Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01556 · Session 4

A National Parks Strategy for Scotland

Closed Submitted 4 Feb 2015 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
1,122 online signatures with a country
Comments
89
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to prepare and implement a strategy to designate more National Parks in Scotland, including at least one Coastal and Marine National Park.

What the petitioner did first

We have:
• Met every Environment Minister since 2004 to propose the designation of more National Parks
• Run a three-year joint project from 2010 to 2013 to carry out research, raise awareness and argue the case for more National Parks
• Published a major report, Unfinished Business (2013), setting out the case for a National Parks Strategy for Scotland, proposing the creation of several more National Parks and identifying seven suitable areas
• Engaged with several other national organisations (eg RSGS and RTPI) and local communities (eg Cheviots, Galloway and Mull) to argue our case
• Met several MSPs for areas we propose as National Parks
• Published articles in several monthly or quarterly magazines and newsletters of other NGOs

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 28 Apr 2015
    1 mention
  2. 23 Jun 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 27 Oct 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,122 online signatures
  1. Scotland703 62.7%
  2. United Kingdom236 21%
  3. England139 12.4%
  4. Wales13 1.2%
  5. Canada9 0.8%
  6. Germany5 0.4%
  7. Netherlands4 0.4%
  8. Australia3 0.3%
  9. Not given2 0.2%
  10. United States2 0.2%
  11. 5 other countries6 0.5%

