Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 5

Unlisted petition 2773 title not published

Unlisted First activity 23 Feb 2017 Last activity 6 Apr 2017

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 2773), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: referendum independence brexit voted another divisive

Signatures
1,471
Comments
320
Activity window
42 days
23 Feb 2017 to 6 Apr 2017

Signatures by country

1,471 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,064 72.3%
  2. United Kingdom352 23.9%
  3. England41 2.8%
  4. Wales3 0.2%
  5. Canada3 0.2%
  6. Northern Ireland2 0.1%
  7. Spain1 0.1%
  8. United States1 0.1%
  9. Taiwan1 0.1%
  10. Australia1 0.1%
  11. 2 other countries2 0.1%

Comments

320 comments, oldest first
320 comments · showing 1–50
  1. Davy Maclellan 23 Feb 2017
    Respect the outcome of previous referendum
  2. Noreen Harding 23 Feb 2017
    I agree with comments below. I further suggest that there should never be another referendum. We already have a country and we are not oppressed.
  3. Colin Strong 23 Feb 2017
    I am coming from a different angle to the petitioner. I voted to remain. I believe Brexit will be a disaster, but see no point in compounding 2 disaster (Devolution and Brexit) with a third!
  4. Donald MacKenzie 23 Feb 2017
    If we never have another referendum on ANYTHING it will still be too soon. The 2014 referendum was divisive and deeply unpleasant, with Yes groups mobbing Better Together stalls, videoing all who approached. Intimidation never reined in by leadership.
  5. Colin Strong 23 Feb 2017
    I voted the other way from the petitioner in both Referenda. I see no point in compounding 2 disasters (Devolution and Brexit) with a third (Separation)!
  6. Mrs Janet Picking 23 Feb 2017
    The SNP need to concentrate on the present problems of Education, NHS, Police and economy rather than tearing Scotland apart with another referendum on independence. We were promised the last referendum would last a life time, please keep to that promise.
  7. Andrew Shearer 23 Feb 2017
    I was YES in 2014, I will be NO in an early INDYRef2
  8. Christopher Jack 23 Feb 2017
    Best interests of Scotland would be for Scottish Government to wait until brexit fully happens before deciding on what options there are for our future. Don't think a third referendum will be well received by large swathes of the population. We are a sensible, canny people. Let's wait and see before making an informed decision.
  9. Andrew Homes 23 Feb 2017
    I voted for independence but democracy said otherwise.
  10. Ewan Hector 23 Feb 2017
    Whether I voted no or yes during indyref is irrelevant. What is relevant is that all of us want to see a better Scotland. One that is fairer for all, one in which there is justice, one in which there is no-one living in poverty, one in which all children have the same opportunities for education, one in which people can be seen in a timely manner by medical services. Indyref cost the tax payer £15 million
    - money that should be spent on our ailing education, health, social and police services. If Sturgeon was serious about her desire to create a better Scotland, she should focus her attention and finances on these very real issues. She should follow the democratic process and accept the result of indyref. Thus far she has ignored the no voters in the SNP's promise to make the referendum a once in a generation decision. That is not justice, and a discredit to no voters.
  11. Alison Orr 23 Feb 2017
    I may not entirely agree with David Robertson's reasons for setting up this petition, but I do believe we will fail to gain independence if there is a referendum in 2018 and that the issue will be dead for another generation. Please wait until Brexit is complete, it can only aid the independence cause.
  12. Richard Tallach 23 Feb 2017
    If Nicola Sturgeon lost a second independence referendum would she wait a generation before demanding a third. Having referenda every few years on this question would rightly make Britain and the British government a laughing stock and is an utterly foolish way to run a country.
  13. Donald Roderick Shell 24 Feb 2017
    I agree with this petition.
  14. Derek McPhail 24 Feb 2017
