Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 2869 title not published

Unlisted First activity 28 Jun 2017 Last activity 9 Aug 2017

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 2869), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: phonics synthetic literacy reading teachers teaching

Signatures
282
Comments
41
Activity window
42 days
28 Jun 2017 to 9 Aug 2017

Signatures by country

282 online signatures
  1. Scotland150 53.2%
  2. United Kingdom42 14.9%
  3. England39 13.8%
  4. Australia28 9.9%
  5. United States6 2.1%
  6. Canada4 1.4%
  7. New Zealand3 1.1%
  8. Spain2 0.7%
  9. Wales2 0.7%
  10. Argentina1 0.4%
  11. 5 other countries5 1.8%

Comments

41 comments, oldest first
  1. Alison Taylor 28 Jun 2017
    It is vital that this petition is circulated amongst teachers, school suppprt staff and parents across Scotland. We can close the gap and raise attainment for all. Please help by signing and sharing.
  2. Sue Lloyd 28 Jun 2017
    I am familiar with research and case studies that have been carried out into the effectiveness of synthetic-phonics teaching. Every time synthetic phonics has proven to be more effective than the mixed methods. When we changed our method of teaching, in the 1980s, to what is now known as synthetic phonics our average went from 102 to 110+ on the standardised Young's Reading Test. Improvements, similar to this, have been replicated around the world. It is a great mistake to ignore the research mentioned by Anne Glennie. I provide details of the research carried out, in the section on 'Preventing Reading and Writing Problems'. I urge you to be accountable and use research to guide your teachers.
  3. Prof Tom Burkard 28 Jun 2017
    I have always advocated the use of standardised cloze tests at 7+ as the most effective means of ensuring that decoding skills have been adequately taught. The Phonics Screening Check has not won the confidence of teachers in England, nor does it make them accountable. Parents need to know if their child is making adequate progress in learning to read, and the Phonics Screening Check--which is often administered by teachers who are opposed to it-- is not well understood by parents.
  4. Francesca Green 28 Jun 2017
    My sister has explained this to me. I whole heatedly agree with it!
  5. Margaret Burns 28 Jun 2017
    literacy is the backbone of our education system. As teachers we have to get our children hungry to learn. As they enjoy success using phonic based learning for reading their hunger and enthusiasm grows and they want to read more. It strikes me that proven theory has been trumped by politically whim
  6. Elizabeth Robins 29 Jun 2017
    It is disgraceful that Scotland, the home of the influential longitudinal Clackmannanshire study, has still not appreciated and implemented synthetic phonics for its beginner readers. Your current falling literacy results are disastrous, many children have been unnecessarily rendered semi-literate meanwhile, and going forward the country is now unnecessarily behind the eight ball in improving its international literacy standing.
  7. Geraldine A Millar 29 Jun 2017
    This is the only way to continually improve outcomes for Scottish children research reflect and where necessary adjust our learning and teaching
  8. Celeste Musgrave 29 Jun 2017
    Scottish Schools should join the trend being seen in most English speaking countries
  9. Francesca Green 29 Jun 2017
    My sister has explained this to me and I agree whole heartedly with it!
  10. Alison McMurtrie 29 Jun 2017
    The effective teaching of reading must be the most cost-efficient way to reduce some of the social ills that plague so many societies. Why is it that there is this reluctance to properly fund and support teachers in how to successfully teach all children to read!
  11. Geraldine Carter 29 Jun 2017
    Growing evidence over the past two decades has demonstrated the effectiveness of Systematic Synthetic Phonics for all children, particularly for the vulnerable and those in areas of poverty. A logical method that obviates necessity for expensive 'catch-up' and dramatically reduces the huge costs of illiteracy throughout society.
  12. Anne Wylie 29 Jun 2017
    It is extremely important that teachers are trained in and have complete knowledge and understanding of teaching literacy from early level to first and beyond. This is crucial since literacy permeates the curriculum and future learning and progression.
  13. Lynne Binnie 29 Jun 2017
    This needs urgent attention to close the poverty related attainment gap. Numbers of children identified with dyslexia is on the increase. In many cases this is as a result of appropriate learning opportunities and lack of knowledge in the teaching profession with regards to how to teach children to read and spell.
  14. Maggie Downie 29 Jun 2017
    I worked for 10 years with children aged 11+ with reading difficulties. All but a tiny handful would have had no problems had they been taught systematic structured phonics from the start instead of 'mixed methods'.. The emotional cost to them of 'failure' was very high. It is deeply unfair to children to let them suffer in this way when the solution is so simple.
  15. Debbie Hepplewhite 30 Jun 2017
    I fully support this petition and I will also support any official enquiry in any way I can if called upon.I implore those in political and educational authority in Scotland to get on board with the wealth of evidence that, in reality, is also common sense. The English language in its written form has the most complex alphabetic code in the world. Research AND common sense shows that this code needs to be taught explicitly, systematically and rigorously for best effect for all children, regardless of their individuality. It is the SAME alphabetic code and phonics skills they require regardless of context. In addition, of course they need a rich spoken language and to be steeped in as much appropriate literature as possible. This is expressed very helpfully through the Simple View of Reading model (Gough and Tumner 1986), the model promoted in Sir Jim Rose's internationally-renowned independent review (2006) and subsequently adopted as a 'useful conceptual framework' in England. The 'multi-cueing reading strategies' where these amount to word-guessing can be enormously damaging for some children and they are not supported by research findings. Teachers should be educated fully in research-informed reading instruction
    - and they are not. Perhaps some are
    - but Anne Glennie can provide evidence aplenty that this is not the case in Scotland
    - having worked with thousands of teachers through teacher-training through the years. Further, her training has been cancelled by some in educational authority and then headteachers in Scotland have contacted me in consequence as they wish to pursue their professional development in reading instruction. This is a shocking state of affairs. Having been a primary teacher, special needs teachers, and primary headteacher leading to becoming a phonics and language programme author, along with being a teacher-trainer, and can provide a huge amount of experience and evidence about the differences that teachers make when well-informed.
  16. Robert W Sweet, Jr. 30 Jun 2017
    President, The National Right to Read Foundation, Strasburg, Virginia, USA. WE COMPLETELY SUPPORT Anne Glennie and her effort to provide the excellent training for teachers in reading instruction. Teachers and children will benefit.
  17. Dr Marion de Lemos 2 Jul 2017
    I fully support this petition, which reflects the views of the scientific community in terms of the research evidence relating to how children learn to read and the most effective way to teach them how to read.

