Petition · unlisted · Session 4
Unlisted petition 1804 title not published
This petition is missing from Parliament’s official list. Parliament’s open data still carries its public comments and signatures (internal ID 1804), but its petitions list no longer includes the petition itself, so its title, petitioner, status and outcome are unknown. It may have been withdrawn or unpublished.
What we hold: when the comments and signatures were made, how many there were, where signers said they were from, and the comments themselves.
Stand-out terms in its comments: geese grass barley numbers crops crofting
Signatures by country
428 online signaturesComments
68 comments, oldest first-
John Bannister 17 Jul 2013It is now clear that some form of control is necessary. This is a wholly disproportionate number of geese to be allowed the freedom to exploit this fragile landscape. A quota on culling and authority to sell carcasses would help offset the economic losses of crofters in that area.
-
Carola Bell 17 Jul 2013The numbers of Greylag Geese resident all year in the area have already stopped arable crops from being worth planting. They currently reduce silage and hay quantiities considerably and reduce the quality of grass and forage crops through contamination. The numbers must be reduced or crofting agricultural activity, particularly cattle keeping will decrease further.
-
Niall McKillop 17 Jul 2013Can anyonefrom outside the islands imagine what these birds are doing to the machair and the machair lochs? There has been some very interesting research in Canada regarding how much each bird excretes onto the grass or into the water showing serious nitrate enrichment of the areas studied. And the number of 'conservation professionals' now in the Islands, most of them with no cultural or economic connection there, seems to be growning in direct proportion to the geese.
-
William Macrae 17 Jul 2013Geese numbers in the islands must be reduced to manageable levels.
We are now seeing large numbers of geese in Wester Ross at times when grass is at a premium , leaving little for overwintered livestock -
william macdonald 17 Jul 2013In North Uist the goose population is completely out of control. What grass they do not eat their droppings soil the grass for sheep.
-
Stephen Walker 17 Jul 2013Although I am a crofters I have no crop that is particularly vulnerable to goose damage. Nevertheless I have seen the quite catastrophic effect of damage caused by what is clearly a population out of control. It is high time to take action.
-
Donald Martin 17 Jul 2013There is no doubt the numbers are out of control and will continue to grow exponentially unless action is taken. This is a matter of urgency to all crofters and something needs to be done.
-
neal kinghorn 17 Jul 2013I agree with this petition.
-
angus a macdonald 18 Jul 2013anser anser the birds latin name says it all those of the past knew how to control excess of nature not the mamba bamby lot we have today.They killed all the regulators of the bird world the humble crow ,once she disappeared the goose numbers exploded support by the stupidest of all a gang of people called Scottish National heritance,what a stupid name when they have no intention of protecting anything they are just another employment agency
-
Ronald Cameron 18 Jul 2013Crofters are an endangered species. Geese are not
-
Alistair Gillies 18 Jul 2013Geese out of control here in Arisaig
-
Steve Robison 18 Jul 2013The figures speak for themselves. Wild goose numbers need controlled in the name of the conservation of some of the most precious environments in Scotland. Something has to be done to support the custodians of the Western Isles, namely the people who live there.
-
Donald MacIsaac 18 Jul 2013Protected status needs to change as a number of 10,000 in the Uists alone indicates that there is not a need for protected status.
-
Iain Macdonald 18 Jul 2013geese should be culled and made available for public consumption
-
Donald Houston 18 Jul 2013The Scottish Executive is self evidently not interested in the problems faced by crofters and farmers in the Highlands and Islands as this matter has been brought to their attention on many occasions in the past. They are more interested in ensuring that they don't upset enormously wealthy organisations such as RSPB than they are in the few votes they might get from the Crofting Counties. The extent of the damage caused to both grazings and the reduction in the annual silage crop is enormous and directly affects the viability of significant numbers of crofting and farming enterprises.
-
Jim Stamper 19 Jul 2013While conservation has its place it seems now to have got out of hand in many cases. If it carries on the only human inhabitants will be the conservationists.
-
Kevin Kennedy 19 Jul 2013Out of control! 6 years ago I seen the first goose on the croft and thought it was a great novelty. Now I have them camped out all year eating everything in the early season where a bite of grass is at a premium. I've also noticed more abortions and deformitities in sheep as the geese increase. It may be unrelated but their leavings are everywhere, bursting with e-coli and salmonella. Can't be healthy.
-
alex morrison 19 Jul 2013a major cull will have to start asap otherwise the good investment in crofting is going to be flushed down the swannee
-
Karen Tait 19 Jul 2013Greylag geese caused significant damage to our barley field. They also eat a lot of our winter grass. Something needs to be done!
-
Andrew MacKinnon 19 Jul 2013My land is always under threat from geese. They ruin crops and they ruin a lot of much needed grazing. Also when you get large flocks eating the grass, the stock will not go back to that area until the following year.
-
Hugh MacInnes 20 Jul 2013constantly keeping geese off crops. need a cull
-
Mabel Georgina Macaulay 20 Jul 2013Had difficulty with security words
-
Mark Cockram 20 Jul 2013Its not just the Western Isles that are being affected, their numbers are increasing in Orkney as well and already have a finacial affect on the farms they gather on.
-
Lynn Thomson 21 Jul 2013Geese are becoming a problem on Westray Orkney, something needs to be done control their increasing numbers.