    Scots are canny, we wait for the right time. I voted a hearty Yes in 2014
    - I won't be voting Yes again until we're on a stable footing. We've waited 300 years
    - what's another 3 or 4? Maybe by then we'll know if the EU is going to get out of its current crisis or not. So let's just wait and see, and concentrate on our own problems as we do so. That is why I support this petition.
  15. Ian Campbell 24 Feb 2017
    This 2 nd referendum must be stopped or there will be violence on the streets.
  16. Seonaid MacLennan 24 Feb 2017
    There are enough problems with NHS, Education, our Economy etc., within Scotland. The Scottish Parliament now need to spend time with these problems at hand, without being distracted by another lengthy campaign. I voted with SNP for independence in 2014 but can't understand why they now want to be controlled by Europe.
  17. Audrey Ewing 24 Feb 2017
    I thing we need to sort out Brexit first.
  18. Brian Griffiths 24 Feb 2017
    Regardless of whether one is for or against Scottish Independence, we need at least a couple of years breathing space after the triggering of Article 50 to establish exactly how Brexit is going to impact on us and also what shape the EU is going to be in following national elections in member countries. I think at this point it will become very clear where our destiny lies.
  19. James kerr 24 Feb 2017
    Scotland
  20. A R Gregan 24 Feb 2017
    Further referendum campaigning will be divisive, expensive and deter business investment into Scotland. The once in a generation referendum of 2014 is the settled will of The Scottish people under the terms of the Edinburgh Agreement.
  21. James 24 Feb 2017
    No more division.
  22. Timothy R Puntis 24 Feb 2017
    I am wholly in favour of a further independence referendum.
    I reject completely the reasons given in the petition's Background Information for delaying or cancelling any planned referendum on independence for Scotland.
    The Brexit vote and also the election of the Republican Trump government in the USA make independence for Scotland more urgently needed than we could have imagined at the time of the last referendum.
    I do not think that any promise or assurance understood as having been given about waiting a 'generation' could have validity in the vastly different world order that we now have.
    I have no doubt that the efforts of the Scottish Government to improving NHS Scotland, Scottish Education and the economic wellbeing of Scotland will be continued if we have another referendum or not, and this task will be better achieved in an independent Scotland.
  23. Timothy R Puntis 24 Feb 2017
    I am wholly in favour of a further independence referendum.
    I reject completely the reasons given in the petition's Background Information for delaying or cancelling any planned referendum on independence for Scotland.
    The Brexit vote and also the election of the Republican Trump government in the USA make independence for Scotland more urgently needed than we could have imagined at the time of the last referendum.
    I do not think that any promise or assurance understood as having been given about waiting a 'generation' could have validity in the vastly different world order that we now have.
    I have no doubt that the efforts of the Scottish Government to improving NHS Scotland, Scottish Education and the economic wellbeing of Scotland will be continued if we have another referendum or not, and this task will be better achieved in an independent Scotland.
  24. Alison Kalotka 25 Feb 2017
    As a former SNP voter who read and Saw through Alex Salmonds nonsense in the "Scotland's Future" white paper I am disgusted with the party! They area showe of petulant children who, because they didn't get their own way, shout Indy at every opportunity!! The country is in ruins, the parallels are there to 1930s Germany, as well as 1970's Northern Ireland! We no longer divide on religion (a good thing!) but we are divided on Union and Indy! Ms Sturgeon has made a mockery of MY country and does not speak for me! She speaks for a minority of Scots. The sooner the SNP or Sturgeon is ousted the better!
  25. Michael Moir 25 Feb 2017
    We were promised that this would be a once in a generation referendum and we simply ask that that promise is kept.

