Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01690 · Session 5

Review treatment of people with ME in Scotland

Closed Submitted 20 Apr 2018 Health
Signatures
0
5,770 online signatures with a country
Comments
453
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the level of support for people with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) in Scotland with a view to:
Investing in biomedical research and creating a centre of excellence for ME
Ensuring healthcare professionals' training and education materials reflect the latest scientific evidence
Providing specialist care for patients and discontinuing the harmful treatments graded exercise therapy (GET) and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT).

What the petitioner did first

Contacted MSPs and the Health Minister.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 7 Jun 2018
    1 mention
  2. 8 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 22 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 30 May 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 19 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 26 Aug 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

5,770 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,904 33%
  2. England1,006 17.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 15.7%
  4. United States629 10.9%
  5. Australia259 4.5%
  6. Canada154 2.7%
  7. Netherlands135 2.3%
  8. Norway122 2.1%
  9. Germany101 1.8%
  10. Sweden99 1.7%
  11. 41 other countries453 7.9%

Comments

453 comments, oldest first
453 comments · showing 251–300
  1. Tom Kaardal 3 May 2018
    A member of my family has suffered for 12 years.
  2. Sarah Osborne 3 May 2018
    I have ME. I live in Wales but support this initiative
  3. Heather Tierney 3 May 2018
    A member of my family has ME and the lack of treatment and support she has received over the years is just shocking. The condition should receive the same level of funding as other life long conditions. The impact this condition has on your life is immense yet the others available are so limited.
  4. Lindsey Patrick 3 May 2018
    We need health care to understand this condition
  5. A.M.Lane 3 May 2018
    I am signing this on behalf of a family member wrho has had M.e. for 7 years now and nothing seems to be being done about it ,all our governments in the Uk should be putting more money into research and treatment of this illness
  6. Amy Keeton 3 May 2018
    I've been living with Myalgic E for a decade now, and know all too well what it does to a person's life. Sending my love and support to MEcfs patients in Scotland!
  7. Don Fraser 3 May 2018
    Important that help & recognition is given to sufferers, not just in Scotland but world wide.
  8. Michael Poston 3 May 2018
    I am affected by ME. The best treatment for me turned out to be a respite in warm climate with a carer. I am now well on the road to recovery. The mindfulness based cognitive therapy helped as well in providing me with the skill to identify exhaustion and crashes at an early stage. Allowing for rest and pauses before it is too late. But every sufferer is different. More active research would be nice. Better protection in the workplace and less pressure from the welfare system would aid a recovery.
  9. Mrs Irene Gallacher 3 May 2018
    I have a relative who has suffered from this illness for a long time and was not able to continue working.
    After receiving sickness benefit for a short while did not have the energy to go through the process of proving to the Benefits Agency their entitlement to benefit when it was stopped.Has now lived without the benefit that I personally think they were entitled to for some years now.I think that people who suffer from ME are treated like lazy people and this could not be further from the truth
    It is a totally misunderstood condition and it is about time that it was investigated in more detail by the health authorities..
  10. Helene Lockwood 3 May 2018
    A member of my family has suffered with M.E. for many years so have to give support to all, wherever they may be
  11. Christopher Spalding 3 May 2018
    We need much more research into this condition.
  12. Phil Murray 3 May 2018
    Improved care & biomedical research for people with MECFS must be a priority for the future. Actiono is needed now.
  13. Nancy Wilson 3 May 2018
    It took 20 years to get a diagnosis of Fibro ME 20years of pain fatigue Fibro fog this should not happen to anyone.
  14. Alison Caldwell 3 May 2018
    I have had M.E for 23 years and hope not to die with it. I'm 62.
  15. Lucy B 3 May 2018
    I have many friends who are living with ME in Scotland who would benefit from access to specialist care.
  16. Rose Ann-marie Slavin 3 May 2018
    I am Scottish but moved to England as a child. I have had ME for 8.5 years. I now realise 2 of my family members had it but was never diagnosed correctly. One of my family members died at 61. I don't want to follow her!
  17. Claire Prideaux 3 May 2018
    I have ME. I've lived with it for decades. The fact that governments have ignored us and worse, forced treatments on us that harm us is a travesty.
  18. Iain Gill 3 May 2018
    A member of my family has had ME for over 20 years. I totally agree with the petition. I recently had 12 weeks chemotherapy and each day I observed that my family member was suffering more than I was. Cancer is well funded, and I don't grudge that but ME needs serious money to find a cure and to correct the lack of understanding of the illness.
  19. Eilidh Hewitt 3 May 2018
    I was struck down with severe ME 30 years ago it came like a bolt from the blue. Then I was profoundly shocked to find that I was to be denied any kind of care or treatment. Ostracised by family and friends due to lack of validation of this disease life was grim and became a daily effort to survive in the teeth of all the misery and pain of it.

