Petition · unlisted · Session 5
Unlisted petition 2883 title not published
This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 2883), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.
What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.
Stand-out terms in its comments: cats neutering feral kittens wildcat neutered
Signatures by country
241 online signaturesComments
41 comments, oldest first-
Ian Dunn 13 Sep 2017I am particularly concerned for the small bird and mammal population as well as the security of the native wild cat conservation programme. This approach has been implemented in other countries in europe to similar ends.
-
Gabriela Peniche 13 Sep 2017The system of pet neutering and registration similar to the Australian one can bring a multitude of benefits. Having a pet equates to a lot of responsibility and just as dog owners are expected to have dogs under control not causing nuisance to neighbours or the public, and to some extent have a grip on unwanted litters, there are similar things that can be achieved with the domestic cat population. Cats roam around on their own and as pet owners we can't control what they hunt, or where they go, but we should be able to control the damage they can cause to the environment. By neutering them we help the wild cat population and limit the number of homeless unwanted domestic cat litters.
Breeding animals should be a responsible act and a breeding licence would help with standards and welfare. -
Allan Bantick OBE 13 Sep 2017For wildcats to retain a viable population in Scotland it is essential that the flow of fertile domestic into the wild is stopped. Domestic cat owners can contribute hugely to efforts by Scottish Wildcat Action to save the wildcat by having their cats neutered. Even better, they should have their cats micro-chipped and vaccinated at the same time.
-
Alice Bacon 13 Sep 2017As a general practice vet I am only too aware of the feral cat population crisis and the health problems associated with this. Also, with an MSc in conservation vet medicine I am very aware of the ecological consequences of high feral cat population density, including the near extinction of the Scottish wildcat. Mandatory neutering all of pet cats with outdoor access would be a huge step towards taking responsibility for the impact of our pet cats, and improving the health and welfare of both pet and feral cats.
-
Dr Keri Langridge 13 Sep 2017I trap feral cats for neuter and release in both a professional capacity (as a Project Officer for Scottish Wildcat Action) and as a volunteer for my local Cats Protection branch. Once you start looking, you find that feral cats are everywhere. Their welfare standards are often very poor, particularly in large colonies. Disease can be rampant. There is an endless cycle of tiny young females struggling to cope with yet another litter of kittens, most of which will die through exposure, starvation, or predation. It is heartbreaking. TNR (Trap Neuter Return) can be an effective method of feral cat control, but it will only be effective in the long-term if we turn off the tap and stop the influx of cats into the countryside. And there is a very simple solution that is best for everyone
- best for the cat, best for the owner, best for the countryside, best for wildcats, best for feline welfare everywhere, and best for all the charities that spend all their time and money and manpower endlessly neutering and trapping and rehoming. The very simplest argument I think you can make is that up until this point, for decades and decades, animal welfare charities have poured their resources into campaigning and educating the public to make the right decision themselves, i.e. they have to convince people and rely on attitude and behavior change. They have undoubtedly had a huge impact
- and yet we still have this huge problem. There is a percentage of the population that you never reach. And so neutering should be compulsory, because it NOT being compulsory clearly isn't working. So lets give it a try! And if micro-chipping were also compulsory, it would make it far easier for anyone conducting TNR to determine whether a cat is owned or not. So even if it would be difficult to enforce, it would make Trap Neuter Return far more efficient and be an invaluable tool for those trying to work to reduce feral cats in the countryside. -
Professor Brendan Corcoran 13 Sep 2017I support this petition fully. It is in fact the exception not the rule that most cat owners elect to neuter their cats simply to avoid the inconvenience of having unneutered cats in their home. It makes perfect sense to extend to all cats not intended for breeding. The larger picture in Scotland would be to protect the wild cat population. It is remiss of us in the developed countries to criticise those in poorer countries for failing to protect their large cat populations if we can't even act to protect our own. The Scottish wild cat is as important as any of the large wild cats to biology and conservation and in fact is under greater threat than many of the iconic big cats that so engage with the public imagination. If we fail to save the Scottish wild cat, we cannot then complain of the threat of loss of threaten cat species elsewhere in the world.
-
Liz Rollinson 13 Sep 2017Neutering pet cats will limit the number of unwanted litters of kittens and minimise the suffering of animals with poor health and nutrition. It will also safeguard the future of the iconic Highland Tiger!
-
Shirley Simpson 13 Sep 2017please protect Scottish Wildcats
-
Anne MacInnes 14 Sep 2017It is vital that the domestic cat population is controlled to ensure the survival of wildcats, and help the numbers of wild birds that are currently being decimated
-
Sir John Lister-Kaye 17 Sep 2017This parliamentary action is long overdue and a vital adjunct to Scottish Wildcat Actions efforts. Cats are out of control in Scotland and we need to act now.
