Parliament Workbench

Petition · unlisted · Session 4

Unlisted petition 2236 title not published

Unlisted First activity 6 Jan 2015 Last activity 17 Feb 2015

This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 2236), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.

What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.

Stand-out terms in its comments: child disgusting restraint behaviour teachers restraining

Signatures
4,669
Comments
365
Activity window
42 days
6 Jan 2015 to 17 Feb 2015

Signatures by country

4,669 online signatures
  1. Scotland2,340 50.1%
  2. England1,232 26.4%
  3. United Kingdom454 9.7%
  4. United States281 6%
  5. Wales105 2.2%
  6. Northern Ireland73 1.6%
  7. Australia52 1.1%
  8. Ireland40 0.9%
  9. Canada37 0.8%
  10. New Zealand7 0.1%
  11. 25 other countries48 1%

Comments

365 comments, oldest first
365 comments · showing 1–50
  1. Beth Morrison 6 Jan 2015
    Disabled children are the most vulnerable and fragile in our society. Very often children with disabilities have great difficulty in communicating, many have no verbal language. The only way that our children can communicate their needs. For example I am hungry,thirsty,too hot,too cold,feel ill or in pain is through their behaviour. If staff ignore this, the child gets frustrated and all too often the response is to restrain, hold down or manhandle the child in order to control the behaviour. Sometimes, these little ones are pulled along or dragged by staff and thrown in alone to cool down rooms which are very often bare cell like rooms where they are left to cry or until the behaviour stops. The child's needs go unmet and often, as a result of the staff response, the child suffers bruising, scratches or other injuries. This is completely unacceptable. There is a difference between a disabled child having a sensory meltdown or resorting to behaviour due to communication difficulties and a typically developing child who understands what they are doing and are deemed in control of their behaviour. Sometimes mobile disabled children are restrained for extended periods in wheelchairs for staff convenience. These responses by staff are at best due to poor understanding or training, but very often used to punish disabled children and there is no accountability when this happens. We need to make sure that this barbaric practise is subject to very strict guidelines which are adhered to by staff. If they do not adhere, they must be held accountable. You cannot punish disability out of a child.
  2. Peter Morrison 6 Jan 2015
    "This Government's ambition is for Scotland to become the best place in the world for a child to grow up. Recognising, respecting and promoting rights is essential if we are to make that vision a reality. This means making practical changes in order to ensure that children experience their rights on a day to day basis." Source www.scotland.gov.uk. Supporting this petition is the chance for the Scottish government to put their words into action and show that they are not empty rhetoric.
  3. louise thomas 6 Jan 2015
    This is shocking
  4. Linda shaw 6 Jan 2015
    Absalutey a disgrace
  5. Lara Allan 6 Jan 2015
    All children should be treated fairly, equally given same opportunities have freedom, fun and given encouragement. Restraining and hard discipline is simply not acceptable.
  6. Lara Allan 6 Jan 2015
    Treat all children with respect and dignity with no restraint stop restraining practices now.
  7. Paige Morrison 6 Jan 2015
    Stop Restraint on innocent disabled children
  8. Bradley Jago 6 Jan 2015
    Please support this petition!
  9. Leeanne MacGregor 6 Jan 2015
    Good luck with this xxx
  10. Jean Milligan 6 Jan 2015
    No child should have to go through this
  11. m brankin 6 Jan 2015
    about time these kids where protected what on gods earth give people the right to bruise kids like this if it was parents we would be charged what makes teachers any different they disabled kids not animals and deserve to be treated with respect and love xx
  12. Siobhan Thomson 6 Jan 2015
    No child should be restrained and definitely not restrained to the point where injury has occurred.
  13. Denise vannet 6 Jan 2015
    I have signed the petition as I have nephew who attends school & I am horrified at the thought of any kind of mistreatment too any child!!!!! These mums & dads are putting there kids into a place of what they hope is. Safe environment & going by the amount of stories press coverage this matter has gotten over the past while I feel the need too sign in the hope that things are looked into properly & that no kids are at risk at anytime & they recurve the best treatment as possible.
  14. Mrs Tamara Cudmore 6 Jan 2015
    This needs to change there is no need of treating Children like this it is wrong .As parents aint allowed to treat children like this so it doesn't give teachers and helpers the right to do it .
  15. annmarie russell 6 Jan 2015
    this shouldn't happen to any child
  16. Mandy Fleming 6 Jan 2015
    As a manager in the care sector, I understand that parents and families of those entrusted to us require a transparent service for their family member.
    Having worked with adults who can challenge, bearing in mind, there is a reason for the behaviour, staff must be not only trained, but a review of their training undertaken. Lead people involved in managing teams of staff must also have an understanding of those being supported by their teams.
