Petition · PE01705 · Session 5
Wildlife crime - penalties and investigation
Signatures
0
Comments
104
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review legislation relating to the investigation of and penalties applicable to wildlife crime in Scotland.
What the petitioner did first
I have written to my MSPs, and have had correspondence with the Scottish Government and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).
I have also written to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee
I have also written to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee
Where it was considered
Official Report-
25 Oct 20181 mention
-
4 Apr 20191 mention
-
10 Oct 20191 mention
-
23 Feb 20211 mention
Signatures by country
365 online signaturesComments
104 comments, oldest first104 comments · showing 51–100
-
ruth gould 28 Aug 2018it's obscene. our countryside is taken under the control of keepers who frequently are found to be persecuting other wildlife to an extent that endangers their species. the death is in terrifying noise and danger, it isnt a guaranteed a quick kill, it's excessive, violent and disrupts actual natural life
-
Robin Wallace 28 Aug 2018We need a proper deterrent to wildlife crime and animal cruelty.
-
Dennis Hollinghurst 28 Aug 2018Scotland's Government must make greater efforts and pass stronger statutes in order to reduce and hopefully eliminate wildlife crime.
-
Pauline Goodwin 28 Aug 2018The corruption of judges etc in prosecution of these law breakers is shameful
-
Val Salmon 28 Aug 2018As long as the consequences for killing wildlife are small fines and suspended custodial and not reflective of the cruelty and environmental damage involved these people will continue committing wildlife crime virtually immune . Hit them hard in the pocket , make sentences a minimum 12 month custodial and strip them permanently of gun licences . The environmental value of wildlife is without question priceless
-
James Albaya 28 Aug 2018Its a sad reflection of our current laws that tghey have become use less because they are no up held and prosecutions are rare and NEVER fit the crime We need action now while we still have some wildlife to save
- because its got to such a sorry state. -
Ian Currie 28 Aug 2018Large parts of the Scottish countryside are virtual wildlife free zones due to barbaric outdated land management traditions . It has to stop!
-
Barbara Milligan 28 Aug 2018Even 3 years is modest for some of the cruelties perpetrated.
-
Joyce Marriott 28 Aug 2018High time the tariff for these crimes was updated. The fines and punishments are a joke.
-
Derek Haggerty 28 Aug 2018All creatures deserve respect!
-
nikki brannan 28 Aug 2018please increase the penalties for persecution of out wildlife. we need to protect not persecute
-
Lucy Searle 28 Aug 2018If people are caught mistreating and killing wildlife they deserve the full force of the law. Crimes against nature are abhorrent and have no place in a decent civilised society
- any punishments must reflect this. -
Paul Edwards 28 Aug 2018Penalties must be tougher otherwise there is no deterrent.
-
Ernie Scales 28 Aug 2018All wildlife crime should be subject to the same minimum and maximum penalties the term to be decided in court. AND the use of video evidence whether filmed overtly or covertly should be admissible in court. Covert filming may be the only way to catch criminals in the act.
-
Debbie Wheelhouse 28 Aug 2018It's time the cruelty stopped!
-
Catherine Cameron 28 Aug 2018Wildlife crime is increasing in Scotland and currently both the enforcement of existing laws and penalties fail to deter wildlife criminals.
-
Heather Ryce 28 Aug 2018Why would anyone not agree with this??
-
Tracy Brighten 29 Aug 2018Scotland has such a diverse habitat for wildlife, still offering wilderness that isn't found in the rest of the UK. Scotland's Government has a responsibility to protect this unique habitat and wildlife from illegal activity. Penalties for wildlife crime must be tougher and video camera footage used to secure prosecutions.
-
Jacqueline Kyle 29 Aug 2018Do the landowners not realise the imbalance they create by killing raptors? We need stronger legislation and more severe penalties for the criminals who interfere with wildlife.
-
carol taylor 29 Aug 2018We should see a precedence for others to follow
-
Jean Bell 29 Aug 2018Our countryside is largely controlled and wrecked by the shooting estates and interests. They damage the environment by slaughtering indigenous and migratory birds, fish and mammals. In doing so they not only put our future in jeopardy but they reduce opportunities for eco and wildlife tourism which should be an important part of our economy. The feeble and limited penalities for wild life crime indicate that the government still puts the interests of the wealthy above those of the general population and the environment.
-
Andrea Goddard 29 Aug 2018You have my total support on this. By increasing the penalties to at least a 3 year jail sentence wildlife crimes will be then classified as serious. Covert cameras can then be placed by Police Scotland in order to detect any suspected wildlife crime, which is vital. Additionally any video evidence showing a wildlife crime taking place should be deemed admissible by the courts, as it would be when any other serious crime is filmed.
