Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01567 · Session 4

Investigating unascertained deaths, suicides and fatal accidents

Closed Submitted 15 Apr 2015 Justice
Signatures
0
1,716 online signatures with a country
Comments
124
Considered
10 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to change the law and procedures in regards to investigating unascertained deaths, suicides and fatal accidents in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

I have raised my concerns about this issue with my local MSP, who wrote to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice on my behalf.
I have also contacted Police Scotland and made a freedom of information request to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).
My own son’s death was categorised as ‘unascertained’ and, as such, I have personal experience of how difficult it is in the current system to convince the authorities to review, or reopen, a case where the initial investigations have been unable to categorically determine the cause of death.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 12 May 2015
    1 mention
  2. 19 May 2015
    1 mention
  3. 22 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 29 Sep 2015
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 5 Jan 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 23 Feb 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    2 mentions
  7. 27 Sep 2016
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  8. 24 Jan 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  9. 2 May 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention
  10. 5 Sep 2017
    Justice Committee
    Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,716 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,402 81.7%
  2. United Kingdom159 9.3%
  3. England87 5.1%
  4. Northern Ireland16 0.9%
  5. United States15 0.9%
  6. Wales6 0.3%
  7. Canada4 0.2%
  8. Malta4 0.2%
  9. Ireland4 0.2%
  10. Sweden3 0.2%
  11. 13 other countries16 0.9%

Comments

124 comments, oldest first
124 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Cally forbes 17 Apr 2015
    I feel the people in charge of making decisions about these laws have never felt the unbearable pain of not knowing what happened to your child parents etc. This is a disgrace to leave people wondering and pondering on what's ifs their whole life. I am a full real director and see the first hand damage these situations cause on families who can't just bandage it up. I often wonder if this is a mo ey saving option which makes it even more horrendous.
  2. Denise Webster 17 Apr 2015
    This is so wrong
    - not to investigate these deaths fully is like saying to the families their loved ones didn't matter!!! Please change this, give the families and loved ones some light at the end of their dark grief tunnel.
  3. Lesley Silver 17 Apr 2015
    All loved ones matter.
  4. Anne Brown 17 Apr 2015
    haven't the family been through enough without having to fight the government for answers disgusting
  5. Sue McAllister 17 Apr 2015
    It's quite simple really.....if it was one of your loved ones, there would be no question!
  6. Sue McAllister 17 Apr 2015
    Quite simple! If it was you or yours- you would stop at nothing!
  7. Donna O'Halloran 17 Apr 2015
    This petition won't protect or even help our love ones who have passed in suspicious events but I sincerely hope it helps the families unfortunate to travel a tragic road like ours n the future.
  8. J. Bannister 17 Apr 2015
    This is something I have worried about for years
    - especially the spiking of alcohol drinks in bars and clubs.. There have been many deaths across the UK of young people which I am sure have not been thoroughly investigated. Bars and club businesses are exploiting a young generation. There businesses are often run by people operating close to the borders of legality. Some may also be run by criminal gangs. These young people have no health and safety protection as would be provided in other places. We must as a society protect young people as they are extremely vulnerable. When deaths do occur they should be fully investigated.
  9. Fiona Young 18 Apr 2015
    Seems only right
  10. Iris Gillies 18 Apr 2015
    Yes all unascertained, suicides and accidental deaths should be treated suspicious until proven otherwise . If they can do it in England to keep in standard with European laws why can't they do the same here . People need to know what has happened to their loved ones and know what really happened to them for peace of mind.
  11. Denise kennedy 19 Apr 2015
    investigate!
  12. Karen mcgrath 19 Apr 2015
    Definitely .
  13. darren maloy 19 Apr 2015
    every one of these deaths deserves an inquiry and so do their families!
  14. Andrena johnstone 19 Apr 2015
    government should be ashamed of them selfs , all deaths should be investigated , let the families mind be at rest xx
  15. John Flynn 19 Apr 2015
    Surely in our Country we can treat all the dead with respect. Respect means going that extra mile to explain a death.
  16. Carol Malcolm 19 Apr 2015
    Law needs to change, admire your determination Donna x
  17. samantha leather 19 Apr 2015
    These families should be helped not hindered. They matter as do their lost loved ones, this change could at least help ease some part of their grief. Help make the change happen..!
  18. Kirsty Gillespie 19 Apr 2015
    Nothing stronger than a mother s love. This love is what has kept this mother going. So wrong that she has to fight for this, please change the law.
  19. Susan Norman 20 Apr 2015
    All cases need absolute answers to stop it happening again.
  20. Catherine Doyle 20 Apr 2015
    Of course, everyone needs to have some sort of closure. Not knowing and wondering, I could not even imagine the pain the family must feel.
  21. James Haldane 20 Apr 2015
    Think I've done it :)
  22. Doreen Forsyth 20 Apr 2015
    This and many more families are unimaginably in turmoil wanting answers that must be answered please have a heart and change the law in order to help bring closure to their many questions.
  23. Sherylann toye 20 Apr 2015
    Shared and signed x
  24. Pam Burton 20 Apr 2015
    Signed. x
  25. MARY MCCRORIE 21 Apr 2015
    Thank you Donna, you are a credit to your David after what as a Mother you have gone through , working so tirelessly to help get justice for others.
  26. Lisa McCart 21 Apr 2015
    Signed x
  27. jason kyle 21 Apr 2015
    signed
  28. Elaine Beveridge 21 Apr 2015
    signed this, great awareness being brought to not only students but any young people x
  29. Suzanne 21 Apr 2015
    Signed
  30. Sheila MacFadyen 21 Apr 2015
    Davids story and indeed, Donna and her family story broke my heart then and still does now. I hope and pray that what happened to David is investigated as it should be and that they all find peace.
  31. Jessie allan 21 Apr 2015
    All deaths need an explanation
  32. Barbara Ann Malcolm 21 Apr 2015
    Families have gone through enough heartache without having to fight to ascertain how thier loved one died Too many young people are dying this way something desperatly needs to change.
  33. Arlene Russell 21 Apr 2015
    Signed x
  34. pauline glen 21 Apr 2015
    Xx
  35. Janie Macdonald 21 Apr 2015
    Signed xx
  36. Ben Marshall 21 Apr 2015
    rip
  37. jade reid 21 Apr 2015
    amazing how donna is selflessly trying to prevent othwr people suffering the way her son did and how it affected his friends and family. x
  38. Michelle mcatamney 21 Apr 2015
    Signed x
  39. Jen Borek 22 Apr 2015
    Petition signed. Good luck Donna
  40. Darren Boland 22 Apr 2015
    Signed x
  41. Roberta McDougall 22 Apr 2015
    Time for change
  42. Margaret yersz 22 Apr 2015
    Change is needed
  43. dawn stubberfield 22 Apr 2015
    More needs to be done.
  44. Jude letham 22 Apr 2015
    Hope change will happen due to this petition
  45. Tracy Myatt 23 Apr 2015
    Time for a changed is needed
  46. Amy Sullivan 23 Apr 2015
    Change is needed , especially for closure for grieving families
  47. Angela Campbell 23 Apr 2015
    Every life is precious and should be treated as such.
  48. nancy campbell 24 Apr 2015
    change is needed
  49. Keira Mackie 24 Apr 2015
    Lots of love x
  50. Karen mcgrath 25 Apr 2015
    Ridiculous you dont case less but if it where you lot them the story would be different. Get moving and do something!