Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01732 · Session 5

A toolkit for working with the Pathological Demand Avoidance profile of ASD

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2019 Health
Signatures
0
1,214 online signatures with a country
Comments
101
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to-
1. Draw up in co-operation with others, a toolkit for professionals to assist in diagnosing and designing therapeutic support for children, young people and adults who have Pathological Demand Avoidance, a profile within the autism spectrum
2. Offer training in the use of such a toolkit and additionally to signpost, promote and facilitate other training by those who have successfully developed therapeutic programmes
3. Provide access to appropriate education, therapies and interventions to reduce or minimise the effects of the condition for the individuals and their families and carers.

What the petitioner did first

Previously submitted a petition (PE1625) on this issue
Have continued to raise this issue with various MSPs and MPs

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 19 Sep 2019
    1 mention
  2. 20 Feb 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,214 online signatures
  1. Scotland723 59.6%
  2. England267 22%
  3. United Kingdom153 12.6%
  4. Wales25 2.1%
  5. United States14 1.2%
  6. Australia9 0.7%
  7. Northern Ireland6 0.5%
  8. Ireland5 0.4%
  9. Canada3 0.2%
  10. New Zealand3 0.2%
  11. 5 other countries6 0.5%

Comments

101 comments, oldest first
101 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Stefanie Harms 22 Jul 2019
    Please please support these children & families
  2. Pauline Grigor - Borders Additional Needs Group SCIO 23 Jul 2019
    BANG SCIO is a charity based in Scottish Borders with over 60 families and a membership of over 250. We have been contacted by families living in Borders with children on PDA profile, and we have 1 confirmed PDA adult. Families are contacting us in crisis with lack of support form health, CAHMS. There are no strategies in place to support the children Unmet needs within this context to the child and thier families is having a significant traumatic affect on the families. We introduced PDA trainign in 2018 and had limited uptake form professionals and there is a significant lack of awareness of PDA profile. Families are isolated and powerless with no support,the result is leaving children being punished for non compliance and often the police are called , the resulting trauma to the child and thier families breaching many disability and equality acts. This must be tackled as a matter of urgency
  3. Anne mitchell 24 Jul 2019
    Help support kids with this profile as lack of diagnosing and understanding means these kids are passed from professional to professional n back again with still no support which from personal family experience know this has a very serious probably long lasting affect on these kids mental health
  4. Euan Robson 24 Jul 2019
    It would be both ground breaking and positive if the Scottish Government was to move on from conventional wisdom and adopt what the petitioners request
  5. Euan Robson 24 Jul 2019
    It would be a great step forward if the Scottish Government broke with conventional wisdom and did as the petitioners request.
  6. Christine Nancollas 24 Jul 2019
    Children withPDA are high on the spectrum of autism and their anxiety expresses itself bu screaming and hitting because they are afraid Children have been abused with this condition by excluding them and putting them into solitary confinement which exarcerbates their anxiety Teachers and people working with these children need to have special training in how to help these children Local authorities have got to start being realistic and helpful in funding their needs
  7. Ian Turnbull 25 Jul 2019
    PDA is a known condition within the Autistic Spectrum, yet some health professionals refuse to recognise or diagnose the condition. This results in no support for the person or their family. This has been the case with family member. Even after getting a private diagnosis, health professionals within my local authority area, still refuse to recognise that it is a condition. Consequently they refuse to provide any meaningful help to them or their parents.
  8. Gillian Newman 25 Jul 2019
    Highland Children's Forum have heard from parents and from professionals working with children on the autism spectrum who have also had Pathological Demand Avoidance. To support such children the intervention can seem counterintuitive to "normal" parenting or child care. It is so important that both parents of children with PDA and the staff who work with such children have the right training and that the children get the right support.
  9. Lisa Reid 26 Jul 2019
    I have experienced a lack of awareness, acknowledgment and support from healthcare and education professionals. This has resulted in a lack of reasonable adjustments for a family member, causing them increased levels of anxiety, symptomatic behaviour and even school refusal.
  10. catia Santos 27 Jul 2019
