Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026 · Votes to 18 Nov 2026

Amendment · S6M-11546.1 · Session 6

Fiscal Framework Review

Defeated Lodged by Ash Regan Alba Lodged 5 Dec 2023 Debate 6 Dec 2023

Amendment to S6M-11546 Fiscal Framework Review

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S6M-11546 in the name of Shona Robison (Fiscal Framework Review), leave out from "believes" to end and insert "notes that although VAT assignment was recommended by the Smith Commission, several years later, half of VAT raised in Scotland that was to be assigned to the Scottish Budget is still not included in the updated fiscal framework, and believes that only with the full powers of independence will the Scottish Parliament have all the fiscal levers required to reduce poverty, grow the economy, tackle climate change by investing in the future of carbon capture technology in the North Sea, and invest in public services."

Vote

1 division
  1. 6 Dec 2023
    Defeated
    1 for, 119 against

Other amendments

3
  1. Defeated
    56 for, 64 against
  2. Fiscal Framework Review
    Michael Marra Lab Lodged 5 Dec 2023
    Defeated
    25 for, 95 against
  3. Fiscal Framework Review
    Liz Smith Con Lodged 5 Dec 2023
    Defeated
    31 for, 89 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this amendment.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S6M-11546.1
  1. 6 Dec 2023
    Fiscal Framework Review
    Annabelle Ewing SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    I call Ash Regan to speak to and to move amendment S6M-11546.1, for up to six minutes. 15:27

  2. 6 Dec 2023
    Fiscal Framework Review
    Ash Regan Alba Meeting of the Parliament

    I am concluding now, I am afraid. It is clear that devolution can deliver to us only so much and that the powers of independence will enable Scotland to create a thriving economy, a wealthier nation and higher living standards for all of u…

  3. 6 Dec 2023
    Decision Time
    Liam McArthur LD Meeting of the Parliament

    The fourth question is, that amendment S6M-11546.1, in the name of Ash Regan, which seeks to amend motion S6M-11546, in the name of Shona Robison, on the fiscal framework review, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.

  4. 6 Dec 2023
    Decision Time
    Liam McArthur LD Meeting of the Parliament

    The result of the division on amendment S6M-11546.1, in the name of Ash Regan, is: For 1, Against 119, Abstentions 0. Amendment disagreed to.