Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3469 title not published

Unlisted First activity 26 Mar 2020 Last activity 6 May 2020

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3469), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: remote traffic control hial jobs islands safety

Signatures
663
Comments
44
Activity window
41 days
26 Mar 2020 to 6 May 2020

Signatures by country

663 online signatures
  1. Scotland507 76.5%
  2. United Kingdom144 21.7%
  3. England11 1.7%
  4. Denmark1 0.2%

Comments

44 comments, oldest first
  1. Murray Taylor 26 Mar 2020
    An atrocious decision that may well have severe safety implications
  2. Susan Macaulay 26 Mar 2020
    The thought of cutting back our air traffic control is very worrying. It cannot happen !
  3. Irene morrison 26 Mar 2020
    All the very best with this
  4. Alan Bews 27 Mar 2020
    Whilst I understand, and agree with, the need for modenisation including Surveillance and CAS, the "REMOTE" part of the programme offers NO increase in safety..in fact quite the opposite!!
  5. Pete Walker 27 Mar 2020
    The Wick airport is a lifeline for so many in the community. The Scottish government have failed to invest in Caithness for many years and a potential airport closure will be another major service to go, along with others. The government should step in and act NOW, this would protect jobs, help the local economy and still give the local community the needed service. Caithness is becoming more and more cut-off from the rest of Scotland.
  6. Neil Lyon 27 Mar 2020
    Centralisation is not the solution.
  7. Kathleen Macleod 28 Mar 2020
    This service needs to be kept local
  8. John Morrison 28 Mar 2020
    These proposals will have a devastating effect on our local communities and is not under "Island Proofing" as set out by the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018.
  9. Chrissie Macaskill 28 Mar 2020
    Done
  10. Seonaidh MacDonald 28 Mar 2020
    Seriously flawed idea in my opinion and the timing of it is all wrong. One wonders as to the REAL motives and indeed 'agenda' behind this proposed change? Island economies are fragile at the best of times and employment sits at the core of this. Proposals like this do nothing to mitigate that fragility and should be resisted robustly.
  11. Colin Brand 28 Mar 2020
    Cost cutting exercise, safety a long way second.
  12. Colin Davidson 28 Mar 2020
    Losing this service indicates we, as a country, are going back into the dark ages and that this government will not support local communities
  13. Donald MacPherson 29 Mar 2020
    Our islands are fragile enough. Population decline is really worrying. The ATMS project is not helping with this.
  14. Loriana Pauli 29 Mar 2020
    Don't centralise. Jobs too important for island life
  15. Marjorie lang 30 Mar 2020
    The plane is a life line for the community
  16. Vic Thomas 31 Mar 2020
    Every time you close a school, business, facility etc involving jobs in a small local community on an island, remote or rural area, you further marginalise vulnerable communities. When this reaches a critical mass you would need to close the island, village or area & relocate to the areas your centrailsineg to. Is this nthe Scotland you want? Its not the Scotland i want.
  17. Alistair Easton 31 Mar 2020
    I am far from convinced that the telecommunications links between Inverness and the Islands can be 100% secure.
    I also strongly object to the ATC jobs being taken from the islands and centralised in Inverness.
  18. Sue Wailoo 31 Mar 2020
    This needs to be looked at again . We don't have reliable connectivity yet in Shetland, we have weather events unlike those on the mainland, we are very exposed, what about emergencies. This is our lifeline service and proposals are unsafe
  19. Roy Longmuir 31 Mar 2020
    If the communications facilities are robust enough for HIAL to consider remote operations then the centre should be in Sumburgh, thus creating much needed jobs and showing government commitment to helping island communities create jobs
  20. David Miller 31 Mar 2020
    Centralisation does not enhance safety and will result in a loss of flexibility compared with on site controllers. Communities need good quality jobs and reliable infrastructure in order to be sustainable. This project offers no benefits in any of these areas.
  21. Michael Bilton 1 Apr 2020
    The islands of Scotland ARE an integral part of the country. Saving money where passenger safety is concerned is shocking. Often planes in these islands can land in difficult conditions when line of sight control is available on the ground. Remote control is farcical in the islands, a truly idiotic idea. You are going to get many many fights turned back for no good reason and possibly bankrupt local airlines. The other possibility is a crash caused by a mistaken remote decision leading to many fatalities. The litigation would be horrendous. Drop this mad idea now. I have been visiting Shetland for 35 years, and Orkney, Fair Isle and Benbecular for even longer. Stop now. Stop making people deeply anxious. Scottish Island culture is unique in the world. Don't ruin their economies like this.
  22. Peter Long 1 Apr 2020
    I really can't see how this is societal progress. Taking keys regional jobs, and centralising them. Sacrificing safety in the name of cost saving. The costs of air traffic control should be paid for by the passengers. We do not need to lower the costs of air travel to promote more planes in the air. Surely there is not a good enough reason to push this through beyond saving some money.
  23. Robert Paddock 1 Apr 2020
    As a 20 year veteran IFR controller and ATC Automation Specialist, I'll be the first to agree that technological advancements are allowing some great new innovations in aviation. However I also believe that moving too quickly on remote tower automation could be very damaging to the industry. Once you remove the on field human intervention, you reduce your capacity to react to unplanned events and operational irregularities. Not to mention the decrease in pilot confidence in and around your airport. Too much too fast HIAL, take this back to the drafting table, for everyone's peace of mind.
  24. Michael Bennett 2 Apr 2020
    We are currently living in a world where hindsight would have been a wonderful thing, given the pandemic. Let us avoid having to repeat this mantra when the very obvious issues with the 'Air Traffic Management Strategy Project' come home to roost. Act now, not when it is too late.
  25. Peter Shearer 2 Apr 2020
    This plan is totally unnecessary, unlikely to bring any improvement to services and is damaging to the local communities and economies.
  26. Donald R MacDonald 2 Apr 2020
    Jobs count just as much in Benbecula etc as in Inverness.
  27. Frank Pole 5 Apr 2020
    Sumburgh airport frequently has some of the worst weather of any airport in UK, with gales, rain and low cloud in the winter and fog in the summer. The terrain surrounding the airport adds additional risk, especially to fixed wing aircraft.