    The medical and education system need to learn and acknowledge PDA as a diagnosis and special needs
    it is hard to believe that diagnosis and treatment is not being given or acknowledged when a child has PDA or symptoms of it early diagnosis support and adjusted interactions can make a huge difference to that child's whole life from education to lifestyle to socialising the longer it is left unrecognised and unmanaged the more children that will suffer great perils in growing up and adult life.
    It would benefit nor only the patient and family, friends but school peers and teachers as early acknowledgement and support can mean the difference between a child who does not fair well in education, life and employment also when needs are managed and supported early it will make a huge difference in preventing further harm and difficulties for all involved especially the patient because without support, understanding and adapted interactions the damage, confusion and emotional damage PDA causes will cause numerous other issues, struggles and needs for the patient and those around them.
    Let's teach, understand and accept PDA so that the future can be brighter and happier for so many undiagnosed, misunderstood and lost patients and families.
  11. Danielle Jata-Hall 28 Jul 2019
    This is great what you are doing for other vulnerable families, thank you and keep up the good work
  12. Doreen Hayes 28 Jul 2019
    PDA or Pathalogical Demand Avoidance does exist and can be diagnosed as those of us with children who present PDA know. No longer will we accept a non diagnosis of PDA. Why are the professionals reluctant to diagnose PDA Could it be that we the parent.grandparent. carers of these children have more knowledge of PDA than the professionals. Makes me wonder.
  13. Bill Chisholm 29 Jul 2019
    It is high time those suffering from this disorder received the care and services they deserve.
  14. Kirsty macneil 29 Jul 2019
    Highlands
  15. Amanda Maguire 29 Jul 2019
    It is imperative that PDA is recognised!
  16. Sarah Whyte 30 Jul 2019
    Young primary age family member has undiagnosed PDA. They have an HFA diagnosis but classic PDA has a wellbeing plan that was written and includes PDA strategies but both mainstream and their specialist placement don't call it that or mention it and a member of staff told family member that it didn't exist when I had explained it to them to help understand them and their presentation. The plan is not followed and neither school used the strategies. This ended up with family member being restrained and secluded on a daily basis which was not recorded or reported to family other than on the odd occasion. Family wrote to the QIO and Head of Educations services and the schools and Ed Psych and they only received a few lines in reply from the school two days later. There was no acknowledgement of what happened. Currently they are providing much better support and family member is no longer being restrained and new teacher is applying PDA strategies well. As a result they get on much better but not able to join the mainstream class. Family member has days where the demand avoidance is too great and they refuse to attend but listening to them and respecting that means the rest of the week goes more smoothly.
  17. Deirdre shakespeare 30 Jul 2019
    I signed this as I support your petition of PDA toolkit which may help practitioners know how to manage children with PDA so that families like yours aren't torn apart through injustice, blame and failure to appropriately support and diagnose.
    I hope when the Scottish government agree to your petition it will then become a nation wide toolkit for not only Scotlands children but children in N.Ireland, England and Wales.
  18. Elaine Macdougall 31 Jul 2019
    Even with some school support in place family member only managed 6 weeks of high school and has since spent the last 5 years educating themself from home. For some children mainstream school will just not work but access to a national online curriculum would. This would benefit not just PDA children but other children who struggle with school for other reasons. The other thing for professionals to understand is the stress having a PDA child causes to to the whole household, often marriages fail and siblings develop extreme anxiety, leaving the parents feeling blamed instead of being supported.
  19. Claire neilson 3 Aug 2019
    Family member is not diagnosed yet. They are on the waiting list for asd and odd assessment. But family are 100% sure they are pda. This is all great work yous are doing and families and everyone else in this situation are so thankful.
  20. Anne Moody 4 Aug 2019
    Family member has PDA, they are now home schooled. The education system has failed them on numerous occasions. The family has done their utmost to promote and educate others on their family member's experience with PDA. They are family member's only true support system. It is heart wrenching to see, hear and read of families' struggles with the system.

    A toolkit if followed would be fantastic.

