Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01716 · Session 5

Full review of mental health service provision across the NHS in Scotland

Closed Submitted 4 Nov 2018 Health
Signatures
0
882 online signatures with a country
Comments
102
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to carry out a full review of mental health services across the NHS in Scotland, to ensure that policy and practice is delivered consistently across the country.

What the petitioner did first

Raised this issue with Monica Lennon MSP, who asked a question to the First Minister. Have had a meeting with the mental health minister, and our concerns have been reported in the media.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 4 Apr 2019
    1 mention
  2. 21 Nov 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

882 online signatures
  1. Scotland759 86.1%
  2. United Kingdom77 8.7%
  3. England30 3.4%
  4. Australia6 0.7%
  5. Ireland2 0.2%
  6. Northern Ireland2 0.2%
  7. Spain1 0.1%
  8. United States1 0.1%
  9. Wales1 0.1%
  10. Cyprus1 0.1%
  11. 2 other countries2 0.2%

Comments

102 comments, oldest first
102 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Sarah McGrath 13 Feb 2019
    My family currently has complaints in with the NHS and also SPSO.We have had a horrific 2 years. A close relative was repeatedly arrested whilst asking for help at A&E. This happened 20 times before she was sectioned eventually after 5 weekends in the cells and several court appearances..She was also fobbed off,as were we.'She can help this' and 'there's no sign of mental illness' were frequent refrains.It's an utter disgrace and has to change.
  2. Fiona French 13 Feb 2019
    Mental health services must be reviewed in Scotland. Patients clearly cannot get the help they need and many are being harmed as a result. Psychiatric drugs are widely prescribed and many are being unnecessarily harmed as a result. The focus on supporting young people and preventing long term mental health issues is very welcome but this is only one section of the population.
  3. Michael Needham 13 Feb 2019
    Hopefully there will be changes and life's can be saved.
  4. Craig ORourke 13 Feb 2019
    It's become all too common to read and hear about NHS failings throughout Scotland. Mental health is very important. I am currently fighting my own battle to be heard about poor service and care. A full review of Mental Health services throughout Scotland needs to be done as soon as possible. Vulnerable people need help instead they are just being ignored and let down by mental health services.
  5. Josephine Docherty 13 Feb 2019
    I am aware of both adults and children at their wits end as they've been unable to access mental health services, one situation was a child having to wait 11 months to access CAHMS. Resources are being continually cut and this is resulting in the loss of life when people see no way out, but suicide. Their poor families are left distraught and no doubt left with mental health issues themselves. More support is required.
  6. Catherine Matheson 13 Feb 2019
    My son spent many years in the care of adult mental health services, before succumbing to his illness six years ago. Inpatient services have now been removed completely from Angus and I believe my son was failed terribly by Care in the community.
  7. Val Herbert 14 Feb 2019
    A countrywide review is needed as the current system is letting families down accross the board, not enough support and long waiting lists when urgent crisis care is required.
  8. Christina McCallum 16 Feb 2019
    My son took his own life in October 9 days after being discharged from hospital which he should never have been. Twice within a 10hr period he was taken to hospital as he was suicidal only to be told to go visit his own doctor. He never made it to the doctors instead he took his own life.
  9. Jon Hudson 19 Feb 2019
    Good luck guys. Respect
  10. Gillian Tosh 19 Feb 2019
    So many being failed with support that then causes mental health. a family member has had from age of 6 because of being bullied to comply instead of supported with autism, PDA and adhd.It is a disgrace. The education system has alot to answer for and professionals that know the issues and ignore them as just as bad
  11. Gareth Lownds 20 Feb 2019
    I'm a serving Police Officer. I mean no disrespect to either organisation as they try there best but neither the Police more so particularly and the NHS are not equipped to deal with MH Issues. The Police aren't medically trained. There aren't enough RMN or facilities. I've seen or heard too many of my fellow colleagues committing or attempting to commit suicide. I've been to so many suicides that will haunt me and last me a lifetime. The Government need to take stock just cos it isn't happening to them and or they can use private healthcare the wider public aren't so lucky. The Government need to take action now and flood the NHS with money for MH Issues as this is the next big disease.
  12. Michael Needham 20 Feb 2019
    Really important that this is looked at as could save lives and help people.
  13. Colin Watson 26 Feb 2019
    I would like to help or get involved
    My father was badly failed in wishaw General. He took his own life.
    Hopefully here back I would like to share my experience hopefully I can help.
  14. Marlyn Fraser 26 Feb 2019
    My experience of adult mental health services was totally negative and heart breaking. My heart goes out to people who need to access these services when they crash and burn and to the families who have to support them with no support.
  15. Findlay Wilson 3 Mar 2019
    A leaflet is not enough for people who are struggling to cope. Medical practitioners are required urgently countrywide who can help. The waiting time for those needing assistance is ridiculous.
  16. isabel barr 3 Mar 2019
    Good luck with this
  17. William Hamilton 3 Mar 2019
    Absolutely tragic.
  18. Ailie murphy 3 Mar 2019
    Media and campaigners have rightfully pushed for Mental health to be highlighted now deal with it!! And properly
  19. Gary Rowe 3 Mar 2019
    Please address this issue. We as a collective continue to let people down.
  20. Michael OHare 3 Mar 2019
    My experience of the Mental Health Service wasn't really great.
    Having suffered depression, anxiety and panic attacks, the waiting times were horrendous and ended up borrowing money to see a private counselor, which actually didn't help my problems at the time. More needs to be done upfront nowadays because the rate of suicide is only going to rise.
