Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3701 title not published

Unlisted First activity 21 Jan 2021 Last activity 4 Mar 2021

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3701), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: grouse shooting moorland flooding moors management

Signatures
885
Comments
94
Activity window
42 days
21 Jan 2021 to 4 Mar 2021

Signatures by country

885 online signatures
  1. Scotland320 36.2%
  2. United Kingdom307 34.7%
  3. England236 26.7%
  4. Wales15 1.7%
  5. Germany2 0.2%
  6. Morocco1 0.1%
  7. Netherlands1 0.1%
  8. Not given1 0.1%
  9. Northern Ireland1 0.1%
  10. United States1 0.1%

Comments

94 comments, oldest first
94 comments · showing 1–50
  1. david mitchell 21 Jan 2021
    Ban grouse shoots.
  2. Rosslyn McNally 21 Jan 2021
    Flood prevention measures on grouse moors have the potential to provide multiple benefits for very little cost to the landowners and the public, and exponential benefits for grouse, other wildlife and obviously humans if their dwellings are protected from flooding downstream. A no brainer I feel.
  3. Jude Maxwell 21 Jan 2021
    Yes, I agree.
  4. kate maclean 21 Jan 2021
    People and wildlife before dodgy sport.
  5. Lynne Tillyard 22 Jan 2021
    Natural flood defences in these areas will become more critical as global warming intensified. Action is needed now to prevent flooding at protect homes.
  6. Joanna Findlay 22 Jan 2021
    These are all much needed actions.
  7. Stewart Love 22 Jan 2021
    Peoples homes come before shooting grouse. The moorland used for shooting should be returned to natural state to keep water from flooding down stream from the moorland.
  8. peter regan 23 Jan 2021
    I live near Hebden bridge in Yorkshire, this is the same scenario that happens here, a fantastic group
    of people called siow the flow find natural ways to do
    just that. Unfortunately much of their hard work is undone, by having a intensely managed grouse moor
    at the head of the valley at Walshaw. Owned by the rich for the rich and sod everybody downstream of them.
  9. David Pritchard 23 Jan 2021
    An absolute yes, rather than as now degrading the land as at present.
  10. Judith Jones 23 Jan 2021
    The future of our wildlife, our wild places and our climate is at stake. Grouse moors are for the benefit of a privileged few, but are detrimental to the environment and the majority of people. We are at a crucial time and must put the environment before profit and bloodlust.
  11. Peter Kemp 24 Jan 2021
    If we consider ourselves to be civilised this needs to be done with some urgency.
  12. Alex Milne 25 Jan 2021
    I'd rather that driven grouse shooting was banned, but a strong set of licence conditions to limit the damage to biodiversity and the environment may be an acceptable start.
  13. Roger Sanderson 25 Jan 2021
    Why are arable farmers not allowed to burn stubble and straw, when grouse moors can burn heather?
  14. Paul Fisher 25 Jan 2021
    Considering any future land use must benefit the many, not the few as at present.
  15. Lance Moore 25 Jan 2021
    Burning moorland is outrageous
  16. Peter McHugh 25 Jan 2021
    Good Luck
  17. Jacqueline tingay 25 Jan 2021
    It would seem obvious that people and property should be protected as far as possible against allowing a select few to despoil the land for the sole purpose of killing wild life.
  18. Harry Bickerstaff 25 Jan 2021
    This is long overdue and puts human beings and their living conditions, ahead of increased Red Grouse productivity.
  19. Angus maciver 25 Jan 2021
    I totally agree with the comments for putting forward this petition
  20. Finn Weddle 25 Jan 2021
    The land belongs to the nation before it belongs to private owners, and the nation's interest must be in protecting its people before protecting it businesses. If business is disturbing people's right to safe and secure housing, or damaging public infrastructure downstream of its activities, it is the moral duty of the state to regulate these businesses to protect these rights. If there are any flood risks associated with grouse moor management, it is imperative that grouse moor licensing is contingent on active and concerted flood mitigation efforts by the estate managers.
  21. Colin Hyde 25 Jan 2021
    We desperately need a licensing system to control the archaic land use currently employed by the grouse-shooting industry. It should also be the first step to a wider debate about the whole future of the rural economy in Scotland being pursued in a more environmentally aware basis.