    Have we learnt nothing from Winterbourne, why are we allowing the abuse of any person that requires help in whatever form to continue.
    Would any decent parents happily stand back and not ask questions at the highest level should their loved one show any sign of abuse.
    This petition should be heard at the highest level..
  17. susan hughes 6 Jan 2015
    disgusting behaviour and shouldn't be allowed to happen to our children
  18. Thomas cochrane 6 Jan 2015
    Please only use properly trained people.
  19. Linda mcgregor. 6 Jan 2015
    This is unacceptable, hopefully enough signatures to make it stop!
  20. Ally Dickson 6 Jan 2015
    this is a form of bullying and must stop. End of...
  21. Mrs Heather Knight 6 Jan 2015
    I really urgevyou to take actiin and stop this kind of treatment to people, Next time one might not be so lucky, they could end up dead
  22. Julie Ellison 6 Jan 2015
    I'm truly stunned as a teacher in the UK that teachers and carers are allowed to 'handle' children without training. I have seen evidence that many children are being handled incorrectly causing unnecessary bodily harm. Please get people trained properly.....no training no handling.
  23. ellen pinkowski 6 Jan 2015
    Stop this now
  24. sandra Burke 6 Jan 2015
    This is totally unacceptable how dare a teacher do this to any child but to hurt a disabled child like this is disgusting.
  25. Paula ogilvie 6 Jan 2015
    Get this stopped now, sickening. I on occasion have to use safe holds in my job but we are all fully trained and this is used as the last option and avoided if can be
  26. Stephen Cardownie 6 Jan 2015
    This needs to be addressed, these kids need help and encouragement not trauma
  27. kim MacFarlane 6 Jan 2015
    itd an absolute disgrace that our children are meant to be in the "care" of these people yet there is no "care" going on...children with learning difficulties or disabilities need love, care and attention, not rstraint or abuse...this has got to stop...it is no more than bullying and that is not tolerated in everyday life...do something now!!!!
  28. Maria Manning 6 Jan 2015
    if this is true, then it is barbaric and should be stopped immediately.
  29. Diane Cathcart 6 Jan 2015
    why are we treating our children in this way?
    Why is the government allowing this ?
  30. jane brown 6 Jan 2015
    Long overdue ...would like to see statement of skill retention included.
  31. Mary L Benton 6 Jan 2015
    Every child matters, every child is precious and every childs needs to be protected. They are our future. Guide them, teach them, love them.
  32. ivancohen 6 Jan 2015
    please stop restraint on kids
  33. louise rankine 7 Jan 2015
    this is barbaric and cannot be acceptable.i cried when i read it.
  34. James Russell 7 Jan 2015
    it should be stopped right now teachers and carers no longer have the right too abuse children in this way no more capital punishment was fased out yes ago when they got rid of the cain
  35. Craig Marshall 7 Jan 2015
    This is a disgrace in this day and age
  36. louie beard beaney 7 Jan 2015
    That is disgusting thay have no right to tuch your child that is abuse i wudont let them do that to my child all thay are showing is bullying children makes me feel sick poor little children must be ferfihd .x
  37. Suzanne trainer 7 Jan 2015
    some times a child being restrained can prevent them from hurting themselves but when responsible adults as abusing the right to restrain it needs to be removed
  38. Angela Kerr 7 Jan 2015
    When I was in Primary school, my headmaster wanted to put me into the local school for people with disabilities, my mum told him no & it was all because I have epilepsy, sometimes Scottish education sucks x
  39. karen simpson 7 Jan 2015
    Surely teachers and carers working in a schlol enviroment for disabled children should be trained to communicate with the child before using any form of restraint.
  40. andy thomson 7 Jan 2015
    Shocking treatment to a kid id want justice if it was my kid
  41. Shona Mcgregor 7 Jan 2015
    absolute disgrace, hurting people like this, young or old!!!
  42. shirley webster 7 Jan 2015
    that's total disgusting how can any teacher do that to any child see if a teacher did that to my child i'd sue them & the school as this is child abuse in my eye's.
  43. Janette Mccubbin 7 Jan 2015
    I think it's sick that disabled children or adults should be restraind like this
  44. AmandA Smith 7 Jan 2015
    Kids should fl safe at school not bullied by members of staff its dusgusting and heart breaking in neads to stop
  45. Margaret O'Neill 7 Jan 2015
    This is so shocking and must be sorted, I no children can be demanding but they do not deserve this when in care.
  46. geraldine pollock 7 Jan 2015
    It is terrible this happens and your expected to believe to teachers but at end of the day who is going to lie the teacher that has put bruises on the child or the child that just didn't understand
  47. christina sorley 7 Jan 2015
    it is atrocious in this day and age that there is still this level of abuse going on.
  48. ann smith 7 Jan 2015
    this is an utter disgrace my grandson is in a wheelchair and is at a capability Scotland school I would hat this to happen to him its a good school though x
  49. Rhiannon Thomas 7 Jan 2015
    omg thus is so wrong .... Should never really happen
    if the person was handled correctly then restraint should not be needed !!!!!!
  50. Jen robinson 7 Jan 2015
    Budget cuts and undereducated untrained staff should be stopped.