  21. Kelvin Martin 3 Mar 2019
    My personal and professional experience is one of dismay, dismay at the lack of core services available to those suffering from mental health related illnesses. There is a lack of mental health hospitals which in turn hampers the work that can be done and is required to successfully treat someone. I also believe there are a number of people suffering from drug induced mental health issues who should be treated in drug rehab centres, thus leaving mental health units free for those who require intensive treatment at the time of crisis. The other anomaly in the system is the disparity in approaches from different health boards, taking those suffering from mental health crises to accident and emergency departments is not only insensitive but unconducive to reducing unnecessary patient time for those who require physical care for acute conditions. Those with mental health conditions should be taken to dedicated hospitals, politicians need to stop talking up investment and start progressing this critical issue by listening to families and patients. More staff and hospitals are what's needed!!!! And now.
  22. Anne Higgins 3 Mar 2019
    Done
  23. Lyn Conn 4 Mar 2019
    Adult mental Health services are not adequate in Scotland. I feel badly about people needing this service.
  24. Bodil McCaskill 4 Mar 2019
    Services are very poor and the drugs given by GOs are hit or miss with many having dreadful long term side effects. More funding is needed for CBT, Mindefulness and counselling
  25. MARGARET WHITE 4 Mar 2019
    Mental health is an illness if you haven't suffered it some people don't understand..
  26. Sharon hossack 4 Mar 2019
    Family member has to wait over a year that could be 12 months to late
  27. Lee-Anne King 4 Mar 2019
    Mental health in this country is joke no wonder people are at breaking point when they can't get the help they need til it's too late. We go from having a exceptionally poor children's mental health service going into a worse star of affairs when you are an adult. It's time.for change and excuses to stop, waiting lists to be reduced significantly and appropriate help for everyone even those with diagnosed neurological disorders and not to be booted out the other side with no help and the excuse it part if your condition. This needs to change and end.
  28. Lorraine Noble-Thompson 5 Mar 2019
    Needs for young people is overlooked ..
  29. Jackie Waddell 5 Mar 2019
    This is a life or death service . I have had mental health issues all my adult life. It is not always taken seriously enough.
  30. Stephanie Cowper 6 Mar 2019
    It's real and it effects everyone
  31. Suzanne moran 6 Mar 2019
    More needs to be done !!
  32. lynn Bennett 7 Mar 2019
    NHS, Mental health in this country is disgusting its like in the old days when mental health was swept under the carpet nobody wants to know or care. Our world has changed in so many ways and many people are suffering anxiety depression the GPS do not care or understand mental health issues. A proper team needs to be involved. with all mental health problems.
  33. Mary speirs 7 Mar 2019
    There is a serious epidemic in young people having mental health problems due to low self esteam and unreal expectations of how life should be as portrayed thrpugh social media. This needs to ne addressed urgently nefore more of our ypung people fall victim and suffer.
  34. Laura Duguid 7 Mar 2019
    Something had to be done
  35. Lorraine Bowman 7 Mar 2019
    Hearing so many people taking there own lives. Mental health issues are the new silent kille
  36. Karen Glackin 7 Mar 2019
    Mental illness needs to be recognised before its too late too many cover ups Mental Health issues Do exist
  37. Nichols Bannon 7 Mar 2019
    Just feel something drastic has to change within our society with regards to the mental health act . Losing too many young people. Clearly something isn't working .
  38. Stephen Shaw 7 Mar 2019
    Think Again, keep talking.
  39. Samantha Farrell 8 Mar 2019
    Need action now.
  40. Sarah McBride 8 Mar 2019
    The Mental Health Service in Scotland is currently not fit for purpose. Too many vital links are broken, wrong information recorded, resulting in readmition, promises of help made several times- broken twice now.
  41. Christine Tod 11 Mar 2019
    Mental Health Services MUST be prioritised!!! Poor mental health is an increasing concern and education is needed to end the stigma which is attached to it!!! It is an invisible and very debilitating illness.
  42. Angela Gillies 12 Mar 2019
    A vast overhaul of mental health services is required in Scotland.
  43. Ricky Grogan 13 Mar 2019
    Listen to the people!
  44. Scott Murphy 15 Mar 2019
    From experience it feels like the NHS and social services are failing those most in need and things are only going to get worse. A full review of all mental health services is needed.
  45. David merchant 15 Mar 2019
    In my work I deal with people who struggle with mental health issues every day. This should be a priority.
  46. Eddie manners 15 Mar 2019
    The Scottish government did to address this serious issue
  47. Caroline & Peter Murray & David Ramsay Senior 15 Mar 2019
    David Ramsay lost his life due to NHS failings.

    We, as a family, have been torn apart by this. our daughter, Gilly, has fought tirelessly and managed to get an inquiry into NHS Tayside Mental Health Services.

    We have met with Karen and heard from others across Scotland and are aware that these failings are not unique to Tayside (although it is our view that clearly there is something far wrong at Carseview Centre, the volume of deaths says it all).

    Welldone Gilly & Karen
  48. Tracy Costello 15 Mar 2019
    The mental health services are over stretched and the NHS and the government needs to do something to improve the situation the waiting list for counseling in Dundee is very long .
  49. Alex Ramsay 17 Mar 2019
    I think patients are turned away due to lack of funds. And why would that be? After all it is NATIONAL health! So why are the problems experienced more in Scotland???
  50. Sean Connor 18 Mar 2019
    Doctors and nurses are guaranteed their salaries for turning up for work. What guarantees do the people.have? I think an overhaul is needed ASAP!