  22. Peter Kemp 25 Jan 2021
    It's time to introduce responsibility to everyone especially large landowners. Whatever happened to land reform? More long grass.
  23. Bob Downie 25 Jan 2021
    No one should be allowed to manage land without considering the effects on people outwith the management area. Flooding resulting from poor management of upland moorland areas is well-known and thus a water management plan must be a condition for the award of a grouse moorland licence.
  24. Nigel Jennings 25 Jan 2021
    The severe environmental damage caused by common grouse moor management practices is often overshadowed by wildlife persecution issues. It must not be overlooked.
  25. Pete Etheridge 25 Jan 2021
    This is an excellent idea and would help to alleviate flood damage and enhance wildlife.
  26. Christopher Hill 25 Jan 2021
    Would like to see our wildlife protected and our landscapes managed in a way that encourages biodiversity.
  27. Stewart Love 25 Jan 2021
    I's long past time that natural flood prevention should have happened years ago.
  28. Ian Clarke 25 Jan 2021
    Good luck
  29. Nick Moyes 25 Jan 2021
    It is essential that management of upland areas for shooting for sport takes into consideration the immense potential impact of that activity on communities living downstream. Mis-management (i.e. severe over-management) just for gamebird shooting must prevented in any licencing scheme so that the Natural Capital Asset that is upland peatlands are maintained for the good of everyone, and not just managed so as to profit a relatively small number of landowners.
  30. Conrad Auten 25 Jan 2021
    Stop using our money to enable rich people to practise recreational blood sports and to mismanage our land.
  31. Erica Beeforth 25 Jan 2021
    I would support the conditions you explained, before licences are granted.
  32. Edward O'Donnelly 25 Jan 2021
    Heather burning is a redundant
  33. Tony Burn 25 Jan 2021
    Flooding is only going to get worse and burning moorland will speed this up.
  34. Malcolm Scott 25 Jan 2021
    We should also ban shooting birds for fun. It's disgusting.
  35. Robert Bailey 25 Jan 2021
    It's a complete no-brainer. So let's hope that the politicians can see this!
  36. Neil Robertson 25 Jan 2021
    At present the many suffer so the few can have a day out killing wee birds. Surely they must pay the full environmental cost for their dirty hobby.
  37. Peter Hack 25 Jan 2021
    Trees whether by rewilding or tree planting also contribute to mitigating climate change which is a key inetre Governmental ambition if in mosaics of habitat that increases diversity.
  38. Judith Smith 25 Jan 2021
    You've only to look at Calderdale and the flooding there to see the effects of moorland burning.
  39. Caroline McManus 25 Jan 2021
    Long past time this destructive and immensely costly
    - costly to our mental and physical health, environment and nature-activity was taxed out of existence.
  40. Colin Pattenden 25 Jan 2021
    Please put an end to these ridiculous practices that are so bad for climate change.
  41. Tim Crozier-Cole 25 Jan 2021
    Common sense.
  42. Nadia Fox 25 Jan 2021
    All shooting should be banned.
  43. Tim Geeson 25 Jan 2021
    Land Stewardship is a privilege which needs to be exercised rationally. The grouse moors of the UK are wonderful and special habitat but the necessity to develop a more effective and environmental solutions is required in the 21st century.
  44. Alan Davis 25 Jan 2021
    Stop messing with nature.
  45. Janet Hoptroff 26 Jan 2021
    The best solution to so many ills would be to ban driven grouse shooting completely.
  46. RICHARD LESLIE ANTCLIFF 26 Jan 2021
    if you believe climate change will make our winters much wetter then every thing should be done to prevent flooding of homes and businesses.
  47. Jim Dawson 26 Jan 2021
    Grouse moors need water so controlled burning is not a problem so far as flooding is concerned.
    The problem lies with forest plantations where run off ditches are cut to allow the land to drain.
    Grouse moors prevent flooding downstream.
  48. Hazel Greenstiles 26 Jan 2021
    Grouse shooting destroys raptors as well, should be banned.
  49. Boyd Johnston 26 Jan 2021
    Driven grouse shooting should be banned. All game bird shooting should be licensed. Estates where raptors disappear ore found dead should lose any licences. There should be incentives to re-wild moorland.
  50. Donald McPhillimy 26 Jan 2021
    Got to get our priorities right. Having been flooded once, I know how awful it is.