Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3312 title not published

Unlisted First activity 14 Aug 2019 Last activity 23 Sep 2019

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3312), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: data social media police raptors monitoring crimes

Signatures
1,812
Comments
23
Activity window
40 days
14 Aug 2019 to 23 Sep 2019

Signatures by country

1,812 online signatures
  1. Scotland942 52%
  2. England540 29.8%
  3. United Kingdom262 14.5%
  4. Wales39 2.2%
  5. Northern Ireland14 0.8%
  6. Ireland5 0.3%
  7. Belgium2 0.1%
  8. Australia1 0.1%
  9. Spain1 0.1%
  10. Switzerland1 0.1%
  11. 5 other countries5 0.3%

Comments

23 comments, oldest first
  1. Leif Brag 15 Aug 2019
    Must be done if we are to have any trust in the system.
    Things cannot continue the way it is.
  2. R Neil Theodoreson 15 Aug 2019
    This is required so that those tagging can't be accused of with holding information or tampering with the information gathered. It is only fair that this data is open and scrutable.
  3. M Porter 15 Aug 2019
    Quite why the Police are not insisting on all the historical tag data for a minimum period of 6 months prior to the tag failure in any alleged wildlife crime is a question in itself. Under disclosure law I would see this as necessary for the investigation and would robustly challenge any conviction or indeed initial investigation based on tag data from a short period of time. In criminal law all exculpatory evidence must be available in fairness to any suspect or accused to ensure fairness to an accused (a cornerstone of Scots law often ignored by groups with agendas).
  4. Ian Macphee 15 Aug 2019
    Time it was transparent
  5. Lindsay Bell 15 Aug 2019
    Independent body is the only way forward. All to often evidence is withheld from police by people and groups with ulterior motives.
  6. Alan James Parr 15 Aug 2019
    This needs to be monitored by the police who should have an open mind as to who are committing these crimes. The perpetrators should be dealt with robustly whoever they are.
    Also misleading comments without sound evidence should also be dealt with. Many people are being branded wrongly I believe and it is affecting their lives as well as their families.
  7. Gareth Mann 15 Aug 2019
    Grouse moors are under increasing attack using data generated by these tracking devices. Its only fair that all interested parties should have access to this data.
  8. Bill Cowie 15 Aug 2019
    There are many reasons for signing this petition, the independant experts are responsible for much disturbance of nests which go unrecorded and the fitting of any foreign body to a wild animal is in itself wrong, these animals were not designed to carry bits of plastic on their bodies, for what purpose?
  9. Martyn O'Reilly 15 Aug 2019
    Get rid of any doubts and have the raptors independently monitored . This will get rid of disinformation and lead to a sensible discussion about the future of the countryside
  10. Martin Kay 15 Aug 2019
    Independent custody and verification of tag data by Police Scotland will improve reaction times to suspected crimes and remove the potential for misuse of data for political or campaign purposes. The cost impact will not be significant as at present there is likely to be a significant cost impact in obtaining and assessing data. Standardisation of data format will also confer efficiency benefits.
  11. Steve Evans 15 Aug 2019
    Need level playing field to counter all the trials by social media
  12. Falconer Wallace 15 Aug 2019
    I wholeheartedly support this petition to pit an end to unproven accusations
  13. Paul Robinson 15 Aug 2019
    This monitoring must be introduced to aid in the crimes concerning raptor specied
  14. Denis John Valentine 15 Aug 2019
    Action must be taken NOW.
  15. Terry Baker 15 Aug 2019
    Sick of the lies and false accusations of the RSPB and other organisations
  16. Kevin Atchison 15 Aug 2019
    We need total transpatency needs to be an independant party.
  17. David Cater 15 Aug 2019
    Needed to. Void false data being used against people employed in the countryside
  18. iain crosbie 15 Aug 2019
    More transparency is needed regarding the tagging of raptors
  19. Daniel 15 Aug 2019
    Monitoring should be carried out by independent Impartial bodies and not by one sided organisations with hidden agendas
  20. Colin Lavin 15 Aug 2019
    In the interests of fairness and openness sattelite tag data must be made available to the public and especially to the Police when birds go missing or are found dead
  21. Donald S Wright 15 Aug 2019
    Unbiased evidence required.
  22. Alistair Meikle 15 Aug 2019
    We definitely need an independent organisation to monitor raptors to avoid any misinformation going on social media
  23. Charlotte Webb 15 Aug 2019
    Without independent monitoring there is too much room for alteration, lack of recording, tampering. Any data needs to be correct and in order.