 2021Culloden should be treated as a war cemetery. The dead deserve peace to rest. More protection is needed for our battlefields in Scotland. Legislation is required to stop reapplications when it has previously been denied. Tweaks should not be allowed.
-
Sonya Whitmire 3 Feb 2021Scotland is known for its culture, and beauty. I can't imagine building over a gravesite.
-
Linda Frantz 3 Feb 2021The historic battlefields of Scotland need permanently protected against any building or desecration of any kind. This IS Scotland's history!
-
Tonya Billings 3 Feb 2021While I know it is tempting to allow development. The battlefields are graveyards and of historical significance. They are what draws tourism. If you don't protect them then it is inevitable that revenue will be lost.
-
Dorothy Holden 3 Feb 2021Our battlefields need to be protected against unwanted and unnecessary development. Current legislation is not sufficient and a much more robust planning system needs to be brought into being.
-
Doug Foster 3 Feb 2021Sad to see historic sites not protected.
-
Sandra Anne Marshall 3 Feb 2021It would be a national disgrace if it was allowed to build on Culloden. Surely there are lots of brown field sites in Scotland to build on.
-
Dorothy Holden 3 Feb 2021Our historic Battlefields need to be much more robustly protected from developers than at present
-
Margaret Manning 3 Feb 2021It does not become them at all when you have to continually lobby them to stop development .
-
Theresa Preitz 3 Feb 2021Your destroying am important part of our history. Make the sight heritage please.
-
Jeanie Corstorphine 3 Feb 2021I am absolutely furious that HES did not object to this development. They are not fit for purpose and the developer's 3rd application, they have no thought whatsover or do not care about our History. If one development is allowed then there will numerous other ones no doubt. The protection of this battlefield should be enshrined in law. Isn't it bad enough that our ancestors were slaughteted as they were fleeing without us having to fight greedy developers time and time again.
-
David Learmonth 3 Feb 2021A Scot, defending greater preservation of Scottish Battlefields, Culloden in particular.
-
Jeanie Corstorphine 3 Feb 2021No I do not believe it's adequate. Applications will continue to be put in regardless how many times they are turned down. Legislation enshrined in law is needed to protect the Battlefield.
-
Kimberley Preston 3 Feb 2021No and Yes
-
Tracey Love 3 Feb 2021I am the first born out of Scotland for my family. my great grandmother and grandmother coming from golspie, and my mum dad sister and brother all coming from glasgow and paisley
In the last ten years I've bell reconnecting with my family and family history
To many of us immigrants this site is of extreme importance as well as the folk from Scotland. -
Julia Punch 3 Feb 2021My Mother was a Fraser, descendent of Lord Lovat, Simon Fraser.
-
Lise Poulin 3 Feb 2021Its time that this historical site and war grave be adequately protected.
-
William Shaw of Easter Lair 3 Feb 2021Culloden is sacred ground.
-
Dorothy Holden 4 Feb 2021We need to greatly strengthen the planning protection for site such as our Battlefields which are under constant threat from developers who have no interest in preserving our past history.
-
Lanier Cassada 4 Feb 2021Please leave these shoulders to Rest In Peace.
-
Linda Anderson 4 Feb 2021Let's protect our history.
-
Frances Palmer 4 Feb 2021Been to Culloden many times. Am absolutely horrified that anyone would consider building on the battlefield.
-
Caroline Clulow 4 Feb 2021Please don't allow property developers to ruin our heritage. It's important to show respect for our history so that generations to come can have the chance to reflect.
-
Mary Thomson 4 Feb 2021We shouldn't even be having to do this, time and again applications going in for houses. Please stop this from happening by making it a Heritage site! Protect our history.
-
Elaine Ryan 4 Feb 2021Not enough protection is afforded to Scottish battlefields. People died fighting for their cause and are buried on these sites. These are war graves and should be afforded the respect and decency shown to other battle does around the world. Planning protection must be given to all historical sites around Scotland. These sites are this country's history and must be protected for everyone.