    Please fund proper research and care for ME patients. It is not cost effective to promote harmful therapies like GET and GET related CBT. Patients could possibly be saved from long term damage if the right advice was given at the start.
  20. Jeff Sumida 3 May 2018
    In the first few years, doctors didn't believe me. They said that if you aren't going to exercise, then I can't help you. Or Think positive, it helped my other patients. Finally, my second infectious disease doctor. said I have Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and there is no pill, no cure. But he got me into the Stanford Medical program. Only a short drive away.
  21. Suzanne Chadwick 3 May 2018
    It is really INSANE that anyone would think that this disease could be fixed by behavioral therapy. INSANE! How about checking out scientific evidencw, such as www.survivingmold.com and doing the proper labwork and treatment? Shame on you for killing people!
  22. Catherine Velez 3 May 2018
    I'm 53 years. I have ME for 30 years. My hope is to have a treatment or a cure.
  23. Catherine Velez 3 May 2018
    I'm 53 years. I have ME for 30 years. My hope is that I can have a treatment to give relief or a cure, and the same for all the millions of patients in the world.
  24. Ms. K. Stewart 3 May 2018
    I love Scotland and while attending school there I was in the beginning stages of fibromyalgia, later being determined by court proceedings and the input of several specialists to have CFIDS (the term used for M.E. at that time). It has now been
    54 years that have finally seen me almost entirely bedridden, bankrupted once due to the cost of treatment and medications and now I would give most anything for others not to spend their lives waiting for help and recognition the way I did. I also lost a husband, who could not handle just watching the levels of my pain. Don't do this to your citizens, your neighbors, your family members. I've lived in Edinburgh and know you can do a better job there -if you choose to- than is possible in the U.S.A. Please take the opportunity to aid in global awareness while helping your own people. Many thanks in advance & best wishes for what you can achieve there, Sincerely, Kate Stewart 54 years a patient of these so-called invisible diseases.
  25. Debby Smith 3 May 2018
    As a former Scot living in Canada afflicted with this condition, I support the three petitions to Parliament.
  26. Elizabeth Laird 3 May 2018
    There are many people living with this condition, but would greatly benefit from treatment. I have several friends whose lives would be transformed by getting the right treatment for this condition. It is long overdue as the diagnosis is widespread!
  27. Julie Crampin 3 May 2018
    I have had ME for 25 years. I support my fellow sufferers wherever they are.
  28. Ms karen price 3 May 2018
    This is such a debilitating disease, I was diagnosed with M E in 2001 but now I am awaiting an mri scan as lumber puncture was inconclusive to be now checked for M S , just shows the similarities, both indescribable.
  29. Tricia M 3 May 2018
    ME is a serious and debilitating illness that deserves serious research funding. Patients have been in desperate need of treatment and support for decades.
  30. Jo Bruce 3 May 2018
    I have always been a supporter of the NHS but the biggest barrier I have faced, apart from ignorant employers who break the disability discrimination act left, right and centre, is my GP. Not just one but 3 over ten years. I always worked and paid my taxes and I had no idea that stories like the ones we tell could happen. Do happen. In this day and age it's scary how quickly you become a non person. As a professional these people were my peers, now they speak to me as though my IQ has dropped, 60 points and I'm little more than a deluded scrounger. At a time when I have needed my GP to be 'on my side', I have found myself working alone to manage my condition.
  31. Ann Higgins 3 May 2018
    Care for the unfortunate people with ME
  32. Angela Barnard 3 May 2018
    Signing on behalf of my friend who is suffering from ME-CFS. I have watched her decline and am humbled by her resolve to continue on fighting. More needs to be done for this people suffering from this disease.
  33. Jennifer Murray 3 May 2018
    I'm not a citizen of Scotland, but as someone who was a productive citizen of the U.S. until I became ill 22 years ago, I urge you to recognize that finally funding proper investigation of this disease is necessary not only for the good of the suffering patients, but also for health of your country.
  34. Anna Maria Woynillowicz Kemp 4 May 2018
    I lived in Scotland for one and half years. The medical professionals need to be much more aware of current research about Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and be aware of medical protocols for treatment. As well, they need to have the knowledge to support persons with ME as they work towards receiving appropriate disability pension and long term disability through private insurance companies.
    Scottish Government funding needs to be aware of the severity of ME and compensation must be commensurate with the disease burden.
  35. S Lauryn Douglass Hayden 4 May 2018
