Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S5M-17091 · Session 5

Subject Choice

Carried Lodged by Liz Smith Con Lodged 29 Apr 2019 Debate 1 May 2019

The motion

That the Parliament believes that Scottish education should be based on the principles of excellence and equity and that all young people, whatever their background, should be afforded the best possible educational experience at all levels of the curriculum; further believes that, while these principles are enshrined in the policy aims of the curriculum for excellence, the delivery of the new curriculum structure has exposed some fundamental failings with regard to subject choice, including the inequity that exists between schools in more affluent areas and those in more deprived communities, and calls on the Scottish Government to recognise the serious concerns, which have been expressed by teachers, parents, young people and academics, and take urgent action to address these failings in the delivery of the curriculum for excellence.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

The Conservatives’ motion was changed by a Labour amendment (S5M-17091.2) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the Conservatives’ motion with Labour’s changes.

That the Parliament believes that Scottish education should be based on the principles of excellence and equity and that all young people, whatever their background, should be afforded the best possible educational experience at all levels of the curriculum; further believes that, while these principles are enshrined in the policy aims of the curriculum for excellence, the delivery of the new curriculum structure has exposed some fundamental failings with regard to subject choice, including the inequity that exists between schools in more affluent areas and those in more deprived communities, and calls on the Scottish Government to recognise the serious concerns, which have been expressed by teachers, parents, young people and academics, and take urgent action to address these failings in the delivery of the curriculum for excellence.S5M-17091.2 Labour ; believes that such action should include an evaluation of how the curriculum for excellence is actually being implemented in schools, as recommended by the OECD in its 2015 report, Improving Schools in Scotland, and considers that, although the senior phase was outwith the remit of this report, how the senior phase operates within the curriculum for excellence should be a priority for review.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S5M-17091.4 SNP John Swinney Defeated vote, 62–63
  2. S5M-17091.1 Liberal Democrat Tavish Scott Not put to a vote (worked out by this site: never called at Decision Time: not selected or not moved)
  3. S5M-17091.2 Labour Iain Gray Agreed without a vote, per the Official Report

Vote

1 division
  1. 1 May 2019
    Subject Choice
    S5M-17091as amended by Labour
    Carried
    64 for, 0 against, 61 abstained

Amendments

3
  1. Subject Choice
    Tavish Scott LD Lodged 30 Apr 2019
    No recorded vote
  2. Subject Choice
    Iain Gray Lab Lodged 30 Apr 2019
    No recorded vote
  3. Subject Choice
    John Swinney SNP Lodged 30 Apr 2019
    Defeated
    62 for, 63 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this motion.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S5M-17091
  1. 1 May 2019
    Subject Choice
    Linda Fabiani SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-17091, in the name of Liz Smith, on subject choice. 14:43

  2. 1 May 2019
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    We come to decision time. I point out that, if the amendment in the name of John Swinney is agreed to, the amendment in the name of Iain Gray will fall. The first question is, that amendment S5M-17091.4, in the name of John Swinney, which …

  3. 1 May 2019
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that amendment S5M-17091.2, in the name of Iain Gray, which seeks to amend motion S5M-17091, in the name of Liz Smith, on subject choice, be agreed to. Amendment agreed to.

  4. 1 May 2019
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S5M-17091, in the name of Liz Smith, on subject choice, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.