    Involve those who know, what these children and adults are suffering. Parents, grandparents and siblings and extended family have a wealth of experience and knowledge.
  21. Helen Ferguson 4 Aug 2019
    more training needs to be done on PDA to help our kids be understood more and to get the help and support they need. It would help to keep them in mainstream school as a lot of these children are now having to be home school due to schools not being able to fulfill their educational, emotional , physical well being
  22. Erin Walsh 5 Aug 2019
    At young age, family member was permanently excluded from their first primary school. At another school they were placed on a reduced timetable, at one point only going to school for an hour and a half on a Monday. . . They were banned from after school clubs, refused permission to attend the valentine's disco and was excluded on countless occasions between September and May.... They are still only young primary age. Just terrible, had no idea the reduced timetable was unlawful I just went with what the school said. Family had to give up job as they were excluded so frequently. Just terrible. They are in a specialist community school now but it is very very far away and they have had no exclusions which is a positive. But still, family member as PDA and if professionals were aware of what that actually is and how to manage it maybe family member wouldn't have been failed and traumatised simply because professionals couldn't manage them. This needs to change before more kids are failed.
  23. April Prior 5 Aug 2019
    Famly member is adult and very clearly has PDA. The issue is that standard autism support is regimented and structured with full routines. This is exactly what they cannot cope with and they launch into damaging and self injurious behaviours. For 18 months family member has been an inpatient in an LD ward and family has fought and fought for this part of their autism profile to be taken on board. Family continue to be ignored. The amount of pressure people with PDA as part of their profile are under is inhumane. No they don't want to eat when you tell them to, they will eat when ready, no they don't want to go out when you are ready, they want to go out when they are ready. Family member now also has depression and anxiety and this is all down to people ignoring this part of their profile
  24. Julia McDermott 6 Aug 2019
    I feel a family member has this and family could do with support to help us help them.
  25. Emmajane Terry 7 Aug 2019
    Please provide access to appropriate education
  26. Evelyn Vrouwenfelder 7 Aug 2019
    A family member has autism and I had never heard of PDA. For school and families having a toolkit would be essential to childrens' wellbeing and educational achievement.
  27. Cathrine Cook 7 Aug 2019
    More awareness and support for parents and teachers to understand how to best support children with PDA.
  28. Clare Chalmers 8 Aug 2019
    To fully understand and therefore offer appropriate help and support for children with PDA it is vital Practitioners receive training in the condition. Training leads to early recognition early intervention which can make all the difference. PDA is a development disorder which is distinct from autism, there are differences. It is anxiety driven with a need to feel in control the problem is incapacity rather than naughtiness. Without recognition children can be left with a trial and error situation which is frustrating for everyone. To Get it right for PDA children there needs to be correct diagnosis followed by support strategies which are specific. A toolkit for practitioners would be a good way to go, hopefully leading onto positive outcomes and happy stress free children. Although more PDA cases are being diagnosed more needs to be done.
    Families should be involved at all stages and contribute to producing an effective toolkit. The PDA society should also be invited to contribute to a toolkit.
    Many children with PDA have suffered and been wrongly labelled as a result of poor recognition and support, it is time to ensure Scotland GETs It Right For PDA children.
  29. Leeanna Emmons 8 Aug 2019
    It needs to be recognized in the united states
  30. Eleanor anderson 8 Aug 2019
    The young people need help, the parents need help, and the teachers and assistants need help. PDA is a really demanding, difficult condition to understand and all help would be really appreciated
  31. Kirsten Terry 8 Aug 2019
    I live in Kent and I have found an enormous lack of awareness and lack of education among health and education professionals regarding PDA. Many have absolutely no understanding of PDA or the difficulties faced by the families, children and young people who deal with PDA everyday. The majority of schools are unable or unwilling to support children with PDA and many blame parenting rather than bother to research how they could help. I believe the development of a PDA toolkit would have a very positive impact. First of all, parents would feel believed and support could be provided at a much earlier point. Children could receive a diagnosis which would help professionals recognise PDA and learn strategies to provide support. Recognition of PDA would improve as would understanding. I think it would also positively impact on the mental health of both parents and children touched by PDA. I think the team should be from multiple diaciplines
    - parents, educationalists, psychologists but ultimately all those involved should be passionate about improving the support and understanding of PDA.
  32. Susan Moody 9 Aug 2019
    It is an absolute disgrace that in this current day, there is members of our Society who are not being given an accurate diagnosis and individualised description of how their condition effects them and signposts to the correct strategies that allow them to thrive in life.
    It is therefore imperative that such information is made available to all service providers to prevent further trauma associated with continuting to signpost individuals to typical parenting, support strategies or Autism strategies.
    A Toolkit specifically for PDA is therefore required imminently, if not as a stand alone resource as a subset within the current Autism Toolkit.
    With the huge emphasis on Scotland being an ACE aware Nation, it is shocking to allow children and adults to continue tp experience the trauma caused by the lack of adequate support and mismanagement from all public services.