    This is a terrible disease with a viral basis. Numerous US studies have shown the biological basis for compromised metabolism and multi-system dysfunction. I know this disease well as I have it. I have lost not only my health, but a successful career, financial security, social, community and most of my persnal life because of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis. I used to climb mountains, run, bike, dance and revel in a good life. ME has the position MS once had. Again, the latter is a disease I know we'll as a member of my family died from MS complications. At onset in the 1960s, MS was wrongfully associated with neurosis and other useless and harmful opinions were held about the illness, possibly in part because many affixed were women. I urge you to move forward with research, treatment and all other necessary efforts to reduce the suffering of Scottish residents with ME. I am fortunate to be a patient at a clinic in my own city, and although there is currently no cure for ME, I am benefitting greatly from what help clinic experts can offer me.
  36. DS George-Jones 4 May 2018
    Please find a treatment for ME. It is a human rights issue. We are tired of suffering in silence.
  37. Elizabeth Edwards 4 May 2018
    Please help.
  38. Tamara Anderson 4 May 2018
    It is necessary and remains without cure and mainly impacts women and we will become lost without the research. The longer people suffer w ME the more likely to develop other illness amd depression. Lives are being lost!
  39. Myrtle Little 4 May 2018
    I have had ME for 20 years, it makes me cross and sad about people and especially children not being believed and punished for having it. This has to change
  40. Kathleen Anderson 4 May 2018
    Please put more research into ME!
  41. Martin Dillon 4 May 2018
    The present treatment options for people will M.E.are almost non existent and often harmful. The approach from G.P. vary wildly. Say to little to them they don't do adequate investigation and often suggest anti
    - depressants. Show to much insight and ask for the adequate tests and they question your mental health. Often it's that bad.
  42. Ruaridh Pringle 4 May 2018
    I've had ME for 30 years, since I was 18. During a relapse over the past 2 years (following 14 relatively good years when I'd recovered to around 70% functionality) I was horrified to find that treatment for, and of, ME patients had got not better, as I'd assumed, but far worse, with the attitude amongst available medical professionals almost universally that 'it's all in the mind'. ME utterly destroys lives in the cruellest way, reducing highly motivated, active people to cognitively and physically crippled ghosts (many of them in constant pain). Yet it is *still* misunderstood or not taken seriously by the only people sufferers have to turn to. As a result, sufferers battle to access any of the kind of support and safety nets that other sufferers of crippling diseases have access to, despite the degree of suffering and disablement having been shown to be generally worse (e.g. compared to MS). ME sufferers are currently invisible, being left to die without help, unless they are lucky enough to have very supportive and understanding family and friends (because sufferers usually exhaust their reserves just trying to get through the day, there's usually nothing left for things like socialising, meaning the first thing ME robs you of is friends). This is a bafflingly unfair and counter-productive: the lack of support, research and understanding is preventing sufferers recovering or stabilising, and (DWP take note) decreasing their productivity. This *has* to change.
  43. Kay Mears 4 May 2018
    From a UK patient.
  44. Sidney Lockwood 4 May 2018
    It is high time ME suffers where recognised as a disability and the Government should accept the need for recognition and financial support. They have acted like "Robin Hood" but in reverse, by reducing payments allowance's to those persons with ME who are unable to work and in need of support whilst increasing their own income. (A case of "Robbing the Poor to pay the Rich")
    I will not vote for the Conservatives again!.
  45. Robert Mac 4 May 2018
    Have lived with M.E. for 30 years
    Despite the scientific medical breakthroughs over the years ........Many patients are treated as if they have imagined their selves ill ? Hard to believe even in regressive Britain ....what terrible harm this causes people .......
  46. Sue Waddle 4 May 2018
    Twice as many people have ME as have MS. Why is there no government funding of biomedical research into this condition or specialist services for patients?
  47. cait ni Cadlaig 4 May 2018
    If such a center is set up It should include those of us with Fibromyalgia or in many cases ,as is mine .I have both There are many similarities
  48. Lesley Doherty 4 May 2018
    This is woefully underfunded and under supported.
  49. Maggie Taylor 4 May 2018
    Treatment for ME is very patchy with little understanding of the condition. This has to change.
  50. Sofia Gurovich 4 May 2018
    I'v been sick with ME for 29 years , the disease is progressive , bed confinde , no treatment . wish there was more humane approach to patients like I. we all need urgent help .