    Dr Molly de Lemos
    Psychologist and Educational Researcher
    Australia
  18. Sarah asome 2 Jul 2017
    I am a U.K. Trained teacher who was not given the skills to teach literacy effectively. My daughter isn't being taught correctly innAustralua either.
  19. Joyce Hawkins 2 Jul 2017
    I worked with Anne 2 years ago as she led a course locally. Since introducing SSP There has been marked improvement in reading ability. Recent tests have shown P2 children reading between 1
    - 3 years above their age.
    I support Anne Glennie regarding this petition.
  20. Sir Jim Rose 3 Jul 2017
    We know more about the teaching of reading than ever before as a result of robust research to whiich Scotland has contributed significantly in the past. It would be a great pity if Scotland did take full advantage of that.
  21. Elizabeth Nonweiler, Teach to Read 3 Jul 2017
    I began teaching children to read by encouraging them to use a mix of methods, like those now in the Scottish Curriculum for Excellence, which is to use knowledge of sight vocabulary, phonics, context clues, punctuation and grammar to read with understanding and expression.
    Many years later, I was introduced to a synthetic phonics programme and began to use that to teach young children to read. The difference was astonishing. The children learned to read faster, more accurately, with better comprehension and with more enjoyment and pride in their achievements. As well as being thrilled, I was upset that I had taught in a far less effective way for so long.
    Now I do what I can to make sure other teachers know how to teach reading effectively sooner than I did. Some teachers in Scotland already know, but their voices are not well enough listened to. Some of the best research into how to teach reading came from Scotland.
    I hope the Scottish government listens now and makes sure all their teachers know how to teach reading well, as soon as possible.
  22. Coral George 3 Jul 2017
    Based on world wide research and pupils' results, Synthetic Phonics is the most direct route to teaching reading and writing in English.
  23. Lorna Walter 4 Jul 2017
    The results of the Clackmannanshire project led to all English schools receiving phonics training so come on Scotland do the same!
  24. Jennifer Morrison 4 Jul 2017
    The literacy of children in Scotland needs to be address there has to be an intervention now.
  25. Loraine bertolini 4 Jul 2017
    I agree that literacy in all schools secondary and primary is not at a present standard schools should concentrate on the basics in all aspects of schools
  26. Professor Kathy Rastle 4 Jul 2017
    This is a very important initiative for literacy standards in Scotland. There is now a substantial research base demonstrating the effectiveness of systematic synthetic phonics on the initial stages of learning to read. It is vital that all children benefit from instruction informed by the strength of this research base.
  27. Robert W Sweet Jr, President, The National Right to Read Foundation, USA 4 Jul 2017
    For several decades the National Institutes for Child Health and Human Development have been sponsoring quantitative research in how children learn to read. More than 40,000 students were tested and evaluated over a period of at least 25 years. The conclusion is that all students need direct and systematic instruction in the alphabetic principle, that systematic, synthetic phonetics instruction is essential if a student is to become a proficient reader. For the past half century multiple studies worldwide, have come to the same conclusion. The Report of the National Reading Panel in the U.S. concluded that direct, systematic, early instruction in phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary development, fluency and comprehension are all necessary components of a good reading program. Brain imaging studies also confirm the physiological necessity of proper instruction if students are to become proficient readers. These findings are consistent with those conducted in England, Scotland, New Zealand, Australia, Canada as well. Anne Glennie's training program is consistent with the findings of reading science, and the conclusions of decades of carefully conducted quantitative research studies world wide. Scotland can continue to be a leader in reducing illiteracy by supporting Anne Glennie's training program for teachers. You are fortunate to have her expertise and dedication to the children of Scotland!
