Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01521 · Session 4

No More Page 3 in the Scottish Sun and Scottish Parliament

Closed Submitted 4 Apr 2014 Equalities
Signatures
0
2,679 online signatures with a country
Comments
100
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the editorial team of the Sun and Scottish Sun to voluntarily remove the page 3 feature permanently.
Furthermore, until the Sun/Scottish Sun ceases its page 3 feature we request the Scottish Parliament no longer stock/sell The Sun or Scottish Sun newspaper given its objectification of women and gender stereotyping both seem at odds with the Scottish Parliament’s equalities framework.

What the petitioner did first

The No More Page 3 campaign has attracted 187,000 signatures to an online petition at change.org over the last 12 months, over 50,000 in the last 2 weeks, seeking to request David Dinsmore, editor of the Sun Newspaper and by default Gordon Smart editor of the Scottish Sun, to take a mature editorial decision to remove the page 3 feature of a semi-naked women from his publication.
In a Scottish context a number of campaigners have contacted local councillors, MSPs, MPs and other civic institutions asking them to commit their support publicly through the signing of a standard letter, public expression of support or the signing of the online petition.
The issue of the No More Page 3 has been debated as part of a members motion led by Jackie Baillie MSP on 6 November 2013. The text of the S4M-07500 motion was:
That the Parliament notes with concern reports regarding a connection between the portrayal of sexualised images of women in the media and attitudes that reinforce sexist attitudes, sexual harassment, abuse and violence towards women; believes that this has been demonstrated by the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women and the UK Government-commissioned Sexualisation of young people review; welcomes the No More Page 3 campaign, which calls on The Sun to refrain from printing pictures of topless women; applauds the campaign for what it considers a successful first year in operation; recognises that a motion in support of the campaign was agreed by the National Assembly of Wales and that numerous organisations, including UNISON, the British Youth Council, UK Girlguiding, the National Union of Teachers, the National Association of Head Teachers, and the Association of Teachers and Lecturers have also shown their support for the campaign, and notes calls in Dumbarton and across the country for The Sun in Scotland to stop printing pictures of topless women.
Individual members of the No More Page 3 campaign have written and corresponded via social media with various members of the editorial team at the Scottish Sun on a number of related matters, including articulating concerns over the recent sexualisation of cancer awareness public health messages, but have yet to receive a response answering the wide range of concerns articulated and fundamental request for them to remove page 3.
We have corresponded with a number of organisations on this issue. For example:
Response to the recent Scottish Government consultation, which closed on 28 February 2014, on the forthcoming End Violence Against Women and Children Strategy: http://nmp3.tumblr.com/post/76320413772/prioritising-prevention-evaw
Letter to the Editor of the Scottish Sun on the specific recent editorial decision to sexualise cancer prevention on Tuesday’s via the page 3 feature: http://nmp3.tumblr.com/post/78678765846/sexualising-cancer-prevention-a-step-too-far
And also general correspondence with the First Minister to raise awareness of the campaign: http://nmp3.tumblr.com/post/74701321365/dear-first-minister-i-write-to-ask-you-to-support
We have as a campaign received replies from Police Scotland: http://nomorepage3.org/news/letter-from-a-deputy-chief-constable/
And Scottish Government: http://nomorepage3.org/news/letter-of-support-from-scottish-government/
We would also request that until The Sun removes page 3 from its publication, that the Scottish Parliament ceases to purchase or stock with its premises the publication. This request we believe is in line with your current equalities framework: http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/abouttheparliament/16483.aspx

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Jun 2014
    1 mention
  2. 11 Nov 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 27 Jan 2015
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,679 online signatures
  1. England1,211 45.2%
  2. United Kingdom678 25.3%
  3. Scotland627 23.4%
  4. Wales54 2%
  5. Northern Ireland22 0.8%
  6. Australia20 0.7%
  7. Ireland13 0.5%
  8. United States11 0.4%
  9. France5 0.2%
  10. Canada5 0.2%
  11. 19 other countries33 1.2%

