Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026 · Votes to 19 Nov 2026

Amendment · S6M-11733.1 · Session 6

Appointments of the Chair and Commissioners of the Scottish Land Commission

Defeated Lodged by Douglas Lumsden Con Lodged 20 Dec 2023 Debate 21 Dec 2023

Amendment to S6M-11733 Appointments of the Chair and Commissioners of the Scottish Land Commission

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S6M-11733 in the name of Mairi Gougeon (Appointments of the Chair and Commissioners of the Scottish Land Commission), leave out from "recommendation" to end and insert "unanimous recommendation that the Parliament approves the appointment of Professor Deborah Roberts and Craig Mackenzie as Land Commissioners to the Scottish Land Commission; recognises the widespread concerns expressed regarding the recommended appointment of Michael Russell; highlights that Michael Russell’s appointment was not approved unanimously by the Committee because it had not had the opportunity to take evidence from him regarding any potential conflicts of interest that would arise from him having recently been an MSP, president of the Scottish National Party, interim chief executive of the Scottish National Party, and a Scottish Minister; understands that Michael Russell has made a number of inflammatory comments in the past about opposition politicians and parties, as well as about land reform, and therefore questions his ability to be impartial, and approves the appointments of Professor Deborah Roberts and Craig Mackenzie as required by section 10 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016, but, in the interests of protecting the reputation of the Scottish Land Commission, does not approve the appointment of Michael Russell until such time as the Committee has undertaken further scrutiny."

Vote

1 division
  1. 21 Dec 2023
    Defeated
    52 for, 64 against, 1 abstained

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this amendment.

In the Official Report

5 contributions mention S6M-11733.1
  1. 21 Dec 2023
    Scottish Land Commission (Appointment of Chair and Commissioners)
    Alison Johnstone Meeting of the Parliament

    I call Douglas Lumsden to speak to and move amendment S6M-11733.1. 13:16

  2. 21 Dec 2023
    Scottish Land Commission (Appointment of Chair and Commissioners)
    Douglas Lumsden Con Meeting of the Parliament

    His blatant lack of respect for democratically elected individuals, use of derogatory language and nasty comments about others on social media should have been investigated by the recruitment panel. If that panel is open and transparent, w…

  3. 21 Dec 2023
    Decision Time
    Alison Johnstone Meeting of the Parliament

    There are two questions to be put as a result of today’s business. The first question is, that amendment S6M-11733.1, in the name of Douglas Lumsden, which seeks to amend motion S6M-11733, in the name of Mairi Gougeon, on the appointment o…

  4. 21 Dec 2023
    Decision Time
    Alison Johnstone Meeting of the Parliament

    We move to the division on amendment S6M-11733.1, in the name of Douglas Lumsden. Members should cast their votes now. The vote is closed.

  5. 21 Dec 2023
    Decision Time
    Alison Johnstone Meeting of the Parliament

    The result of the division on amendment S6M-11733.1, in the name of Douglas Lumsden, is: For 52, Against 64, Abstentions 1. Amendment disagreed to.