Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 3014 title not published

Unlisted First activity 3 May 2018 Last activity 13 Jun 2018

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 3014), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: named person legislation public inquiry intrusive data children

Signatures
1,488
Comments
209
Activity window
41 days
3 May 2018 to 13 Jun 2018

Signatures by country

1,488 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,069 71.8%
  2. United Kingdom355 23.9%
  3. England47 3.2%
  4. Wales6 0.4%
  5. United States4 0.3%
  6. Isle of Man3 0.2%
  7. Japan1 0.1%
  8. Jersey1 0.1%
  9. Northern Ireland1 0.1%
  10. Ireland1 0.1%

Comments

209 comments, oldest first
209 comments · showing 1–50
  1. Clare Chalmers. 3 May 2018
    So many families have been abused by unlawful data sharing. Practitioners remain confused to this day and still abuse the law. Who authorised this? Why was this allowed to happen against the data protection act of 1998? Why have the ico not informed organisations they gave out unlawful information in the first place? It has been left to families to correct organisations and bring them back in line with the law. It is not good enough. We deserve answers and those badly affected should be entitled to compensation.
    This must never be allowed to happen again.
  2. Tristram Llewellyn Jones 3 May 2018
    This whole slippery business of extracting personal information needs to be comprehensively stopped.

    Why not have consent based public services that actually provide what people want instead?

    That would be a much better proposition for all concerned.
  3. Catherine Stirton 3 May 2018
    Well done for highlighting this issue and for standing up to the Scottish Governments half baked attempts at deciding a viable policy on this issue. They have caused untold misery with their actions and distress to children and parents they are supposed to be protecting.
  4. Ian Meikle 5 May 2018
    Not before time!!!
  5. Marie Harris 5 May 2018
    The Named Persons Scheme and GIRFEC clearly violates the Human Right to a Family Life, free from State interference, and MUST BE STOPPED !
  6. Steven McLaughlin 6 May 2018
    The suffering the State is imposing on we the people will no longer be tolirated with the HAMMER of the SCOTS
  7. Catherine spink-white 7 May 2018
    Given the subjective opinions of many of the people involved I find the named person totally and an absolute danger to children and families alike
  8. Patricia Hewitt. 8 May 2018
    I totally agree and have seen evidence first hand of this happening , myself included . I was the main Petitioner of PEO1625 re Pathological Demand Avoidance where Parental Blame due to poor parenting is the norm . Children taken into care , families destroyed due to malicious accusations amongst Professionals . Families left past crisis point due to an appaling understanding of the Autism Spectrum by so many .By my experience and so many others Educations Laws , GIRFEC , and the Wellbeing Wheel and not worth the paper they are written on . GIRFEC is certainly not happening and is in breech of Human Rights .
  9. George McCann 8 May 2018
    South Lanarkshire Council deliberately broke DPA and Councillors Code of Conduct and nobody cares, South Lanarkshire Council are as far away from GIRFEC as possible to the point they seem to think it means Getting It Right For Every COUNCIL.
  10. Marie Mccann 8 May 2018
    Full review to highlight failings is overdue
  11. Shona donnelly 8 May 2018
    Wholeheartedly support this petition
  12. Bill Casey 8 May 2018
    While protecting children is important, this legislation uses these real concerns as an excuse to require us all, adults and children, to give up our rights to privacy and autonomy, and give the state unwarranted rights to intrude into our private family lives.