-
Edmund Palmer 18 Sep 2017The feral cat population in Scotland is a very major welfare challenge, and threatens the native Scottish wild cat population with extermination
-
Antje Molton 18 Sep 2017I agree that the domestic cat population needs to be controlled, but I would be totally against a cull. Chipping and neutering is an absolute must, and any responsible cat owner would have no objection to it, I am sure.
-
Gill Hulme 18 Sep 2017I own cats myself and see at first hand the impact they can have if uncontrolled. This seems a very sensible measure in view of the large feral cat population to protect wildlife in general, as well as for the well-being of the cats themselves.
-
Duncan McKenzie 18 Sep 2017I believe, as an owner of two neutered and micro-chipped cats, that it is every cat owner and potential cat owner's responsibility to ensure the welfare of any animal is paramount. That includes neutering, micro-chipping and ensuring all vaccinations are carried out. If that is cost prohibitive then serious consideration should be given to owning a cat. In addition the Scottish wildcat is critically endangered and the compulsory neutring of all cats would make a huge difference to their survival for future generations to enjoy. It would also ensure people looking for a cat can source them from a reputable breeder and they will have the piece of mind that the animal is healthy, from good stock and therefore should not result in unneccessary vet bills, outwith the norm.
-
Mr David James Catchpole 18 Sep 2017I have had 4 cats in my life and if one is not there to care and nurture them then do no have any at all as we do not own them we care for them for all our benefits.
-
Peter 18 Sep 2017Wildcat population needs to be protected
- so do populations of birds in our towns and cities: currently hammered by the domestic cat population. -
Dee Govan 18 Sep 2017There are too many domestic pets in this country and if there is conflict between wild animals and
pets we should ALWAYS be taking measures to prioritise protection of our wildlife and wild spaces. -
Amanda Roy 18 Sep 2017I volunteer for Cats Protection, raising awareness of neutering and chipping and actually believe microchipping should be mandatory for cats as it currently is for dogs.
-
chelley 21 Sep 2017We need to be neutering and returning feral colonies of cats. Most cats out there started of as someone's pet. A responsible owner will chip there cat, but if the details aren't registered or kept up to date it's useless.
-
Shirley Otto 22 Sep 2017Thank you for this initiative. The wildcats and birds in our urban areas need to be protected
-
Catriona Laird 24 Sep 2017Although I live in England I was brought up in Scotland and still have family there. I care both about the plight of the Scottish wildcat and the general small wildlife population. I feel everything must be done to protect the wildcat but early neutering will also protect cats. It's been shown to be a quick procedure which has fewer side effects when performed early in kittens. I suspect the legislation will be difficult to enforce but cannot any good reason not to try.
-
Andrew Swales 24 Sep 2017Pheasants next? I hit one on the A7 last month, it did £150 damage to my car but even though someone bred and released it I can't go after them for compensation.
-
Lyn Flanders 1 Oct 2017Been involved in at rescue and TNR for 30 years. Neutering is of extreme importance and the only answer to the world over population of cats. I do not believe in breeding at all. Neutering every cat is hopefully bound to result in less cats in need of help although it will never end but reduction in numbers would benefit cat welfare charities.
-
LYDIA REID 2 Oct 2017Sorry no 2
I believe it is healthy to neuter and release cats
They do as mine did and move inside if ill
What I object to is some of the stories of cruelty that I have heard of to keep feral cats away from our wild cats
Catching in cages and leaving them to die is unacceptable
To catch neuter and release maybe even in a different area is fine
I accept the wild cat must be protected -
Kathleen 3 Oct 2017Chipping and neutering will only work if the humans cared about their cats. The Scottish wildcat needs to be protected and it is only humans that can make sure of this working.
-
Raymond F Carlin 4 Oct 2017Please consider this petition to alleviate suffering in both the feral cat and less well cared for pet population.
It will also help safeguard our native wild cat, bird, small mammals and other wildlife. -
Colin 6 Oct 2017There is no excuse for anyone keeping un-neutered cats unless they are in the business of breeding cats, in which case they should value their animals too highly to allow them to wander.
Widespread neutering is justified on both animal welfare and conservation grounds. The practice would drastically reduce the number of unwanted kittens left in cat shelters for rehoming, the incidence of fighting and disease in free-roaming pet cats, the problem of feral & stray cats, and impacts on wildlife including the endangered wildcat.
Microchipping of cats would allow lost cats to be returned to their owners, and by enabling cat owners to be identified, would encourage a responsible attitude towards their pets.
The proposals would help reduce pressure on overstretched animal welfare charities, and although there would likely be an overall reduction in cat numbers, it would potentially create more business opportunities for responsible licensed breeders. -
Brian Clark Paterson 8 Oct 2017I live in a small hamlet of 12 houses in the Carse of Gowrie and one of my neighbours cats which was not neutered had in excess of 20 kittens which were left to roam wild looking for food and shelter. The kittens became a nuisance and would dash across the road in front of traffic and fouled our garden and twice took food from the BBQ when my back was turned. The lady who had the cats eventually relented and agreed to the Cats Protection League rounding the kittens up to neuter them and arrange for them to be re housed some way away from the hamlet. Thankfully things are now back to normal and we only see the occasional kitten thanks to the iniative of the CPL. Brian & Val Treetops.