Comments

100 comments, oldest first
100 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Ginnie Cumming 1 May 2014
    How would men like having male genitalia exposed (and described) daily on Page 3? Would it make them feel inadequate or anxious about their own appendages? Would they mind women laughing in the office? Of course they would. Its all about empathy.
  2. PAULINE WALSH 1 May 2014
    Not before time!
  3. jane sawyer 1 May 2014
    so glad to be one of th many wanting to ban this obscenity
  4. L Whitworth 1 May 2014
    It would be a great coup for Scotland if it led the way on this.
  5. Claire J 1 May 2014
    We were campaigning for this in the 1970s, when will they listen????
  6. Sid Ali Derradji 1 May 2014
    This need to stop, we value our women's our sisters our mothers better than that.
  7. Lucy Ross 1 May 2014
    We do not see male page 3
    - objectification for one sex only
    - enough said
  8. Marc Prowe 1 May 2014
    Full equality and dignity for everyone is one of the core values of the Christian faith
    - as Paul writes in Galatians 3:28 "Faith in Christ Jesus is what makes each of you equal with each other, whether you are a Jew or a Greek, a slave or a free person, a man or a woman". No-one must be turned into an object or commodity.
  9. Janie Nicoll 1 May 2014
    The Sun is out of date and out of touch
    - end Page 3, and its objectification of women. Zero tolerance of sexism, there is no excuse.
  10. Asim Hussain 1 May 2014
    Please please take this out of newspapers. This is a cheap trick to sell papers. If people really cared about society and "real" news they wouldn't apply such cheap tactics. People say Islam oppresses women when it is completely un true. So I push it back to you, why do you allow women to be subjected to that. Men look at it get the wrong idea, any wonder why UK has the highest pregnancy rating then the knock on to the taxes everyone pays for. Please it's not about one thing its the knock on effect it has on all forms of society. Please lets work together to make this a better place.
  11. matt derrington 1 May 2014
    i commend the Scottish Parliament for recently setting the standard on how to combat slavery.

    Sad and astonishing that in this day it should also have to consider making an official stand on another form of gross barbarity- the objectification of women's bodies.

    i believe there will be no better day until efforts like this are made and helped to succeed.
  12. Biddi Kings 1 May 2014
    Once more Scotland is showing the way! Demonstrating that we in England have more to lose that Scotland if we part company.
  13. Sarah Best 1 May 2014
    Please restore long overdue dignity to women so that we may be treated with respect and as equals instead of our having to feel shame and pity for our current society and humanity.
  14. Emily Bacharach 1 May 2014
    Please stop pretending boobs are news. Page 3 is an outdated, irrelevant and harmful feature
    - sexualised nude pictures do not belong in a family newspaper.
  15. amanda robb 1 May 2014
    Come on Scotland! Lead the way on this, like you did with the smoking ban! Page 3 is an anachronism now, and if it dies the death north of the border, maybe it will meet the same south of the border.
  16. Merril Archer 1 May 2014
    no more boobs in the sun please. Give women their dignity.
  17. Dawn Taylor 1 May 2014
    I have felt strongly about the issue of page three pages objectifying women for decades .I urge Scotland to lead the way again in standing up for Values .
  18. Kay Leitch 1 May 2014
    I'm proud to be Scottish. The Scots make great leaders. Lead the way in this: ban breasts on page 3 of The Sun. If they were denigrating black people, gay people or Jewish people, you'd be (quite rightly) quick enough to act. Why is it still considered OK to depict women in such a contemptuous way?
  19. T Murphy 1 May 2014
    Please set an example to your colleagues in the House of Commons and House of Lords! Thank you.
  20. Chris Berry 1 May 2014
    Page 3 belongs with the rest of the paper-in
    the recycling bin.
  21. Kim Haslam 1 May 2014
    Yes. Please do the right thing Scottish Parliament and do the right thing...Ban topless woman in The Sun & Scottish Sun newspaper.
  22. Cathey Cousins 1 May 2014
    The Page 3 feature only serves to encourage men and boys, women and girls that the role of females is primarily for sexual gratification.
  23. B Mace 1 May 2014
    Show respect for human beings, they're sentient beings not hollowed out carcases.
  24. Paul Jarvis 1 May 2014
    Lets move things forward a bit.Blokey blokes & Girlie girls should just grow up.
  25. Junette Phillips 1 May 2014
    This is degrading to women and totally disrespectful, and also bad for the future generation. Why has this taken so long to stop this in this day and age. Thought it was respect and equality for all and against the law on discrimination grounds. I and most people I know have not read the Sun newspaper for several years because of the sleaze it,s generally known for.
  26. Pearl Jackson 2 May 2014
    I really only found out how men react to Page 3 when working in a pub 3 years ago! The disgusting comments directed at me after leering at the page 3 girl were too much to bear so I left and will never work in this environment again. By the way I am a well preserved pensioner and have never known anything like this in my life having worked in may pubs in the past.
  27. malcolm boughey 2 May 2014
    It is high time this kind of sexism was stopped there is no need for it in this day & age
  28. Mark Parsons 2 May 2014
    The time is right, the time in NOW
  29. Adam Rahman 2 May 2014
    The beauty inside woman is what matters.
  30. sheila owen 2 May 2014
    needs to stop
  31. Katherine Adewumi 3 May 2014
    Please support the No More Page Three campaign as best as you can as it mirrors and perpetuates discrimination against women in our culture. There are many of us who are sick of it.