    This is just another step towards the erosion of the family unit and reduces our children to nothing more than a state-owned commodity.
  13. Clare Chalmers 9 May 2018
    Why on Earth was the data protection act overridden & ignored? Who gave the green light? Why will SG not release the legal advice they were given at the time? Why did the ico promote this illegal activity? Will victims get an apology, compensation?
    Why has it been left to citizens such as myself to hold organisations to account, enforcing the law changing what they promote on websites and in practice? This should be the responsibility of the ico. They should have ensured organisations were made aware their original advice was unlawful especially following the SC ruling but failed to do so.
    Only an independent public inquiry will address these questions and more if you wish to rebuild trust in the system and move forward.
  14. Katherine Mcinnes 9 May 2018
    Couldn't agree and support this petition more as if someone shared information regarding my children without my consent I would definately have something to say about it. These acts have an impact on family's lives and health and I've witnessed it.
  15. Wayne Sutherland 10 May 2018
    Shocking piece of legislation that clearly breaches the human rights and privacy of every family in scotland . We need a full public inquiry to find out why the govt are so keen to disregard our human rights despite the supreme court ruling.
  16. Ann Calder 10 May 2018
    Insulting, intrusive piece of legislation
  17. Carol-anne Murray 10 May 2018
    100%
  18. Kenneth baker 10 May 2018
    Glad to put my name to stopping this filthy rubbish
  19. Louise Nicolson 11 May 2018
    Totalitarian nonsense. The State does not have our childrens wellbeing at heart, but is blinded by its own Power. Disgusting waste of resources at the taxpayers expense. Scotland calls for responsibility and accountability .
  20. Aaron Martin 12 May 2018
    A totally fascist move to control the population and manipulate individual families. Tyrannical!
  21. Michel Lhombreaud 12 May 2018
    Down with big government!
  22. Anita woods 12 May 2018
    Me and my family have been victims of this .... It was, still is and will always be absolute torture to live with.
    Knowing there's more families than just us going through what we're going through sends shivers down my spine.
    The people who ruined our lives must be held responsible for what they did.
    My kids lives are ruined! :(
  23. Tom Reilly 12 May 2018
    Couldn't agree and support this petition more as if someone shared information regarding my children without my consent I would definately have something to say about it. These acts have an impact on family's lives and health and I've witnessed it.
  24. Richard Loup 12 May 2018
    There is never justification nor excuse for bad new laws. NHS Scotland waiting time guarantee, anyone?
  25. Bill Goodall 12 May 2018
    Although I am in my sixties and my children are thankfully old enough not to be affected by this draconian scheme, I still feel it important that any right thinking person should speak out in fierce opposition. I would urge fellow citizens of all ages and backgrounds to make their views known.
  26. John Barrie Saunders 12 May 2018
    An approach from any Named Person to my family would give rise to further social division through a somewhat frank exchange of views
    - not advisable.
  27. Gerard mc VEIGH 12 May 2018
    Legislation that needs to be challenged,intrusive # .
  28. Andrena Crawford 12 May 2018
    Shocking piece of legislation.
  29. Laura Riley 12 May 2018
    The Government should be held to account for a nasty piece of authoritarian legislation which should never have passed on to the Statute book.
  30. Brian Rattray 12 May 2018
    this disgraceful NP situation needs to be binned & the SNP held accountable for all failings
  31. Derek Fox 12 May 2018
    Just to add my support in getting this distasteful legislation put to bed for good.
  32. Ian Meiklejohn 12 May 2018
    Interfering Nanny state
  33. angela gavin 12 May 2018
    Intrusive piece of legislation. I want reassurance that information has not been shared on my family without my consent.
  34. Anne Rae 12 May 2018
    Government flying in the face if pubkic opinion.. again
  35. Bill Jarvie 12 May 2018
    Surely this will be the beginning of the end for this utter totalitarian nonsense, and the typical product of this 'wee pretendy parliament'?
  36. Catherine Andrews 12 May 2018
    The doggedness of the SNP to push this legislation through regardless is frightening and they should mot be allowed to get it through
  37. Marjory Bissett 12 May 2018
    Shocking this was allowed to happen at all
  38. Andrew Pointer 12 May 2018
    There does need to be an independent inquiry into the GIRFEC and Named Policy section of the CYP Act was passed, when it was patently obvious to all that it was contrary to the Data Protection Act. Our MSPs and government lawyers, local authority lawyers, and the Scottish justiciary all failed to competently scrutenise the legislation before it was passed by Holyrood. And some councils are still citing unlawful guidance (Ken MacDonald's 2013 letter) about data sharing to their staff to this day.
  39. Bruce Luffman 12 May 2018
    The SNP Government talk about a power grab by Westminster with regard to Brexit, yet this proposed legislation is a blatent attempt to to get total central control and treading all over our family rights.
  40. Jean P A Giusti 12 May 2018
    The Scottish government has no right and no democratic mandate to intrude on the lives of families with their proposed GIRFEC scheme and is behaving in an exceedingly authoritarian way not unlike totalitarian regimes. They need to sort out the NHS and allow families to bring up their children without unqualified and unaccountable state spies causing unnecessary disruption to their lives.
  41. William McDowell 12 May 2018
    As a concerned grandparent I find the whole idea abhorrent.Big brother spying on not just the children but whole families.
  42. Betty Cosgrove 12 May 2018
    So much for data protection!
  43. Maurice Frank 12 May 2018
    All ways known from experience to any person, of getting it wrong for a child, have an automatic right to be aired as evidence.
  44. Eileen Stuart 12 May 2018
    This needs to be thrown out now
  45. Susan Nelson 12 May 2018
    This is very scary stuff. I have no responsibility for children. I wish to protect all families and professionals. Let us have no more of these off the wall unsolicited unauthorised and unsupported proposals.
  46. Drew Given 12 May 2018
    It's the parents duty to guide, teach and care for their children not the governments, the government want interfere in every situation in families life.
  47. David Bryce 12 May 2018
    The Governments proposals are totalitarian
  48. Myra Pendrich 12 May 2018
    Im completely against this Named Person scheme.
  49. Alisdair Morrison 12 May 2018
    Truely shocking proposals. These are a gross intrusion on our privacy.
  50. Muriel Leith 12 May 2018
    Disgraceful that the Scottish government are still trying to push this through in spite of massive opposition.