    It is time to not just raise awareness or acceptance but to take action to allow these individuals to access the support they so desperately need. For those already suffering to have the support to recover and better support moving forward and for those yet to come to not be subjected to the sheer ignorance that we see today.
  33. Tracey Turner 14 Aug 2019
    The inconsistencies across the UK beggars belief and makes parents, such as myself, so frustrated, angry, depressed with feelings of failure because of this. Some parents are paying in excess of £2k for a private diagnosis, just so they and their child can get the correct help and support.
    I have been advised by a charitable helpline that a family member appears to have PDA not clinical psychologists charging thousands to assess them for adhd for the last 6 years.
    psychologists should know symptoms and traits of all conditions, just in the same way a gp has a broad knowledge of nearly all physical illnesses.
  34. Pauline Anderson 14 Aug 2019
    Its important for all children to get an education. A toolbox for working with our children would make a vast difference. A family member is struggling in school and their school is using PDA strategies to help them cope. Thos should be the same for all children with PDA. Children are very clever and will be great members of society and the workforce. Please give them a chance to do by having a PDA toolbox in schools.
  35. Sally Hesford 15 Aug 2019
    Much more awareness and understanding of this condition is essential for Early Years practitioners and everyone who contributes to development in children.
  36. Marie Lacey 16 Aug 2019
    I am working with children with additional needs and would welcome some guidance to help myself and others support this need,
  37. Karen McCormick 16 Aug 2019
    It is a disgrace that in this day and age that so many children are being failed by a system that could be so easily solved..... Parents are having to fight for the right for their childrens support & education.... This is so wrong on so many levels.... Utter disgrace.... The government & local councils should be ashamed of themselves.... We are in the 21st century not the dark ages..... Get a grip for the sake of our children's futures!!!!!
  38. Barbara Richards 17 Aug 2019
    I was diagnosed with PTSD in 2005 and Asperger Syndrome in 2007, but I've been rediagnosed by local police as a pest and my GP colluded with others to stalk me so they could take away my PIP and now I am a prisoner I hardly go anywhere and people laugh at me and call me a loser and a nutter. I think they want me to kill myself and one day I nearly did, I was going to throw myself off the motorway bridge but my neighbour stopped me. I don't have a life in just existing I listen to music and paint and try to block it out but I get very very very depressed. I've tried to complain about it but all the complaints are blocked and PALS are useless and I can't get a lawyer so I feel like nothing. I am not allowed to marry my partner they've all ganged up on me and I don't know what to do.
  39. Barbara Ann Dow 17 Aug 2019
    Teachers do not get enough training or proper support in teaching for people with PDA.
    If you want to get people with PDA into employment you need to give them and employers the tools to do so.
  40. Laura rayner 17 Aug 2019
    please make people more aware of PDA. Family member is suffering as there is no help or support out there. They are almost 10
  41. Sarah willshire 19 Aug 2019
    Having a family member with autism and pda I think this would be really beneficial especially in schools who have no idea how to deal with children like this and instead that child is being punished and excluded from school for behaviours they have no control of. They have personally been a victim of this situation and has been out of school now for 6months. They are 6years old and the way they have been treated is disgusting
  42. May Keegan 20 Aug 2019
    Education is needed for all schools dealing with pda
  43. Sally Anderson 20 Aug 2019
    PDA IS REAL, Too many parents, claimed by medical & educational professionals. sent on loads of parenting courses being told how to parent children etc. Family were were lucky.it only took 4 years to get family member's correct diagnosis to be told, ignore everything you were tought on the course.it wont work or will make them worse. Family knew that.we they had been telling everyone else that for 4 years. because it's not yet in diagnosis manual there is far too many differences depending on the professional you deal with & also it's a postcode lottery. Children deserve every opportunity to live their lives to their best potential without either killing themselves intentionally or accidentally or another individuals because they cant cope with life.
  44. Dawne Randell 20 Aug 2019
    A young primary age family member has been to two primary schools and is now home schooled because the education system is not able to meet their needs. Family has found nobody in the education system so far that knows what they are doing for a child with PDA. It has been up to family to provide resources and sign post to resources for those who have worked with family membr but unfortunately it's not taken on board and they have suffered. There needs to be a complete overhall of the system.
  45. Elizabeth Souter 20 Aug 2019
    Teachers need much more training and support in order to deal with all the issues that children with PDA have to deal with in their lives.
  46. Maria Harkin 20 Aug 2019
    This is a much needed service. PDA is still such a new diagnosis that most professionals have never even heard of it. For that reason parents aren't being heard and in turn are directed to the wrong services.
  47. Elizabeth Souter 20 Aug 2019
    PDA continues to be an unknown condition even to those working in the education system. Just a naughty child is usually the response! Time to get real in the Scottish Education system! Hope J S is reading this!
  48. Fiona Gartland 21 Aug 2019
    These children and young adults are being failed by the system and its not fair on them or their families. They deserve so much more
  49. Connie paterson 21 Aug 2019
    Because family members and others deserve to be helped.
  50. Sheena Crosbie 21 Aug 2019
    PDA is a real condition. Show it the respect it deserves and provide support and resources to help.