Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3545 title not published

Unlisted First activity 16 Jul 2020 Last activity 28 Aug 2020

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3545), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: beavers wildlife killing species animals relocate

Signatures
16,912
Comments
1,326
Activity window
43 days
16 Jul 2020 to 28 Aug 2020

Signatures by country

16,912 online signatures
  1. England5,688 33.6%
  2. Scotland5,367 31.7%
  3. United Kingdom4,449 26.3%
  4. Wales389 2.3%
  5. United States327 1.9%
  6. Australia68 0.4%
  7. Northern Ireland66 0.4%
  8. France64 0.4%
  9. Netherlands63 0.4%
  10. Ireland60 0.4%
  11. 57 other countries371 2.2%

Comments

1,326 comments, oldest first
1,326 comments · showing 1–50
  1. Elvera Geen 16 Jul 2020
    The licences given to kill beavers (a protected species) are a joke, giving farmers freedom to murder as many as they like, ridiculous and shameful. Beavers are a wonderful addition to our landscape, improving biodiversity and habitat creation.
  2. Tommy Moore 16 Jul 2020
    Lots of suitable environment to look at before lethal controls ever need to be considered.
  3. John Allen 16 Jul 2020
    I am very pleased to be able to support such a worthy cause for beavers and for the environment.
  4. Edward Hurst 16 Jul 2020
    It is complete madness to cull these creatures when a sensible and practical alternative is available. This is almost as bad as New Zealand dropping 1080 to control possums and killing everything by doing so. Scotland has the opportunity to support Beavers and has the greatest potential for ecological restoration.
  5. David Gibbon 16 Jul 2020
    It is disgraceful that ScotGov is taking the opposite view and has dragged its feet in regard to beaver reintroduction from the start. This is not to say that farmers do not face very real difficulties but these difficulties should be managed with the help of the tool of translocation and of non lethal mitigation. Recourse to lethal control is wholly inappropriate at this very early stage in the reintroduction of the species and threatens the viability of the whole project, as is the intention of some of the vested interests.

    Far from giving in to these interests ScotGov should be imposing limits on how close to riparian areas it is permissible to farm or otherwise exploit natural habitat.

    As a we face climate and species extinction emergencIes this keystone species should be permitted and encouraged to proliferate and vested interests should be faced down.

    It is disgraceful that ScotGov is taking the opposite view and has dragged its feet in regard to beaver reintroduction from the start. This is not to say that farmers do not face very real difficulties but these difficulties should be managed with the help of the tool of translocation and of non we lethal mitigation. Recourse to lethal control is wholly inappropriate at this very early stage in the reintroduction of the species and threatens the viability of the whole project, as is the intention of some of the vested interests.