    Aircraft accidents usually are due to a chain of events coming together, often likened to the holes in a Swiss cheese lining up. If an aircraft has a serious malfunction on a day of evil weather, and the proposed remote Air Traffic comms at Inverness go down at the critical moment, an aircraft emergency could turn into a disaster.

    The HIAL must be persuaded to abandon this risky policy which is a real threat to a lifeline service.
  28. yvonne bryan 5 Apr 2020
    slow drip towards bringing service in a downward spiral for the islands travel
  29. Elizabeth Davidson 5 Apr 2020
    I strongly object on the basis of safety, reliability and the loss of local jobs
  30. Fiona Celli 5 Apr 2020
    What plans are in place should the internet connection break down? This is not uncommon in remote areas.
  31. John Gray 5 Apr 2020
    Centralising ATC makes the system less resilient. Jobs are far more valuable located in remote communities, & especially such highly skilled types.
  32. Ingirid Windwick Jolly 5 Apr 2020
    Too many vital services are being centralised to one or two centres in Britain with loss of local knowledge and observations
  33. Ian MacLeod 6 Apr 2020
    Insane idea taken with no regard for safety whatsoever. Madness!
  34. Linda Hamilton 6 Apr 2020
    Confidence, security, flexibility, local nous, employment and sense of worth in a tight knit community. Anything else is less.
  35. VIVIENNE WILSON 6 Apr 2020
    Please, for all our safety, halt the transfer to Inverness
  36. Angus MacDonald 7 Apr 2020
    Absolutely diabolical idea no regards towards people's safety madness of the first degree
  37. Stuart Smith 14 Apr 2020
    This proposal is ridiculous. If it is such a great idea then why dont we turn this idea on its head and "control" HIALs airports from the islands? After all Scotlands political foundations are entwined in supporting the remote regions. Get a grip HIAL!
  38. Jim McEleny 15 Apr 2020
    Safety before profit. Scottish Government must get involved and engage with unions particularly Prospect, who know have members with skills and expertise in this field.
  39. Marie shearer 20 Apr 2020
    I believe this is a safety issue and should be abandoned. It will also remove high paid jobs on the islands
  40. Andrew Mackintosh 20 Apr 2020
    Centralising services not for efficiency but to allow closer political control.
  41. Calvin Allen 21 Apr 2020
    How long must remote communities continue to suffer from this outside-in perspective which takes away the services which help bind us together?
  42. Paul Horth 23 Apr 2020
    In addition to the loss of jobs in remote communities it will introduce large areas of controlled airspace in remote areas of Scotland that will impact General Aviation in particular.
  43. Brian Robertson 2 May 2020
    We should be trying to decentralise highly paid jobs from the Central Belt. This is doing the opposite.
  44. Frances Valente - Clerk 5 May 2020
    Lerwick Community Council has serious concerns about the safety issues relating to the remote air traffic control service that is proposed by HIAL.