-
Janice Lawson 29 Aug 2018Fully agree with this..wildlife crimes may be taken more seriously with a stiffer sentence...this is long overdue
-
ranald leask 29 Aug 2018Bird watching and countless other country pursuits add millions of pounds to the rural economy. Quite apart from the appalling cruelty of those who kill and maim animals, the economic advantages of protecting animals in the wild should also be noted. Thus, increasing the penalties for those guilty of such crimes would benefit all in society, other than those intent on evil.
-
Patricia martin 29 Aug 2018Time justice was done
-
Joan Kevan 31 Aug 2018Totally support this petition , the wanton destruction of wildlife is shameful .
-
Stewart Love 31 Aug 2018Agree to wildlife crime penalties being increased to 3 years or more and to covert cameras being set out to catch wildlife criminals and being used when these criminals are brought to court.
-
Chris Batchelor 31 Aug 2018The land owners who employ these criminals are nothing more than supporters and facilitators of organised crime, and as the criminals are armed they should be taken far more seriously by police & courts alike. Any & every method of getting evidence must be adopted.
-
chris hawkins 1 Sep 2018Organised crime is now well established in the peace and tranquility of a British landscape. Unseen, un-recorded and commonly ignored. Increasing Wildlife Crime penalties to 3 years or more will begin to turn the tide in favour of what the people want "Wildlife Crime has to stop !" Good luck with the petition.
-
Kevin Kibble 1 Sep 2018Time to put an end to wildlife crime
-
Steve Harris 1 Sep 2018It cannot be right that a criminal escapes justice when a video recording, the integrity and reliability of which is proven, shows them breaking the law. The law is an ass if it frustrates justice.
-
John Calder 1 Sep 2018Genuine video footage should be taken at face value, whether taken deliberately or accidentally.
-
Sheila Dorsett 2 Sep 2018I agree to both increasing the sentences and also the acceptance by courts of the video evidence.
-
Keith Donnelly 2 Sep 2018I agree that video evidence should be admissible as evidence in a crime.
-
Sarah Reilly 3 Sep 2018Wish everyone would sign
-
Harris Keillar 3 Sep 2018Video evidence should be allowed in all cases of wildlife crime. The estates are happy to photograph us
- as at Glen Turret or via other remote monitoring devices as in Glen Lyon. These estates depend on subsidies which we as tax payers pay, so they should be subject to much greater control. -
Mary Betteridge 4 Sep 2018Wildlife crime penalties should definitely be increased to at least 3 years. The police can then set covert cameras to detect suspected wildlife crimes. Wildlife crimes should be treated as seriously as any other crime and any video evidence should be determined in the law courts.
-
Mr Jonathan P Tyler 6 Sep 2018That the very symbol of Scottish wildlife, the golden eagle, along with other species such as the elegant hen harrier, seem to be at risk from certain sectors of the grouse moor owning community is appalling. There have to be more convictions with heavier penalties to bring this culture to an end.
-
Angela Mounsey 6 Sep 2018It is essential that evidence taken by video cameras be admissible in Court.
I also think a much harsher penalty of 3 years imprisonment together fines and with a removal of licences should be applied. -
Pete Rowberry 6 Sep 2018The illegal persecution of our birds of prey is but one of the abominations of the driven grouse shoot. A study has shown that it is not economic unless large scale eradication of predators takes place. Even the Mountain hare falls victim to gamekeepers and the dead bodies are just dumped in "stink pits". A farmer would be prosecuted if he disposed of his dead stock in this way. End this abomination now.
-
Denise Young 7 Sep 2018Penalties far too lenient.
Dog breeders need much more policing and severe penalty . -
Liz Scott 8 Sep 2018Video evidence should be admissible
-
David Rodger 10 Sep 2018I agree with the aforementioned questions.There could only be positive results from the measures as I hope they will act as a deterrent because if doesn't we may as well say good bye to our beautiful wildlife .Also why aren't more of you signing this petition what on earth are you scared of would you rather these rural criminals had their way cause if they do we may as well go " hillwalking " on the moon.
-
Bree Tait 10 Sep 2018The law must be strong enough to to deterr as well as punish to help poor animals who are at the mercy of very cruel and file people! Protect our animal better!
-
dee donworth 22 Sep 2018I have car stickers. Love Scotland. Stop killing the wildlife !
-
jonathan david Grant 22 Sep 2018If someone commits a crime they must be punished for it.to kill wild animals for gain is a crime against GOD
-
George Murdoch 22 Sep 2018The fact that an individual can be photographed committing a crime and this evidence cannot be used in court because the beneficiary of the crime must consent to its use is ridiculous and must be terminated.
-
Patricia Scales 22 Sep 2018Not allowing covert video is ludicrous. No-one would commit a crime if they knew a camera was recording it, they'd just wait or commit the crime elsewhere.
-
Les Wallace 22 Sep 2018Those involved in Field Sports that claim they detest wildlife crime are perfectly free to sign as well
- how many have done so? -
Agnes Whiting. 22 Sep 2018All those who try to destroy the woodlands should be jailed for more than three years.