Petition · PE01670 · Session 5
Reform the Scottish electoral system to make it democratic and accountable
Signatures
0
Comments
83
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the current Scottish electoral system so that, when the relevant powers under the Scotland Act 2016 are devolved, candidates standing for a constituency seat are not also able to stand on the regional list.
What the petitioner did first
I have contacted the seven regional list MSPs for my area.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
26 Oct 20171 mention
-
15 Mar 20181 mention
Signatures by country
494 online signaturesComments
83 comments, oldest first83 comments · showing 51–83
-
david murdoch 25 Jul 2017need to make our democracy representative of the people not a party.
-
Alex Barclay 25 Jul 2017I am disgusted to see these rejected candidates sitting in our Parliament against the wishes of the electorate.
-
Lindsay Neil 27 Jul 2017There should be a time limit on shoe ins using election lists due to resignations, deaths etc. In any case it should not be a party prerogative but on votes cast only.
-
Paul Molloy 27 Jul 2017In Scotland it is a scandal that candidates, parties and referendum results that have been rejected should be able to represent the voting majorities view, changing at the ground level may help in correcting the system all the way to the top.
-
Tom Halliday 28 Jul 2017It is galling that politicians who stand for a constituency and are defeated, are then elected through the list system, this allows parties to have the same candidate standing in two elections for the same position, this situation could be quite easily resolved by having a constituency list and a regional list, no candidate can appear on both.
-
James Grau 28 Jul 2017You should only be able to stand for a constituency seat. Not both Regional List. Get rid of these dead beats.
-
Ian Logie 29 Jul 2017Do it by the rules unlike our neighbors
-
Jason MacGilp 29 Jul 2017There is a pressing need for a full parliamentary review of the system of electing MSPs to our Parliament.
Allowing failed constituency candidates to be elected via regional lists is anti-democratic and reduces trust in the electoral process, and gives political parties more power than citizens.
I wish to see a new system based on Single Transferable Votes, with constuency MSPs only, no regional lists. This would improve accountability, create smaller constituencies more relevant to local communities and would make all MSPs work harder to understand and reflect the needs and priorities of their constituencies. -
Jackie Osborn 29 Jul 2017Disgraceful that our taxes are being used to pay the wages of people in the Scottish Parliament who haven't been voted in directly by the electorate. Whole system needs reform
-
William Winslow 30 Jul 2017Candidates you can vote for should not be on the list. That way if you fail to make the grade by not being voted in then that should be the end of the line until next election.
There should be a limit to the terms that a list candidate may be selected from the list. -
Scott Brady 30 Jul 2017In order to stop 'job for life syndrome' and to ensure fresh blood flows into the chamber I suggest that a person may only serve one term as a list MSP.
-
joseph shepherd 30 Jul 2017this is how Tory and labour kept a hold of many areas in my opinion.Parties should not be allowed to manipulate results.If the people reject a candidate that should be that
-
john ferguson 30 Jul 2017I agree fully with the petition and hope it succeeds.
-
Donald Paton 30 Jul 2017I wrote to Donald Dewar about this at the time. It is ludicrous that the "list" consists of people nobody voted for. Despite the notion of beaten candidates having been rejected by the electors, many have stood and amassed considerable support. Far better that the list consist of people in order of votes received than party placemen who could be anyone. Indeed many party nominees would never get elected otherwise.
-
William Habib Steele 30 Jul 2017While I'm not living in Scotland at the moment, I am still committed to the welfare of my country. I have been concerned about the injustice of constituency candidates also appearing as list candidates. The injustice of this seems very clear. I wish that candidates be required to chose to be either constituency candidates or list candidates.
-
Grant Brown 31 Jul 2017I completely agree with the petitioners premise that constituency candidates who lose out in elections must not be allowed in through the back door by way of the lists. I also agree that list candidates must not be predetermined in a ranking system. But I would go further and suggest that list candidates can only hold positions for a maximum of three parliaments before being automatically deselected and forced to become a constituency candidate to retain their position as an MSP.
-
Willie Miller 31 Jul 2017The system at present is not satisfactory as it allows candidates who were effectively rejected by the electorate to gain a position via the back door of the "list". That's no better than ennobling a failed candidate to the HOL to beat the national voting system.
-
Owen Gallagher 31 Jul 2017The present system allows candidates who have been rejected by the electorate to remain in post. I am unsure which system should replace the present be but it is clear the present set up in unsatisfactory.
-
Peter Kelly 2 Aug 2017I would add that all party leaders must stand in a constituency seat and not sneak in the back door
-
Paul Grierson 2 Aug 2017Perhaps the number of times one can stand on the list should also be examined....
-
George S Gordon 2 Aug 2017Being able to use the list as an insurance policy does not seem ideal. However, the main issue for me is that list candidates cannot really be rejected by voters if the party keeps putting them forward. As it stands, voters don't really know who they will get from a party's list at the time of voting. I agree with the petitioner. Or perhaps there should be a limit on how many times a candidate should be allowed on a list.
I'd also like to see electronic voting used, which would help stop confusion about how the AMS works by guiding the voters. I'd also use an electronic system to force voters to rank all the candidates in the local elections. -
Kevin Peden 2 Aug 2017I also believe some limit should be imposed on how many terms a list MSP can sit.
-
Thomas Valentine 3 Aug 2017I believe that no person not directly elected should sit in parliament or present themselves as an elected politician. For each party a leader, deputy and maximum two party spokesmen should be elected under a party ticket. If they gain a percentage share of the vote but no constituencies the parliamentary votes should be cast by the party leader or deputy. No additional members should appointed because they have not gained the direct approval of the citizens to sit in parliament.
I do not think individuals who have been repeatedly rejected by voters should bypass democracy through personal connections. It is a corruption of democracy. -
Anne Munn 3 Aug 2017I agree that if a candidate is rejected on a constituency vote, it overturns the democratic will of the voters if they then can still gain a seat through the AMS. There was considerable outcry from Scottish parliamentarians when a defeated candidate at the recent general election was then given a seat in the House of Lords -- same thing? Numbers of MSPS should also fairly reflect percentage share of the vote
-
Neil Ferguson 8 Aug 2017In addition, list MSPs should not be allowed more than two list terms in total during their careers. Two terms should be enough to prove their utility to the electorate. After that, they should be required to stand as constituency MSPs.
This would also provide a steady flow of new MSPs and help prevent the Scottish Parliament from becoming a Westminster-style cosy club for time-serving Establishment members. -
Barry Gale 11 Aug 2017I agree that candidates who have not been elected should not be admitted to Parliament. I do not see why Regional MSPs cannot also be elected through explicit choice on the ballot paper.
-
JULIE CHRISTIE-GAMBLE 14 Aug 2017I agree with the Petitioner 100%.
The system is allowing candidates to be elected to the Scottish Parliament by a collection of 2nd, 3rd, etc preference votes rather than votes for the candidate of their choice.
It is also allows Parties to manipulate 'The List' by ordering candidates, they know may not be elected as Constituency MSPs, to gain a seat. -
J T alexander 18 Aug 2017Constituency or list one or another not allowed to stand on both.
-
Ann Forbes 18 Aug 2017Agree with first comment .
-
Tom Forbes 18 Aug 2017There should be no list candidates
-
Terry Barlow 28 Aug 2017Candidates should be limited with one choice Constituency or List
-
Myra Brodie 28 Aug 2017We need a country run by the people we vote for, not the also rans
-
Charles McKinley 28 Aug 2017This a backdoor for failed politicians within a party clique to keep a job