  28. Donnchadh MacGuaire 4 Jul 2017
    Tha an obair seo air leth feumail and da chuid airson Foghlam tro mheadhain na Gaidhlig ri foghlam annam Beurla no canan sam bith eiloe.
  29. Catherine Quinn 4 Jul 2017
    I support this.
  30. Geraldine Carter 4 Jul 2017
    In England, Australia, US, Gov Committees have concluded that Synthetic Phonics is the most successful way to teach children to read. House of Commons Select Committee 2009 also confirmed this finding. Thousands of papers,articles from esteemed academics and leading supporters of ResearchED and RRF have endorsed the robust evidence-based SSP research. The minority of academics promoting Analytical Phonics, or a mixture, have contributed to steep decline in Scottish literacy. Decoding, a foundational skill of reading, has been downgraded with dire consequences particularly for children from areas of poverty. An emphasis on 'real reading' before basic skills are embedded has also damaged the progress of struggling readers.
  31. Valma Adams 6 Jul 2017
    Our young people face a dark future in an already crumbling education system. Allow teachers to teach, but train them wisely and allow them to the methodologies that will benefit society. A change should be beneficial for those who give as well as those who receive.
  32. Christopher Jolly 6 Jul 2017
    Scotland has been a world leader in the past in education, and specifically in synthetic phonics through the Clackmananshire study. It is very sad this is no longer so, and it undermines the ability of the next generation in the country.
  33. Angela Jordan 7 Jul 2017
    I have used a synthetic phonics system to teach struggling readers one to one for one hour per week and have raised their reading age by up to 4 years after 35 sessions.
  34. Elaine van den Akker 7 Jul 2017
    This is important stuff.
  35. Lynn Wallace 8 Jul 2017
    I have been using systematic explict phonics teaching successfully with previously illiterate children with 100% success. It is the best antidote to poor self esteem I have seen in 20 years of teaching
  36. Chiara 8 Jul 2017
    Essential research-based knowledge is being lost in education and far too many teachers leaving university now no longer possess essential understandings of children's learning, instead requiring to follow pre-designed programmes that may not always be appropriate for the children they teach or enable children to learn the concepts being taught with understanding. This is the case across teaching, in both numeracy and literacy. We were once seen as a world-leading country for education, this is now no longer the case. We need to return to knowledge based teaching by ensuring that students leave university with ample knowledge and understanding of children's thinking and learning trajectories and how they can support this as teachers. Better systems could also be put in place to ensure that this learning continues in schools such as mandatory additional time out of class for teachers to participate in research -based CPD opportunities and self-study to support the development of research-based practice.
  37. Tahira Sheikh 9 Jul 2017
    I am a systematic synthetic phonics trainer living in Pakistan. This approach of teaching has helped so many teachers to teach correctly and so many children have benefited with good reading & writing skills here. I am surprised to hear of a decline of literacy standards in Scotland's schools, considering that the Clackmannanshire study was done there. I thought they knew better!
  38. Eileen Measey 9 Jul 2017
    The Clackmannanshire study inspired me to organise SP teacher training in a small island in the Caribbean. Since the study showed how well SP works, why would you not do it?
  39. Peter Teesdale 14 Jul 2017
    This issue has to be addressed as I am shocked by how far standards of literacy have fallen. I travel extensively and see how other nationalities children are so far ahead particularly in languages, the sciences and maths. The government have got to invest in the necessary skills so that teachers can teach effectively with a passion and our children are not disadvantaged in what is now a very connected world.
  40. Anne Atkinson 4 Aug 2017
    I hope there can be changes made
  41. Faith Borkowsky 8 Aug 2017
    Good luck!!