    Far from giving in to these interests ScotGov should be imposing limits on how close to riparian areas it is permissible to farm or otherwise exploit natural habitat.
  6. Hugh Chalmers 16 Jul 2020
    Please allow beavers to spread to suitable areas where they will restore wetland habitats
  7. Nicola MacLeod 16 Jul 2020
    As well as being a unique and important reintroduced species, beavers are such an environmental asset that killing them is sher madness. They provide and construct incredible wet land habitat hugely increasing biodiversity but they alo are natural engineers of flood mitigation. Please don't allow another single beaver to be killed. If they are not wanted in one place somewhere else will definitely want them so trap them and move them.
  8. Roz Brooks 16 Jul 2020
    Why reintroduce a species just to kill them? Doesn't make sense?
  9. Victoria Grenfell 16 Jul 2020
    Please leave our previous wildlife alone. Nature balances itself.
  10. RAYMOND&PEARL BELL 16 Jul 2020
    Please stop the Cull!
  11. Nicola Gowers 17 Jul 2020
    This plan makes perfetc sense. It is ludicrous that so many beavers are being killed so soon after their reintroduction to Scotland. This must change.
  12. Debby mcilquham 17 Jul 2020
    We must protect these wild animals as they have the right to live.
  13. Pauline Dvies 17 Jul 2020
    Why bring them back to cull them? Amazing creatures, learn to live with them!
  14. Linda Harries 17 Jul 2020
    Leave the widelife alone.
  15. GEN SAMSON 17 Jul 2020
    It is not acceptable or ethical to reintroduce a species only to cull when it does what any species does!
  16. Sharon nicol 17 Jul 2020
    Please do not cul the beaver now they have been reintraduced back into scotland after you hunted them to extinction.
  17. Jan Lunsford 17 Jul 2020
    humans killing wildlife so we can have their habitat, WRONG! let's live with nature, biodiversity.
  18. Paul Hawkins 17 Jul 2020
    Please relocate the Beavers for the good of the environment. Thank you.
  19. Karen Swan 17 Jul 2020
    Please be compassionate. This cull is not necessary.
  20. Carol Reith 17 Jul 2020
    Living in rural Angus I have seen the destruction that beavers cause.
  21. Jenny Pearson 17 Jul 2020
    Beavers across Scotland will boost biodiversity by creating fantastically rich wetland sites. In the times of an ecological crisis and in one of the most nature depleted countries in the world, beavers will be hugely beneficial. Also in combatting climate change related flooding, beavers will slow and steady water flows, protecting homes, businesses and lives. Beavers are a super animal and they belong I'm scotland.
  22. Paul Fisher 17 Jul 2020
    Reintroducing beavers costs money, taxpayers money. Licensing their culling also cost taxpayers money. Apart from being inefficient it is also brainless.
  23. JAYNE Kettles 17 Jul 2020
    Leave the beavers alone
  24. Allan Bantick OBE 17 Jul 2020
    Whilst limiting the range of the unofficial beavers in the east of Scotland may have seemed an appropriate measure at the time, matters have moved on. There is an appetite in other parts of Scotland with suitable beaver habitat for this native species to return and so move threatened beavers from the east of Scotland to these new sites now seems perfectly sensible.
  25. James Nairne 17 Jul 2020
    Expanding beaver presence helps fight climate change and biodiversity loss. Translocating them to suitable new areas is such an obvious step
  26. Sandra Strathie 17 Jul 2020
    Please bring this cruelty to an end. What the point of reintroducing an animal then hunting it. Education required.
  27. Louise Ramsay 17 Jul 2020
    Scotland, so far, has a very small number of beavers compared to most other European countries, and quarantine issues make it difficult to bring more into the UK. They are very much needed in many parts of Scotland to create and restore wetlands, to boost biodiversity in this time of crisis, and regulate water flow, reducing both flooding and drought exacerbated by climate change. There is also much scope for developing ecotourism based around beaver wetlands. When beavers are caught in conflict zones where mitigation has been shown not to work they should be relocated, not shot. As a protected species, shooting should be avoided unless no other options are available. The shooting of 87 beavers under license in 2019 has exposed a catastrophically misconceived approach and must be put right. Part of the solution is to open the rest of Scotland up to the possibility of relocation and to move more of these beavers conflict to other parts of Scotland. Farmers' organisations cannot be allowed to overly influence policy in this area. Their interests may often be in conflict with the public interest, and in this case it is in the public interest to increase the number of beavers in Scotland in the many parts of the countryside where they will bring nothing but benefits, rather than have them killed out in the low ground farms .
  28. Chris Davies 17 Jul 2020
    Come on Scotland
    - get your act together.
  29. Vaughn Khelifa 17 Jul 2020
    Abhorrent
  30. Elizabeth Ormerod 17 Jul 2020
    I am a Scottish veterinary surgeon. Beavers contribute to our ecology, so do not cull them
  31. Tony Eggeling 17 Jul 2020
    Killing beavers should not even be under consideration. Isn't the whole idea meant to be re-introduction and not falling back on extermination at the first hurdle?
  32. Juliet Conway 17 Jul 2020
    The issuing of the licence is a disgrace and the animals should have trapped and rereleased. A real disgrace and shows that the beavers were reintroduced with little consultation to landowners!
  33. Lynne Hardeman 17 Jul 2020
    Please try to relocate protected the Beaver community outside its range to minimise need to kill them
  34. Janie Faulkner 17 Jul 2020
    The reintroduction of beavers in Scotland has been a huge success but we need to prevent any further licenses being given unnecessarily. Relocation has to be the preferred option.
  35. Evelyn McIntosh 17 Jul 2020
    This is disgusting, please let it stop asap!!
  36. Matilda Scharsach 17 Jul 2020
    The loophole in the law that has enabled the widespread killing of beavers to continue makes any so called protection that they have absolutely meaningless. The Scottish government is truly committed to conservation and all the biodiversity benefits that they bring, then they will close this loophole and give beavers the genuine protection that they deserve.
  37. susan fleming 17 Jul 2020
    Stop killing beavers in Scotland!
  38. Trudi Ford 17 Jul 2020
    Please fix this
  39. Jo Cartmell 18 Jul 2020
    The UK was one of the last countries in Europe to reintroduce beavers. We need to translocate them not cull them. We are probably the only country doing this!
  40. Ian Whittaker 18 Jul 2020
    Translocation has to be the most environmentally sensible & beneficial option rather than the knee-jerk cull
  41. Cameron Woodall 18 Jul 2020
    Beavers are ecosystem engineers that can have a huge positive impact on the natural environment, providing unique wildlife habitats and improving watercourses. They need to be protected instead of killed and are a valuable wildlife asset to Scotland, but are in a fragile state with low numbers.
  42. Sharon Lashley 18 Jul 2020
    Please try and help these animals co-exist alongside society. They are amazing ecosystems engineers as well as highly intelligent creatures.
  43. David Stevens 18 Jul 2020
    Scotland needs nature based solutions to the climate and nature emergency. Beavers can help. Please don't kill them, relocate them!
  44. Karl Mullee 18 Jul 2020
    Had the good fortune to visit Knapdale where they have the Beavers and learned an awful lot. They get a bad press, but in actual fact their industrious Ness helps to guard against flooding in some flood hit areas by limiting the flow of water downstream. So they can act as a natural flood barrier.
    In Knapdale this isn't such an issue. Originally neighbouring farms opposed their introduction, but in actual fact, once leaving the previous territory, moving on to where they are now: the soil quality in that previous territory was far better as a consequence of their activities, much more nutrient rich, so the farmer received a benefit also of their endeavours. They can be of huge benefit, both to homeowners and farmers, if we overcome the prejudices and false headlines of those with an agenda to not have them.
  45. Kay Kelly 18 Jul 2020
    Beavers are a keystone species, and their work reduces flood risk more effectively than the far more expensive measures sometimes employed.
  46. Amy Kapherr-Diament 18 Jul 2020
    relocate
  47. Anne Rogers 18 Jul 2020
    I think Beavers have an important place in managing flood risk with climate change.
  48. Anne Rogers 18 Jul 2020
    Beavers are important in managing flood risk in climate change
  49. Caroline Mellor 19 Jul 2020
    Please protect the beavers!
  50. Elaine Martay 19 Jul 2020
    Beavers are good for biodiversity and flood control.