    Thank-you.
  32. Rosemary Godwin 3 May 2014
    Objectifying-of-women-style adverts or photos make my stomach heave: they should never be in newspapers, billboards or in public places.
  33. Caron Elliott 4 May 2014
    I can't believe this hasn't been done sooner! Time to listen to the people!
  34. Duncan Gibb 5 May 2014
    Pin-up pictures are for specialist magazines etc and should not be used routinely in the newspapers where they are liable to embarrass some members of the public who are forced to see them when a colleague opens a newspaper. They also coarsen the public dialogue.
  35. Jane Hebborn 5 May 2014
    I find it completely shocking that such a sexualised and reductive images of women are still permitted in a " family newspaper". Is this the 1970s??
  36. Tonicha Baldock 5 May 2014
    About time, in the fight against the sexualisation and degrading of women
  37. Mark Heavenor 6 May 2014
    STOP!!
  38. Anisa 7 May 2014
    Ban this embarassment of a newspaper completely!!
  39. Katy Relph 7 May 2014
    A new generation that respects women and teaches yound girls to respect themselves. ITS TIME!
  40. Maria 8 May 2014
    The sexual objectification of women needs to stop now!
  41. Susan 12 May 2014
    Please ban page 3 and help promote women as more than sexual objects
  42. cecilia reilly 13 May 2014
    The women who pose for the sun page 3 should also think about what they doing it is not all about money and fame
  43. Elizabeth Lewis 15 May 2014
    Its high time the Sun dropped this outdated page 3 and gave women some credibility as thinking people and not objects who are valued by their breasts.
  44. Judy Ferguson 16 May 2014
    Naked pictures displayed in a workplace would be illegal, therefore it defies logic that they are allowed in a 'family' newspaper often on display in numerous public places- cafes, waiting rooms etc as well as being read openly where the sexualised image of topless women can be seen by all and sundry. It is completely inappropriate and devalues and objectifies women. Children are influenced by this and as the Scottish Government fully acknowledges that VAW is caused by gender inequality this type of image perpetuates the problem and conflicts with policy approaches.
  45. Arlene Caldwell 18 May 2014
    It's about time this outdated feature was removed from the Sun- completely sexist and objectifies women. Should be banned!!
  46. Rhona McMenemin 18 May 2014
    Show the way Scotland
  47. Eleanor Seelig 18 May 2014
    How will women ever be treated with respect if items such as page 3 are normalised within the mainstream media.
  48. Lee Reed 18 May 2014
    Archaic!
  49. Katherine Hughes 18 May 2014
    Because if the country's most widely read newspaper objectifies women on a daily basis, it teaches its readership to do the same thing.
  50. Pauline Ellis 18 May 2014
    It's time we moved forward, many women feel like second class due to the way they are portrayed in these newspapers. We're not just sex objects