-
Gerard McAuley 4 Feb 2021It is a sign of a mature nation that we interpret our history and preserve it for future generations. We need accessible artefacts in museums but we also need to guard and protect the ground where key historic events took place.
-
Mrs Sheryl Hepworth 4 Feb 2021The battlefields of Scotland need full and proper protection as they contain the graves of so many Scots who fought for our Scotland. They are precious and should be sacrosanct. The level of protection accorded these places is totally inadequate and legislation is badly needed against rich, greedy speculators that would desecrate our graveyards. Please do not allow any further intrusion by land speculators by allowing our historic grounds to be threatened with modern buildings for profit.
-
Judi Evans 4 Feb 2021Culloden Muir should never be built on again. It should be a designated War Grave.
-
Philippa J Martin 4 Feb 2021This Battlefield is a place of remembrance for this lost in 1746. Many families go to visit there lost ancestors. It is Sacred for many.
-
Randi Aichel 4 Feb 2021Let them Rest In Peace! They are heroes who should be memorialized for all time!
-
anna ellis 4 Feb 2021we visit scotland twice yearly
- my disabled son loves history , a castle visit every year !, we hope and pray the historical sites are left as they are now ,- wide open spaces for all to enjoy, as they were in battle. once planning laws are passed once allowing unnecessary building, there will be no end to the flood gates this will open. act now to preserve history for all FOREVER. -
Gina Stewart 4 Feb 2021Must not let this happen it's a war grave and must remain so.
-
Dayna Zarazinski 4 Feb 2021This is an important piece of Scottish history! I am descended from the Kincaid family and dream of visiting Scotland and this site is on my list of places to see.
-
Barbara Milne 4 Feb 2021Culloden should be a protected site, it is a war grave
-
elaine sisson 4 Feb 2021This is sacred ground! Do NOT disturb!
-
Stephen MacLennan 5 Feb 2021All battlefields should be given the highest degree of protection available so that there is never any building on these historical sites.
So much history has been lost to concrete jungles and it needs to stop otherwise there will be nothing to learn from. There will never be anymore knowledge to be gained from a developed battlefield, history and any future finds will be wiped out, destroyed and lost forever, this cannot and must not go on any longer.
Scottish government, please take note.
Recently, we have seen several applications be turned down, now we need to stop any developments from ever happening again. -
Laura Gilbard 5 Feb 2021I've visited the battlefield a few times and find it horrifying that housing units would be built around it. This land is sacred and is the resting place of the Highlanders.
-
Kayla Seddon 5 Feb 2021My dream is to visit this place. Please do not destroy it!
-
Melissa Little 5 Feb 2021This is beyond ridiculous!! This is a mass grave and a historical place! To even consider this is unbelievable!!
-
Caitlin Miller 5 Feb 2021It is totally unacceptable that Scotland's battlefields are not protected from development. Especially Culloden. The law needs to be changed so that Scotland's history is protected. It should not be up to individuals to continually lobby and protect these sites. It is shameful, truly shameful, that this is going on. If land is needed for development, tell the Queen to hand back Balmoral.
-
Heather Binks 5 Feb 2021I believe battle fields should be treasured
-
Todd Ferguson 5 Feb 2021Better protection is required to ensure our battlefields are preserved for future generations. There is undiscovered archaeological evidence which can shed more light on these events. It is unacceptable to have creeping developments and planning applications continually challenging the boundaries. I am calling on the government to extend the policy of battlefield protection and stop further developments and applications from coming forward.
-
Wilma stuart 5 Feb 2021Culloden should be classed a World heritage site and protected for ever more. This is our history and should never be forgotten. Ruthless Developers should get nowhere near this consecrated ground. The Council should all get kicked out for even considering passing this. They should remember and listen to the people that put them there to work for their community. " SAVE CULLODEN ITS OUR HISTORY".
Should get nowhere near Culloden.