Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S5M-05172 · Session 5

Scotland's Economy

Carried Lodged by Murdo Fraser Con Lodged 18 Apr 2017 Debate 19 Apr 2017 2 supporters

The motion

That the Parliament notes with concern that the Scottish economy contracted in the final quarter of 2016, while the wider UK economy experienced strong growth; notes that business confidence in Scotland is lower than in any other part of the UK; further notes commentary from the Fraser of Allander Institute that it is hard to argue that Scotland’s weaker economic performance can be explained by the outcome of the EU referendum; recognises that recent policies of the Scottish Government, including on income tax, business rates, the large business supplement and the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax will further undermine growth; considers that in prioritising its aim of separation from the UK above all else, the Scottish Government has neglected and mismanaged the economy; further considers that the threat of a second referendum is causing further economic damage, and therefore calls on the Scottish Government to set aside its campaign for a second referendum and take urgent action on the economy instead.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

The Conservatives’ motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S5M-05172.3) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament
158 words removed by S5M-05172.3notes with concern that the Scottish economy contracted in the final quarter of 2016, while the wider UK economy experienced strong growth; notes that business confidence in Scotland is lower than in any other part of the UK; further notes commentary from the Fraser of Allander Institute that it is hard to argue that Scotland’s weaker economic performance can be explained by the outcome of the EU referendum; recognises that recent policies of the Scottish Government, including on income tax, business rates, the large business supplement and the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax will further undermine growth; considers that in prioritising its aim of separation from the UK above all else, the Scottish Government has neglected and mismanaged the economy; further considers that the threat of a second referendum is causing further economic damage, and therefore calls on the Scottish Government to set aside its campaign for a second referendum and take urgent action on the economy instead.
S5M-05172.3 SNP recognises the strength of the Scottish economy, with unemployment now lower than in the UK as a whole, productivity growing four times faster in Scotland than the UK, and the number of people in employment up by 45,000 since 2008, with the number of registered businesses having grown by 15% since 2007 to an all-time high; notes that most powers over the economy are reserved to the UK Government; acknowledges the resilience of the Scottish economy in the face of the slowdown in the oil and gas sector and welcomes the measures that the Scottish Government is taking, including the Energy Jobs Taskforce and the Decommissioning Challenge Fund; further acknowledges the wider measures that it is taking to grow the Scottish economy, including investment in transport and digital infrastructure and financial support for private sector business investment through the Scottish Growth Scheme, and believes that the main risk facing Scottish households and companies is the UK Government’s plans to adopt a hard Brexit, against the wishes of the Scottish people, impacting negatively on business growth and leading to skills shortages, which will in turn reduce employment, investment and public spending across the country.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S5M-05172.3 SNP Keith Brown Agreed vote, 62–55
  2. S5M-05172.1 Labour Jackie Baillie Fell (worked out by this site: the Presiding Officer announced it would fall if another amendment was agreed, and that one was)
  3. S5M-05172.2 Liberal Democrat Mike Rumbles Fell (worked out by this site: the Presiding Officer announced it would fall if another amendment was agreed, and that one was)
  4. S5M-05172.4 Green Patrick Harvie Fell (worked out by this site: the Presiding Officer announced it would fall if another amendment was agreed, and that one was)

Signatures by party

2 MSPs besides the lodger · 0 from other parties
Con 2

Party on the day each MSP signed. Signing a motion is voluntary and not whipped. Who signs whose motions

Vote

1 division
  1. 19 Apr 2017
    Scotland's Economy
    S5M-05172as amended by SNP
    Carried
    62 for, 55 against

Amendments

4
  1. Scotland's Economy
    Jackie Baillie Lab Lodged 18 Apr 2017
    No recorded vote
  2. Scotland's Economy
    Mike Rumbles LD Lodged 18 Apr 2017
    No recorded vote
  3. Scotland's Economy
    Keith Brown SNP Lodged 18 Apr 2017
    Carried
    62 for, 55 against
  4. Scotland's Economy
    Patrick Harvie Green Lodged 18 Apr 2017
    No recorded vote

Supporters

2 MSPs

Con 2

Show all 2 supporters by party

Con 2

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

3 contributions mention S5M-05172
  1. 19 Apr 2017
    Scotland’s Economy
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-05172, in the name of Murdo Fraser, on Scotland’s economy. 14:41

  2. 19 Apr 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    There are up to seven questions to be put as a result of today’s business. I remind members that if the amendment in the name of Keith Brown is agreed to, all the other amendments will fall. The first question is, that amendment S5M-05172.…

  3. 19 Apr 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    All the other amendments are therefore pre-empted, so the next question is, that motion S5M-05172, in the name of Murdo Fraser, on Scotland’s economy, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.