Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Amendment · S5M-05185.3 · Session 5

Defence Basing Reforms and the Impact on Scotland

Defeated Lodged by Jackson Carlaw Con Lodged 19 Apr 2017 Debate 20 Apr 2017 1 supporter

Amendment to S5M-05185 Defence Basing Reforms and the Impact on Scotland

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S5M-05185 in the name of Keith Brown (Defence Basing Reforms and the Impact on Scotland), leave out from "expresses" to end and insert "understands that the Ministry of Defence’s Estate Optimisation Strategy has the sensible aims of updating the defence estate to be more capability focused and better suited to the needs of modern armed forces; believes that the UK Government should continue to engage fully with the Scottish Government, local authorities and local communities on the review; notes that the defence estate in Scotland will still remain considerable; acknowledges that the UK Government has made wider investment in defence in Scotland supporting thousands of jobs, and believes that an independent Scotland would have a very limited military, which would weaken the defence of the nation and damage its proud military traditions."

Vote

1 division
  1. 20 Apr 2017
    Defeated
    31 for, 80 against

Other amendments

2
  1. Carried
    74 for, 36 against
  2. No recorded vote

Supporters

1 MSP

Con 1

Show all 1 supporter by party

Con 1

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

2 contributions mention S5M-05185.3
  1. 20 Apr 2017
    Defence Basing Reforms
    Jackson Carlaw Con Meeting of the Parliament

    I do not accept that. The point that I make is that Scotland is an integral part of the UK defence forces, but it is imperative that we meet the requirements of the armed forces. There is no point in having some imaginary sense of what was…

  2. 20 Apr 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    There are six questions to be put as a result of today’s business. The first question is, that amendment S5M-05185.3, in the name of Jackson Carlaw, which seeks to amend motion S5M-05185, in the name of Keith Brown, on defence basing refor…