Comments

89 comments, oldest first
89 comments · showing 51–89
  1. Bea Holden 19 Feb 2015
    Completely in favour of the Galloway National Park which would cover the Merrick area, Loch Trool and Loch Doon. I live very close to this area and am involved in tourism. It would be very beneficial, especially as it would include the Galloway Dark Sky Park and Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere, plus the Galloway Forest Park. Along with the Wild Land designation this area has there is no other location like this in the world
    - it is unique. I also have experience of the Cairngorm National Park and have witnessed all the improvements and developments they have instigated and permitted. A National Park does not mean 'no' to new developments at all, rather they seem to encourage and assist in sustainable and appropriate developments.
    Please support the new Scottish National Parks.
  2. Ian Donnachie 21 Feb 2015
    Would be of enormous benefit to the whole region adn add diversity to the National Park estate generally.
  3. David Hawker 22 Feb 2015
    Galloway and South Ayrshire has a Biosphere Reserve centred around The Merrick and Corserine Hills which would be ideal for the creation of the third Scottish National park. This already is an area for tourism and the local communities are very supportive of the present designation. It has the potential to create more jobs in the area and assist in the conservation of the most southerly wild land in Scotland.
  4. Jon Proctor 22 Feb 2015
    Particularly concerned about dredging in coastal waters and its effects on Marine life. Also why we have to have pylons and not a sub see cable for electricity distribution across west coast.
  5. Alastair Richardson 23 Feb 2015
    The creation of Parks increases public interest and will encourage better management of our unique and beautiful country
  6. Michael Dolan 25 Feb 2015
    I think the National Park designation, makes people cherish and use their countryside and landscape even more.
  7. Alistair Beeley 25 Feb 2015
    I suppose the best way to preserve our wonderful landscape heritage is by creating National Parks, though they do need pretty robust terms of reference to achieve this. Certainly Inverpolly & the Cuillins Skye are areas that come to mind immediately but one could consider the entire western and northern areas of Scotland, including coastal and marine environments should be included
  8. Carol Carey 25 Feb 2015
    It's shocking that a country as beautiful as Scotland has only two national parks.
  9. Mark Aitken 25 Feb 2015
    We need to fully protect and support Scotland's stunning landscapes and seascapes. Further National Park designations will help this.
  10. Finlay Carson 25 Feb 2015
    I would promote as the ideal location of a marine and land based national park
  11. Per Bullough 25 Feb 2015
    Scotland is claimed by many to have the finest landscapes in the world. We should be ashamed that these landscapes have so little protection.
  12. Neil MacNaughton 26 Feb 2015
    Scotland's amazing wild landscapes have suffered more than enough from from totally inappropriate developments, with no end to the push for so-called green energy. There is a monetary value to wild land as recent research has again confirmed. We must protect our scenic and wild lands for future generations and more National Parks would ensure protection of this valuable resource.
  13. philip maher 26 Feb 2015
    Hope this goes through.
  14. Bob McChristie 26 Feb 2015
    agree totally
  15. Kenneth W Johnson 26 Feb 2015
    Two national parks, both inland does not reflect the diversity of Scotland's landscape. Other types of designation (SSSI, Regional Park etc.) do not give protection form encroachment and reduction of unspoiled land.
  16. Mr Maurice McPhillimey 27 Feb 2015
    Hope they accept this petition. . We need to protect the land for our children and childrens children.
  17. Marion Thomson 1 Mar 2015
    National Park status gives international recognition to our beautiful and diverse landscapes and it also offers opportunities to address the long standing need for better integration of rural policies and to demonstrate these in practice. The two designated National Parks are a 'good start' but need to be supplemented by representatives of other valued Scottish landscapes and habitats.Please bring on the work required to achieve this. I would also add a more local comment that I believe that the so called 'forgotten areas' of sw Scotland really benefit from such a designation.
  18. Anne Levi 1 Mar 2015
    We need to cherish and protect our beautiful landscapes with more than just words.
  19. Erica Sarney 1 Mar 2015
    The Scottish Government have allowed the ruination of huge tracks of land through wind farm development
    - save what is left for future generations.
  20. David Woodhouse 1 Mar 2015
    It is quite shocking for any sane person to absorb, that Scotland has the worst record in the whole of Europe on creation of National Parks,
  21. Ian Pascoe 1 Mar 2015
    It is ridiculous that Scotland only has two parks, one of which has part of what should be its core area outside its boundary. The Torridon area would be my first choice for a third park but there are several other areas with strong claims eg Glencoe.
  22. Judith Parker 1 Mar 2015
    We need to do this quickly before we spoil our beautiful landscape and lose archaeology forever.
  23. Mr and Mrs Andrew Todd 1 Mar 2015
    We need to act quickly before the whole of Scotland is just one big wind farm.
  24. Joy Woodhouse 1 Mar 2015
    How can it be that when our spectacular natural environment is so vital to the rural economy here ,that we still have only two National Parks ??
  25. R G OLIVER 2 Mar 2015
    Very necessary
  26. Carol Meiklejohn 2 Mar 2015
    No More wind farms in Dumfries and Galloway. Enough already.
  27. Elizabeth Morton 2 Mar 2015
    National Parks are really important for preserving biodiversity and bringing joy into people's lives.
  28. John Burns 3 Mar 2015
    For a country with such beautiful countryside and coast line ,Scotland needs to formalise its protection. National Parks are the international gold standard for recognising these precious areas.
    Why not take a different approach with any new parks and link the products made, farmed or reared with that National Park, selling it as a gold standard of product.
  29. Denise Cook 4 Mar 2015
    Dumfries and Galloway has been the place I wanted to live and promote as a beautiful, unspoilt destination, with abundant wildlife and walking opportunities. The placing of wind farms has had a negative impact on the landscape, but what remains is well worth including in a National Park.
  30. Kevin Howett 11 Mar 2015
    We have two National Parks focused on recreation & local business. There is a real need for a western seaboard Park right down the western side of scotland including the islands that focuses wilderness & conservation & to prevent continued damaging exploitation such as wind farms & poor land management based on outdated Victorian shooting estates. A wild land returned to its wild nature with free access for all for non damaging recreation & giving local business from sustainable environmentally friendly means. A land where the ecosystem is repaired enough to see once lost species such as Lynx & wolf help establish a thriving wilderness legacy we can leave for our children instead of damage & destruction.
  31. Joanne Hull 11 Mar 2015
    As a frequent visitor to Scotland (and now a resident) I visited, and still visit, our national parks for their outstanding beauty. Having travelled the world, Scotland can, just, hold its own with the likes of Canada, Austria and the Himalaya. But, excessive development (power lines, turbines etc) ruin that raw natural beauty and this means other the other places mentioned are much more of an attraction to me as a tourist. I'd much prefer to spend my money at home but try taking stunning photos with man-made structures in the way. We have something so beautiful that it needs protecting for future generations and to show the world just what a gorgeous country we have. There are alternatives
    - hydro is a proven success and power lines can be buried and development can be done sensitively.
  32. Margaret Luscombe 11 Mar 2015
    It is vital that areas in Scotland are protected for future generations.
  33. Gerald O' Connor 11 Mar 2015
    I have spent most weekends in our wild places for the last 5 years, and can see the harm beeing done
    We need to protect the environment and National Parks is a good way of doing this.
  34. Neil Collins 12 Mar 2015
    As a frequent visitor to Scotland, I would have no hesitation in saying that I believe it to be one of the most beautiful countries in the world. However, this astonishing beauty is currently threatened by many hundreds of planned inappropriate developments, particularly but by no means exclusively, wind farms, with damaging proposals currently in the pipeline across the whole country, from Galloway to Shetland. Yet, Scotland's natural beauty is surely its prize asset and one of its biggest tourist draws. It is imperative to act now to ensure that this beauty is not lost and can continue to be enjoyed by future generations.
  35. Gary Dickson 12 Mar 2015
    Worth it in itself, but especially if it helps the industrialisation of remote areas with ever growing wind factories and mile upon mile of poorly constructed tracks to service them.
  36. Abbie Patterson 12 Mar 2015
    I think that it is not a case of how many NP's we have or would like, but what areas of Scotland do we leave out?
  37. Robert Watt 12 Mar 2015
    Something coastal?
  38. Dr Ivan Bishop 13 Mar 2015
    I'm off the opinion we need marine sanctuaries too. The West Coast is a treasure trove of animal life, beautiful Islands and unspoiled waters. Future oil-gas development there will need to be CAREFULLY managed but the Scottish parliament.
  39. Gerrie Purcell 13 Mar 2015
    Marine conservation is prime concern. We must protect our coastal areas and special interest or habitat areas for our sea life.