-
Karen Kirkland 9 Oct 2017After 26 years of cat rescue I cannot stress enough how important this is.
-
Peter Berwick 10 Oct 2017Such an important program...left in checked the population will reach truly miserable proportion ... facing the problem and acting now makes sense.
-
Roy Dennis 12 Oct 2017At present, I think the prospect of saving the Scottish Wildcat is in the balance. This is a serious conservation issue so the action, such as proposed, is essential and overdue.
-
David Sequin 15 Oct 2017I think its a good idea it keeps cat population under control & stops your going missing .
-
Donna Moran 15 Oct 2017Recently I had two pregnant cats that visited daily at first I didn't feed them. But soon realized that they were in fact pregnant and would still visit daily or they stayed hidden under the decking and felt safe. I have a two year old daughter and didn't feel right about leaving these mums out to have their kittens. So I contacted west fife cats protection. And they took them in. They each had four kittens each. Now the same situation could very easily have had a totally different outcome had I not been able to get the help needed for the stray mums. I am now a foster mum for cats. And shocked at how much cats protection and organisation's like them have to deal with on a daily basis.
-
Neil Kirkland 16 Oct 2017Last week we picked up four 4-week old kittens found under a bush. Someone left them there to fend for themselves. Tomorrow we are getting a three day old kitten, the young mother killed the rest of the litter because she was confused and frightened all because people did not have their cat neutered. Also last week picked up a 8 year-old unneutered male with a large wound , think how many kittens he has been responsible for over a period of 8 years. We need to act now before its to late.
-
Maggi Allan 16 Oct 2017Essential program for ecological and humanitarian reasons.
-
Miss SCOTCAT 16 Oct 2017This has to do with animal welfare and conservation. It is a sadness when those who want to help families who can not or do not neuter their cats are constrained by the lack of powers to enable those agencies to enforce neutering. SSPCA cant help, apparently, as they consider it's not "cruelty" to allow cats to reproduce without regard to welfare. For those who DO have neutered cats, it is terrifying to witness the territorial fighting with impostors. And for those who do not keep cats, it is a challenge when scavenging ferals raid their kitchens and join in their al fresco dining uninvited! Farm animals have more protection that domestic cats do, as neglect, lack of feeding, and failure to manage husbandry can see a farmer prosecuted. I would not seek to criminalise, but if there were legisllation in place to empower those such as Cat Protection organisations and SSPCA to remove, treat, neuter and re-home ferals without a consent, it would alleviate the unnecessary suffering to the unwanted and un-cared-for cats, and the actual nuisance that their uncontrolled and unmanaged breeding causes to other animals and neighbours
-
Kathleen 17 Oct 2017These very special puss cats deserve the beet in life like our Scottish wild cat. They have no voice themselves so it is up to us to put their case forward for the powers that be to listen. Which I really hope they do this time. Purrs
-
Rhona Gordon 17 Oct 2017As a Scottish cat rescue charity (Fife Cat Shelter) we spend most of our time rescuing and neutering cats and raising money to do so. We offer a much discounted price to owners on low incomes to have their cats neutered to try to reduce the number of cats , there are too many cats and too few potential owners. If we did not have to divert the majority of our time and funds to neutering, we would hope to have time to inform people of the importance of neutering and the potential spread of life threatening disease through un neutered males . Micro chipping is a valuable resource for reuniting cars and owners and part of the responsibility of ownership.
Neutered cats are healthier cats and we desperately try to stop annual abandonment of pregnant cats or cats with kittens. Encouraging people to have their cats neutered and not to see litters of kittens as potential money earners , is essential. -
Lynne Ellis 18 Oct 2017Although not living in Scotland I have lived there many years and have family there. It's similar problems here. People do not take responsibility for the welfare of other species. Cats are left to breed and this is unfair, kittens and cats abandoned. breeders need to take more care and all animals licensed for breeding, a large program to help get neutering done. To prevent cruelty. Chipping and neutering is something which needs to be addressed and forced, and help for those animals in poor families. Ignorance is a problem here too. Charities would have more to spare on helping cats in need. The wild cat needs protecting. I was a cat rescuer in Scotland and remain one here now. Regards L. ellis
-
Lynne Ellis 18 Oct 2017As a cat rescuer formally in Scotland for many years and now here, this programmer needs to start as soon as possible.
-
Marion Smith 18 Oct 2017There are more than enough cats, those that are already here deserve care and attention. It is irresponsible as a career to allow your male to procreate willy-nilly or female to have a succession of unplanned pregnancies.