-
magnus henderson 21 Jul 2013I support this petition
-
Ronald Maclean 22 Jul 2013Some questions
-
Who is stopping realistic action being taken to significantly reduce geese numbers. E.g. allowing their meat to be sold into food chain?
How many geese are on Lewis?
What is the target number?
What is the purpose of their protection?
What benefits do they bring?
Are these benefits worth more than farming or crofting?
Etc
There's more questions than answers! -
Steven Bain 22 Jul 2013Greylag geese that nest in Orkney should be wiped out as they shouldn't be here.
-
Nick Joy 23 Jul 2013There are way too many geese on all of the outer isles. Orkney and Shetland are inundated. It is time something was done.
-
Martin Palmer 23 Jul 2013Geese in this area of Point on Lewis have become a real problem both for eating grass all year round and for the mess they make on pavements, paths and roads from their droppings. They also leave these droppings around houses where young children play and then tend to pick them up. This is surely a health hazard. Geese are not natural in these numbers and may well be affecting other species with whom they compete for breeding space. This may partly explain the reduction in Terns as on our local loch the Terns have to compete with the Geese for space and, being smaller, the Terns tend to loose out. Geese should be culled back to their former level and should not be allowed to breed here. If the Government and or SNH cannot afford to do this Crofters cannot afford not to do it and will, if allowed, soon sort out the problem.
-
Angus Macleod 24 Jul 2013The Geese on Lewis are nesting in such high numbers that the longer this is allowed to go on crofting will become a thing of the past.
Please do something about this sooner rather than later? -
Mike Briggs 24 Jul 2013I just cannot understand why these geese can't be shot and eaten. When we are visiting the Uists we always ask where we can get goose to eat and answer comes there none... All that free food going to waste.
-
Alexander Murray 25 Jul 2013"dominion over the creation" is a basic ordinance, irrevocabably given to man by the Creator Himself, and requiring continuing implementation on our part
-
Alasdair Mackenzie 25 Jul 2013Crofting, by definition, is barely sustainable and the locust like damage to crops and grassland on the islands is a real threat to the economy.
-
Andrew Miller 25 Jul 2013It is said that 5 geese eat the equivalent of 1 sheep, I've never seen so many as this year. Time to reduce the amount of geese to protect crofting
-
Iona MacDonald 27 Jul 2013The number of geese has a detrimental effect on various asspects of farming. In one case they cleared a field of potatoes. It is a situation that requires to be addressed
-
Lewis Shand 27 Jul 2013Ignoring this obvious problem is no longer an option. We need a viable control plan NOW!
I have over 30 geese in front of our house daily in the winter, and the numbers keep increasing. They have returned again in the past week. -
calum morrison 31 Jul 2013We have to cut goose numbers.
-
Iain Campbell 1 Aug 2013If nothing done there be no Crofting
-
Alayne Cameron 13 Aug 2013We are having in excess of 100 geese landing on our fields just now 13 th August.we can no longer put up with these numbers or we will have no feed for our sheep.
-
M Kimm 28 Aug 2013Promote crofting?? The crofters are fighting a losing battle!
-
Richard Oliver 28 Aug 2013The geese damage crops and cost the farming community hundreds of pounds in damage the only solution is to shoot as many as possible.
-
John Murdo M MacLennan 28 Aug 2013I can no longer be chasseing geese of my crofts. I have crofts in Arnol 13 miles away from Stornoway and I have crofts in Newvalley to so I cant travel 13 miles to geep geese of my crofts and they are making a mess and eating all the grass so I have no place to put my sheep. I hope you will do something about this.
-
DW Sinclair 28 Aug 2013An appropriately worded 'General License' for a couple of years would be of huge benefit to those affected. this could then be reviewed and extended if necessary. Numbers are now beyond easy control and require a more concerted effort to bring the numbers down.
-
Gary Stanger 29 Aug 2013Geese are wrecking crops nearing ready for cutting. cut them to a better number or the farmers will be eaten under!
-
William Harcus 29 Aug 2013The geese are way out of control we should be aloud to shoot on an open licence all year. It is very hard to get a big number culled in the summer time by shooting alone.We should be aloud to round up the young before they can fly and manage them in this way for a few years.The grass and crop damage is massive now.
-
Alan Stevenson 29 Aug 2013We have hundreds of geese on our fields. They ruin the grass and eat the barley leaving less for our cattle. In the past we just had a few migratory geese but now the population has exploded and there are ever more geese breeding here in Orkney. Something needs to be done. It would be more humane to deal with the geese when they are still flightless.
-
Ann Stevenson 29 Aug 2013The damage done by the geese is enormous. Something needs to be done to control the numbers.
-
hugh seatter 30 Aug 2013Goose numbers here on hoy are forcing huge extra cost on our farm geese eat the barley seed the day you sow it they eat it when it when it is growing and now as it ripens it takes a gas gun to 5 acres if you want crop to harvest.We have had to stop growing swedes turnips as you just lose the hole crop . The Orkney country side is rely changing as growers place old cars around there fields in desperate attempts to move the geese on to someone else . Reckon it wont be long till someone takes foxes hear might be the lesser of the 2 evils.
-
george craig archibald 30 Aug 2013grelags need to be designated on an open licence as vermin.
protected spieceis need to be managed to a level the public can afford and farmers and crofters can sustain -
David J. Ker 30 Aug 2013About 20000 greylag geese landed in the two fields shut up for early grazing on the 3rd of April 2013 and completely bared them making it the middle of May before we could turn out the cattle about three weeks later than normal