    I can imagine the furore from the Separatist Regime, if the result had went the other way in 2014 & those No voters then had immediately began campaigning for 'another' referendum!
  26. Kate Rosindale 25 Feb 2017
    Would be happy to never have another independence referendum and for SNP to lose power and dwindle away.
  27. Jennifer Hastie 25 Feb 2017
    Scotland already voted to remain in the UK, we said No to the Snp's independence. Since the end of 2014, the Snp's threat of a second independence referendum has been damaging Scotland's economy, businesses, investment and prospects. There is no majority support from Scots for another independence referendum. Talk of a second independence referendum must be removed until the serious economic decline Scotland is in shows signs of abating.
  28. Heather Palmer 25 Feb 2017
    Scotland doesn't need more diversions from the important issues. Scotland voted to reason part of the United Kingdom and the Scottish Government have to respect that fully.
  29. Fiona Taylor 25 Feb 2017
    Scotland had a Referendum, and the result was No to separation from the UK. We don't need another one.
  30. Donald Ogilvie Adams 25 Feb 2017
    No more referendums.
  31. Alex Holt 25 Feb 2017
    I object to a second referendum
  32. Irene Forrest 25 Feb 2017
    Thank you and God bless you for this !!
  33. Chris Haxton 25 Feb 2017
    I believe there should never be another referendum for at least a generation.
  34. Robert McConachi 25 Feb 2017
    Fed up with the same old same old. Concentrate on the services you're abusing IE police, health, education etc etc.
  35. L 25 Feb 2017
    I would say leave it for a generation as promised. Too divisive and bitterness from 2014 still remains.
  36. Iain Gall 26 Feb 2017
    The uncertainty the 2014 referendum had cost Scotland dearly, a second one puts off any foreign investors for a good time to come. Scotland is subsideised £1,200 each year and scotlands deficit is the fastest growing in Europe. How on earth can any realistic argument be put forward to separate? Scotland was bankrupt 400 years ago as a baron, uncivilised country wrapped in civil war. In that time Scotland has flourished due to the union and I say that as a proud Scot but a loyal Brit.
  37. George 26 Feb 2017
    No referendum
  38. Sandra Smith 27 Feb 2017
    The country needs stability. Stop trying to divide the country and cause strife and confusion amongst us. United we stand divided we fall. We do not wish to be governed from Europe. We want a United Kingdom.
  39. Bill Perrie 27 Feb 2017
    I voted for an independent scotland and still want independence but agree with the petition that now is not an appropriate time for another referendum.
  40. Alex wat 28 Feb 2017
    Why want the be ruled by Brussels when we can stay in the country our fathers fought for and not full fat cats pockets in brussels
  41. Alex watt 28 Feb 2017
    Why want to be ruled by Europe when we can stay in a union with our closest allies
  42. David Norris 1 Mar 2017
    Stop stirring up hatred of the rest of the UK that feeds Scotland
  43. Derek 1 Mar 2017
    Forget a referendum and progress with governing this country properly not spending another £xxxmillions unnecessarily.
  44. Andrew Pearson 6 Mar 2017
    Utter nonsense. Unionist propaganda at its worst.
  45. Duncan Cassidy 9 Mar 2017
    Can the Scottish Government please stop trying to deflect from the poor job the SNP are doing in running this country, continued talk of a second referendum is only serving as a smoke screen and the first minister should really get on with doing her job. A second referendum is not welcome.
  46. Charles collings 11 Mar 2017
    Respect the result of the 2014 referendum result and concentrate on running Scotland. The last thing we need at this moment in time is another devisive referendum.
  47. Nadia Reid 12 Mar 2017
    The Scottish Government are becoming complacent in regards to the needs of the Scottish people. Nicola Sturgeon has only one agenda, independence! Ineffective opposition is only facilitating this. Who will address the really issues facing this country? Education, Health...
  48. mike 12 Mar 2017
    sort out your mess before trying to divide us any more
  49. carole 12 Mar 2017
    I have not recovered from the trauna of the last referendem so do not want another.
  50. Fraser 13 Mar 2017
    What a great idea, another referendum costing millions based on pitiful gripes. Makes perfect sense to call a referendum because of Brexit. Wailing on about how it's going to be the end of the world as we know it and the solution? break ties with the rest of the UK with whom we do circa 3x more trade with than Europe! Genius.
    Do what's best for Scotland and spend your time improving education, health and emergency services.